Uncovering sophisticated discrimination with the help of credence goods markups

How to cite

Neururer, Daniel. 2019. "Uncovering sophisticated discrimination with the help of credence goods markups." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004328. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4328-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Daniel Neururer*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004328
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4328-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-07-10 – 2018-10-19
Countries
Turkey (City of Antalya)
JEL codes
C93, D82, J15
Secondary IDs
https://aspredicted.org (#12363)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4328

Abstract

We present the results of a pre-registered natural field experiment designed to uncover a sophisticated form of discrimination against an immigrant minority in a market for credence goods. For this purpose, we introduce two markups: (i) the credence goods markup defined as the difference between the price paid by the same person for an ordinary service and an otherwise equivalent credence goods service; and (ii) the discriminatory markup defined as the difference between the price paid by a member of an immigrant minority group and the price paid by a member of the majority group for the same kind of service. We document the existence of a large credence goods markup of about 40%, on average. Moreover, we find a sizeable discriminatory markup for the credence goods service but no discriminatory markup for the ordinary service. The results of an ex-post survey suggest that this sophisticated form of discrimination is mainly due to the prejudicial behavior of sellers belonging to an established local ethnic minority group towards buyers belonging to a low-status immigrant ethnic minority group.

Intervention

We will use a mystery shopper approach, where research assistants enter cell phone repair shops with a non-functioning phone and ask for a repair. The mystery shoppers are either locals (Turkish) or non-local (Syrian), and either know (ordinary) or do not know (credence) the problem with the phone. The participants (i.e. the cell phone repair shops) are thus assigned to four treatments:

• ordinary_local: ordinary service market and local customer
• credence_local: credence goods market and local customer
• ordinary_non-local: ordinary service market and non-local (Syrian) customer
• credence non-local: credence goods market and non-local (Syrian) customer

Experimental design

We plan to conduct a natural field experiment in the Turkish market for cell phone repairs to address the following research questions: (i) To what extend are non-locals discriminated against in an ordinary service market? (ii) To what extend are non-locals discriminated against in a credence goods market? (iii) How large is the ‘credence markup’ (that is, the price difference between a service without credence goods character and the same service with credence goods character) in general? (iv) Is there a difference in the credence markup for non-locals and local customers?

• By comparing the average repair price in the treatment ordinary_local to the average repair price in the treatment ordinary_non-local we address research question (i).
• By comparing the average repair price in the treatment credence_local to the average repair price in the treatment credence_non-local we address research question (ii).
• By comparing the average repair price in the treatment ordinary_local to the average repair price in the treatment credence_local we address research question (iii).
• By comparing the difference of average repair prices between ordinary_local and credence_local to the difference of average repair prices between ordinary_non-local and credence_non-local we address research question (iv).

In addition to the data on repair prices we also plan to collect data on characteristics and attitudes of repair shops via a questionnaire to be filled out by our mystery shoppers and a survey to be completed by the shop owners.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was done by the field coordinator with the help of a computer.
Randomization unit
We used a random number generator to match the individual shops to our four treatments (described above) and finally to the undercover shoppers.
Clusters
In total, we plan to collect 200 observations. We will strive to select the sample in such a way that the person behind the counter is Turkish (native). However, we will make sure to document this and control for it if it happens that several shop owners are non-native.
Observations
In total, we plan to collect 200 observations. We will strive to select the sample in such a way that the person behind the counter is Turkish (native). However, we will make sure to document this and control for it if it happens that several shop owners are non-native.
Arms
We plan to collect 50 observations per treatment.
Primary outcomes
The main dependent variable is the average repair price in each treatment group.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords