Firm Expectations and Price-Setting
How to cite
Perez-Truglia, Ricardo; Giaccobasso, Matias; Kanz, Martin. 2021. "Firm Expectations and Price-Setting." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004289. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4289-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This experiment studies the effect of macroeconomic expectations on the business decisions of small enterprises. More precisely, we study: (i) whether small businesses form accurate expectations about important macroeconomic indicators such as the foreign exchange rate and inflation rate; and (ii) how changes in those macroeconomic expectations affect the actual day-to-day business decisions, such as price-setting or inventory holdings, among others. We designed a survey that allows us to measure the expectations of firms selling their products through one large online retailer in India. Firms that participate in the survey are assigned to a treatment or to a control group. The treatment group receives information about one macroeconomic indicator; either an official forecast of the expected inflation in the next 12 months or the forecasted exchange rate. The control group does not receive any information. We use the rich administrative records of the firm to measure the effects of the information on actual, real-time, pricing decisions.
Intervention
We study firms that sell their products through an online retail platform in India. We invited around 20,000 firms that were active in the platform in the months before the experiment. Within the survey, we conduct an information-provision experiment. We elicit beliefs on, and provide information about, two topics:
(1) the expected nominal exchange rate in the next 12 months.
(2) the expected inflation rate in the next 12 months.
The goal is to measure how the macroeconomic information included in the survey affected firms' day-to-day decisions.
The intervention was conducted between May 2019 and March 2020. However, due to COVID, the process of acquiring the administrative records was delayed and as of the time of this writing, to the extent that the COVID situation permits, we are in the process of acquiring the administrative data. Thus, at the time of this registration, we have not analyzed the effects on pricing decisions yet.
Experimental design
We invited around 20,000 firms that sell their products through an online retailer to answer an online survey. Because of the high turnover rate in this type of platform, we selected firms with recent online activity.
Invitations were distributed using a pop-up window that was shown whenever a seller logged in to his/her profile. To increase the response rate, the online platform offered a monetary incentive (i.e., a discount to be used in online purchases on the website) for users that completed the survey. To link the survey responses to the administrative records, we created unique survey links for each seller.
In the survey, we elicit beliefs on and provide information about, two topics
(1) the expected nominal exchange rate in the next 12 months.
(2) the expected inflation rate in the next 12 months.
The main intervention of our experiment is designed to create exogenous variation in macroeconomic expectations. We randomly divide the sample into three groups: two treatment groups and one control group. The first treatment group receives information about the expected nominal exchange rate 12 months in the future (forex-information group). The second group receives information about the expected inflation rate over the following 12 months (inflation-information group). The information provided to these groups is based on the Survey of Professional Forecasters on Macroeconomic Indicators published bi-monthly by the Reserve Bank of India. Finally, the third group receives no additional information (control group). To measure whether individuals incorporated the information provided to them into their beliefs, we measured their prior beliefs (i.e., before receiving the information) and their posterior beliefs (i.e., after receiving the information).
Note that we are interested in measuring the causal effect of beliefs. We are not interested in measuring the average treatment effect of providing a piece of information -- indeed, this average effect is probably zero, because the same piece of information may make some individuals update upwards and other individuals update downwards.
We will test predictions from simple macroeconomic models. According to these models, when firms expect the local currency to depreciate, they should raise the prices in anticipation. Likewise, when firms expect the inflation rate to increase, they should raise the prices in anticipation. We also expect to test some additional hypotheses informed by these macroeconomic models. For example, we can measure how exposed firms are to the foreign exchange rate (e.g., whether they export their products or import some of their inputs), and then test whether the firms which are more exposed care more about the exchange rate.
Note also that we will have the administrative data from before our intervention. As a result, we can use pre-treatment outcomes for falsification tests (i.e., did the information affect behavior before the information was provided?). We'll be able to use the pre-treatment outcomes as control variables, which will help us to increase power. The pre-treatment outcomes may also be useful for heterogeneity analysis.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.