Strategic Disclosure and Startup Funding

How to cite

Guzman, Jorge; Yu, Sandy; Chiles, Bennett. 2019. "Strategic Disclosure and Startup Funding." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004291. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4291-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jorge Guzman* , Sandy Yu , Bennett Chiles

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004291
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4291-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-10-29 – 2020-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
L26, G24
Secondary IDs
Columbia IRB: AAAS5167; UMN IRB: STUDY00007210
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4291

Abstract

This project studies the extent to which withholding information about a startup can influence the evaluation of and financing of startups. To do so, we perform two randomized control trials asking two distinct populations of investment related individuals to assess the value of a startup by looking at two investment decks. We include four treatment arms, where we (a) withhold information about the team background, (b) withhold information about team financing, (c) include both pieces of information, or (d) omit both pieces of information. We then assess, as our primary outcome, the extent to which subjects differentially evaluate a startup based on this absence of information. As a secondary outcome, we consider the total time spent on the remaining slides and the ways in which subjects use other information to assess startup quality, using a slide-tracking software (DocSend) that allows us to see how many seconds each individual spends in each slide.

Intervention

This project studies the extent to which withholding information about a startup can influence the evaluation of and financing of startups. To do so, we perform two randomized control trials asking two distinct populations of investment related individuals to assess the value of a startup by looking at two investment decks. We include four treatment arms, where we (a) withhold information about the team background, (b) withhold information about team financing, (c) include both pieces of information, or (d) omit both pieces of information. We then assess, as our primary outcome, the extent to which subjects differentially evaluate a startup based on this absence of information. As a secondary outcome, we consider the total time spent on the remaining slides and the ways in which subjects use other information to assess startup quality, using a slide-tracking software (DocSend) that allows us to see how many seconds each individual spends in each slide.

Experimental design

This project studies the extent to which withholding information about a startup can influence the evaluation of and financing of startups. To do so, we perform two randomized control trials asking two distinct populations of investment related individuals to assess the value of a startup by looking at two investment decks. We include four treatment arms, where we (a) withhold information about the team background, (b) withhold information about team financing, (c) include both pieces of information, or (d) omit both pieces of information. We then assess, as our primary outcome, the extent to which subjects differentially evaluate a startup based on this absence of information. As a secondary outcome, we consider the total time spent on the slides and the ways in which subjects use other information to assess startup quality, using a slide-tracking software (DocSend) that allows us to see how many seconds each individual spends in each slide.

Design details

Randomization method
Full randomization (randomly assigned through Qualtrics).
Randomization unit
Person-deck level (each participant will receive two pitch decks to evaluate; each of these two pitch decks will be randomly assigned).
Clusters
We aim to collect responses from at least 150 participants (though it is possible that we will obtain more responses than this; it is also possible that we are not able to obtain our target). We are soliciting (via email) 368 MBA students that are members of the Columbia Business School Venture Capital club, and will continue to collect responses for at least two weeks; if we have at least 150 survey responses by the end of this two weeks, we will cease collection at that point. If we have fewer than 150 survey responses at the two-week mark, we will continue collecting responses for another week. We will end our collection after three weeks even if we have fewer than 150 responses.
Observations
We aim to collect at least 300 slide deck evaluations (150 participants x 2 slide decks each). See details above with regard to our planned procedure for survey administration. We will collect for two weeks. If we have less than 100 subjects, we will do another week with an additonal email request. Email once now, and once next week, and one 24 hours before the survey closes.
Arms
40% of randomly assigned slide decks will contain both team and funding information 40% of randomly assigned slide decks will contain team details but NO funding information 10% of randomly assigned slide decks will contain funding information but NO team details 10% of randomly assigned slide decks will omit both team details and funding information
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcomes are survey measures of interest in the company... We will focus on the answer to the following three questions: 1. What is your preliminary assessment of what this company is worth at its current stage? 2. Suppose you were a VC investor. Please select one option below that best describes your assessment of this company. 3. I believe that this company will survive more than 3 years. As robustness, we will also consider the following two questions: 1. I believe that this company will be successful in raising additional funds from VC and/or angel investors. 2. I believe that this company will achieve a successful equity outcome such as an IPO or acquisition.
Secondary outcomes
We will use time spent in other slides as tracked by DocSend to assess what other pieces of information do evaluators choose to spend time in. We will also conduct exploratory analysis on potential heterogeneity of treatment effects (with respect to both team/firm characteristics and evaluator characteristics).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords