Boosting patience for inter-generational poverty reduction
How to cite
Thibaud, Juliette. 2019. "Boosting patience for inter-generational poverty reduction." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004387. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4387-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This document presents the pre-analysis plan of a randomized control trial experiment that has been conducted in Salima district of Malawi. The intervention has been completed, but the follow-up data collection has not started.
This project aims at measuring the impact of interventions designed to increase patience in mothers on investments in children. It randomly varies the content of those trainings to design an optimal policy to increase investments in children. In one treatment arm the training encourages mothers to be more patient when it comes to their own wealth and consumption; in another, the mothers are encouraged to be more patient when they make decisions relating to their children. It then assesses which type of intervention is more effective in increasing investments in children, depending on the mothers' relative discounting of their and their children's consumption.
The attached pre-analysis plan outlines the theoretical model, the experimental design, the outcome variables and the econometric methods I will use to assess the effectiveness of the trainings.
Intervention
Investments in children are low in developing countries, in spite of high returns. I propose an RCT to test whether training designed to increase mothers' future-orientation can be an effective way to boost investments in children. In addition, I study whether the focus of those trainings matter depending on the shape of the mother's baseline time-preferences.
Indeed, a companion paper (Lichand and Thibaud, 2018) has documented that a large fraction of parents do not discount their future consumption to the same extent as that of their children. Parents who are more patient for their children than for themselves tend to plan to be more generous towards their children in the future and to reallocate this planned consumption towards themselves when the time comes to execute those plans. We call those respondents parent-biased. In theory, the most effective way to increase investments in children for those parent-biased subjects is to increase the discount factor they apply to their own future consumption. Increasing the discount factor they apply to their child's consumption would lead them to make more ambitious plans for their children's future but would not help them stick to those plans.
I present here an RCT designed to test the following research questions:
1- Can training interventions aiming at developing future-orientation in mothers be effective to boost investments in children?
2- If mothers are parent-biased are the training interventions more effective when they focus on increasing the mothers' own discount factor?
In collaboration with a Malawian NGO, Student Driven Solutions (SDS), I have developed two sets of trainings that were randomly assigned to villages. The first set of workshops aimed at increasing patience and decreasing present-bias when making decisions involving one's own consumption(``Treatment 1''), the second one at increasing patience and decreasing present-bias when making decisions involving one's child consumption (``Treatment 2''). Both sets of trainings are inspired by the protocol of previously evaluated interventions who have been successful in shaping intertemporal preferences and by SDS' female empowerment workshops. SDS translated the material, recruited and trained the trainers. The intervention was monitored through random spot checks.
A subset of ``Control'' and ``Treatment 1'' villages received leaflets containing information about returns to investments in children, to control for the potential priming effect of ``Treatment 2''. Each treatment was composed of a set of eight two-hours trainings. In treatment villages, 30 participants were invited to attend the trainings, which were held approximately twice a week.
Experimental design
Two stage randomization:
At the village level, villages are allocated to three treatment arms:
-Control
-Treatment 1: received 8 2-hour long workshops focusing on inter-temporal decisions involving the mother's own consumption
-Treatment 2: received 8 2-hour long workshops focusing on inter-temporal decisions involving the child's consumption
At the individual level, respondents were then assigned to either receive additional information about returns to investments in children or no additional information.
This experiment was conducted in 80 villages of Dedza district in Malawi, with 2,400 participants. Households were eligible if both parents lived at home, if they had at least one child aged between 3 and 12 years old and if no one in the household was allergic to peanuts.
At baseline, if multiple children were present, one child was randomly selected to be the focus of the data collection.
At endline, if multiple children enrolled in primary school were present, one child was randomly selected to participate in the data collection. If no children enrolled in primary school was present in the household, the questionnaire focused on the child selected at baseline.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.