The Limits of Startup Strategy

How to cite

Gong, Sara; Guzman, Jorge. 2019. "The Limits of Startup Strategy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004302. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4302-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sara Gong* , Jorge Guzman

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004302
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4302-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-07-16 – 2019-09-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
L26, D03, D9, D21, D22
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4302

Abstract

In contrast to the traditional model of a firm, a startup is fundamentally inseparable from its founder. This experiment aims to demonstrate that the strategic decisions of startups are determined by a tradeoff between the conflicting professional and personal motivations of their founders. We use priming to explore how the relative importance of entrepreneurial identity affects the behavior of founders who face a strategic choice that will increase startup growth at a personal cost.

Intervention

This study examines how the profit-maximizing strategic decisions of growth-driven startups are constrained by the personal motivations of their utility-maximizing founders. In a novel experimental approach integrating economics, psychology, and strategy, we apply priming techniques to study entrepreneurial decision-making. We prime the "entrepreneurial identity" of startup founders and then study how a variation in identity salience influences their willingness to make certain choices in hypothetical scenarios.

Experimental design

This study examines how the profit-maximizing strategic decisions of growth-driven startups are constrained by the personal motivations of their utility-maximizing founders. In a novel experimental approach integrating economics, psychology, and strategy, we apply priming techniques to study entrepreneurial decision-making. We prime the "entrepreneurial identity" of startup founders and then study how a variation in identity salience influences their willingness to make certain choices in hypothetical scenarios.

Design details

Randomization method
We performed block randomization according to the background characteristics of subjects collected at registration. We partitioned the covariate space using the following variables: startup financing stage, startup value, startup location, satisfaction with local resources, satisfaction with local quality of life, number of founders, number of employees, having children, marital status, having a second job, age, and gender. We then grouped similar subjects together, in backwards order of the listed variables, until each block had at least 4 subjects, as recommended by Athey and Imbens (2016), resulting in 18 total blocks. Finally, we performed a balance test (attached) to ensure that treatment and control group means were not significantly different among every covariate.
Randomization unit
Individual.
Clusters
The experiment is run at the individual level and not clustered.
Observations
We recruited class participants over the course of three weeks. Our total enrollment was 278, and after dropping non-entrepreneurs and minors, we had a subject pool of self-identified entrepreneurs with a startup, to whom we will send out the priming and control surveys. We been able to recruit 121 entrepreneurs for our experiment.
Arms
61 treated, 60 control.
Primary outcomes
There are two key outcome variables of interest: entrepreneurs' score on the word-choice test describing their entrepreneurial identity dominance (entrep_score), and entrepreneurs' stated willingness to take hypothetical strategic decisions (strat_score). We measure entrep_score by calculating the number of entrepreneurial words a subject selects from the ten word pairs, divided by ten, so that entrep_score is between 0 and 1. We measure strat_score as the average of a subject's responses to the hypothetical scenario questions, where each scenario is a 5-point Likert item, with possible responses as "Very Unlikely" (1), "Unlikely" (2), "Neutral" (3), "Likely" (4), and "Very Likely" (5). In our analysis, we study these variables in several ways: (a) First, we run simple regressions showing whether treatment (a binary variable representing those that are primed) predicts a higher entrep_score and/or strat_score. (b) We also study the distribution of these effects by using machine learning methods that allow us to recover the shape of the effects based on observables. In particular, we apply the honest tree method of Athey and Wagner (2015) and the sorted effects method of Chernozukhov et al (2018). (c) Finally, we study how the difference in strat_score is determined by differences in the underlying characteristics of subjects. To do so, we run interaction models where we interact our treatment with pre-treatment characteristics and then estimate flexible functions of pre-treatment characteristics with the estimated effects from (b).
Secondary outcomes
We perform the analysis described in "Primary Outcomes" independently on each hypothetical scenario. We do not have any priors at this moment on how their shape or magnitudes will be different. We also add the following analyses: (a) Changing our main outcome variable to a binary measure that is equal to 1 if the subjects choose "Likely" or "Very Likely" and 0 otherwise to study LPM, and logit specifications on the odds (or probability change) of being likely choose. (b) The impact of being more 'entrepreneurial' (as defined by entrep_score) on strat_score as well as the impact of treatment across this distribution.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords