The ``Fake News'' Effect: Experimentally Identifying Motivated Reasoning Using Trust in News
How to cite
Thaler, Michael. 2020. "The ``Fake News'' Effect: Experimentally Identifying Motivated Reasoning Using Trust in News." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004339. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4339-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Motivated reasoning posits that people distort how they process information in the direction of beliefs they find attractive. This paper creates a novel experimental design to identify motivated reasoning from Bayesian updating when people have preconceived beliefs. It analyzes how subjects assess the veracity of information sources that tell them the median of their belief distribution is too high or too low. Bayesians would infer nothing about the source veracity, but motivated beliefs are evoked. Results support politically-motivated reasoning about immigration, income mobility, crime, racial discrimination, gender, climate change, and gun laws. Motivated reasoning helps explain belief biases, polarization, and overprecision.
Intervention
The theory of motivated reasoning posits that people distort how they process information in the direction of beliefs they find attractive. This experiment uses a new design that aims to disentangle motivated reasoning from Bayesian inference when people enter into the experiment with preconceived beliefs. It analyzes how subjects assess the veracity of information sources that tell them the median of their belief distribution is too high or too low. In this environment, Bayesians would infer nothing about the source veracity, but motivated beliefs are evoked. I test motivated reasoning on ten different topics, and relate the bias to current belief biases, belief polarization, trust in "Fake News," overprecision, and overconfidence.
Experimental design
Identifying Motivated Reasoning:
The main test of this in the experiment involves three steps. See the analysis plan for more details.
1. Beliefs: Subjects are asked to guess the answers to questions like the refugee one above. Importantly, they are asked and incentivized to guess their median belief (i.e. such that find it equally likely for the answer to be above or below their guess). They are also asked and incentivized for their interquartile range.
2. News: Subjects receive a binary message from one of two news sources: True News and Fake News. The message from True News is always correct, and the message from Fake News is always incorrect. The probability of either source is 1/2 and iid across questions. This is the main (within-subject) treatment variation.
The message says either "The answer is greater than your previous guess of [previous guess]." or "The answer is less than your previous guess of [previous guess]." Note that the message space is different for each subject since subjects have different priors. These customized messages are designed so that they have the same subjective likelihood of occurring.
3. Assessment: After receiving the message, subjects assess the probability that the source was True News on a scale from 0/10 to 10/10 and are incentivized to state their true belief. This is the main outcome measure. The page is identical to the beliefs page but the guess boxes are replaced with assessment choices. The effect of variation in news on veracity assessments is the primary outcome variable for identifying motivated reasoning.
The general point of this setup is that subjects receive messages that compare the answer to their median, so they should not rationally update their assessment based on the message. Directionally different assessments are difficult to reconcile with Bayesian updating; they are also difficult to reconcile with general misweighting of priors (since the prior of source is fixed at 1/2) or likelihoods (each message is equally likely, so the message is uninformative about source veracity). However, these deviations can be explained by motivated reasoning.
The most direct test is to hypothesize what people are motivated to believe, and compare their assessments on "Pro-Motive" news and "Anti-Motive" news. If Pro-Motive news is trusted more than Anti-Motive news, this indicates that motivated reasoning is likely with these hypothesized motives is at play.
Interacting this assessment gap with a treatment provides an estimate for the effect of the treatment on the degree of the motivated reasoning bias. If this gap is positive, and the interaction of news type (Pro/Anti-Motive) and treatment is negative, then the treatment likely is effective in debiasing subjects.
Subjects see 14 rounds of questions; on politicized and performance-related topics, the random binary messages are coded as Pro-Motive or Anti-Motive using a hypothesized table of motives.
Between-subject randomizations:
Given prior / not given prior:
1/3 of subjects will be told that there is a 50% chance of seeing True News and a 50% chance of seeing Fake News, while the other 2/3 will not be given this prior.
Willingness-to-pay (WTP) / Second guessing (SG):
WTP: Half of subjects will have their WTP for a message elicited using a Becker-DeGroot-Marschak procedure in Round 12. They will either see a message as in previous rounds (if their WTP is above the random number), or a black bar over the message.
SG: The other half of subjects will be asked to guess the answer to the original question again after seeing the message.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.