Empowering Staff to Enhance oral language in the early years
How to cite
Law, James; Dockrell, Julie; Mathers, Sandra. 2019. "Empowering Staff to Enhance oral language in the early years." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004379. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4379-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Developing children’s oral language skills has been the focus of research and policy for a number of years. Social disadvantage is closely associated with language delay and language delay impacts on social emotional and behavioural development and the ability of children to access the curriculum. The extent of poor oral language skills in the population and the significant impact that this has on children’s long term outcomes points to the need for a systematic approach to the challenge at both universal and targeted levels of intervention.There are currently a number of oral language interventions in the public domain both within the UK and more widely, the majority of which are targetedselecting subgroups of children within schools and classes who have been identified as ‘at risk’. By contrast this trial evaluates a universal intervention (Talking Time http://www.stass.co.uk/publications/talking-time) focusing on children at most risk of experiencing poor language trajectories, comparing their performance in language development to those children in nursery classes experiencing business as usual. The participants in this study are attending nurseries in the most socially disadvantaged areas in London and the north east of England. All children in the study will be between three and four years years of age. The nurseries will then be randomised to a treatment and a business as usual arm. The treatment arm will consist of a manualised intervention, Talking Time, which targets a range of oral language skills and provides staff with tailored support about talking with children.
Unlike other interventions which focus on targeted language support, Talking Time was devised as a universal approach which aims to support language learning for all children in the classroom by embedding the activities within the day to day running of the settings and supporting staff to develop ways of talking with children. Effectively through manualised activities staff are scaffolded in using different materials and foci to support children’s language learning. This is particularly important in areas of social disadvantage where both the children’s oral language is less well developed and the input they are reported to receive in early years settings is more impoverished.
For educational settings a strength of Talking Time is that the activities are consistent with the early years curriculum and training of staff in effective ways to talk with children will, in theory, generalize to the setting more widely. Thereby benefitting the children who experience Talking Time and also increasing work force capacity. We explicitly test this hypothesis, unlike in other studies which focus on targeted interventions, by including setting measures and staff questionnaires.
The intervention has been found to be effective in a small trial in inner London and will be scaled up in this study and enhanced to include professional development to support adult-child oral language interactions within the activities and across the settings. The primary outcomes are changes in the children’s language skills and the language-learning environment of the classroom. Social emotional development and staff knowledge are examined as secondary outcomes. The effects of child and setting factors will also be included in the analysis to capture barriers to implementation.
Intervention
Intervention
Talking Time is an oral language intervention with, as a primary outcome, the language and communication development of preschool children. In this study it is delivered by appropriately trained educational professionals who have received specific professional development (PD) from the research team. There is also strong evidence to suggest that oral language skills impact on social, emotional development (SED) and so we examine this possibility by including a measure of SED as a secondary outcome.
The Talking Time arm of the study will be compared with a "Business as usual" arm. It is predicted that there will be no differential impacts on the non-targeted skills (non-verbal ability and phonology).
The intervention will run from January to May 2022.
Intervention Content: The manualised component of the intervention will be based on Talking Time. Three main activities will be included in the trial:
1. Word Play involves a series of dramatic activities and games using target vocabulary.
2. Story Conversations supports children in talking about the pictures in a book to draw inferences using language and to develop complex vocabulary and grammar.
3. The Hexagon Game provides children with a visual stimulus to support the construction of personal oral narratives.
Acting out and Story talk will be implemented over the full intervention period. The Hexagon game, which emphasises narrative language, will be added to the range of activities in week 8 of the intervention period (as per original protocol).
The PD element of the trial will include three components:
1. Materials and training to prepare practitioners to use the intervention activities and materials, and make the language-learning principles behind them explicit. TT already includes training guidance and videos of staff carrying out the activities and this will serve as the starting point, supplemented by additional DVD footage to be developed and piloted.
2. Support sessions from mentors to provide feedback on TT practice, with a focus on recognition and acknowledgement of specific language supporting behaviours, with the aim of increasing both teachers’ understanding of the principles behind these behaviours and the likelihood that they will apply them within their practice with other activities.
3. In addition to mentor-supported analysis of practice, teachers will also be encouraged to discuss and share practice with each other, to build a strong "community of practice" using the TT intervention.
Delivery: In the autumn term (2021) all classes will be provided with a whole school CPD session on the impact of early oral language delivered by the PIs. This session will also outline the assessment measures that will be used in the classes. The intervention group will receive a further three delivery sessions (one covering each of the three activities and associated principles) and will be provided with exemplar materials to support the activities. Training will be provided by independent appropriately qualified trainers.
Posttest data will be collected in the summer term (2022) on completion of intervention. This provides the necessary time gap to conform with test restrictions for the standardised measures.
End of intervention:
To acknowledge their involvement all participating schools will be given story books following successful collection of the follow-up data. Following the post-test data collection BAU classes will be provided with the intervention materials and the option of a training session by both the PI or CoIs. A final interactive conference will be held for all participating schools in the north and the south.
Experimental design
The overall aim of the study is to ascertain whether, in areas of disadvantage, training staff to use a manualised intervention in combination with PD about language development improves children’s oral language skills in comparison with business-as-usual (BAU); and whether it can impact on overall quality of the language-learning environment beyond the intervention sessions themselves.
The project started in July 2021, nurseries were identified in June/July 2021. Parental consent was gained in September/October 2021. Data collection will run from October 2021 to December 2021. Initial training sessions will start in December 2021. The intervention and mentoring will run in the Spring term of 2022 (January to May). The children will be retested in the summer term of 2022. The data analysis, report writing and dissemination will take place between July and December 2022.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.