Saving water at Cape Town schools by using smart metering and behavioural change
How to cite
Visser, Martine. 2019. "Saving water at Cape Town schools by using smart metering and behavioural change." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004260. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4260-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The city of Cape Town suffered a severe water crisis in 2018. At the peak of the drought in South Africa’s Western Cape, a randomised control trial over four months at 105 schools investigated the impact of two behavioural interventions to encourage responsible water usage: feedback in the form of detailed and customised water usage data from smart meters, and an interschool competition. Difference-in-differences analysis showed that the interventions reduced water usage in these schools by 16 to 27%. The information feedback was found to be more effective in reducing night time water use, indicating better water usage by the staff, while the competition was found to be more effective during the day time, indicating better water usage by the pupils. The contrast highlights the way feedback signalling was understood differently by the two groups, with different effects on their assumption of responsibility. This example from Cape Town schools demonstrates the effectiveness of combining smart technologies with behavioural insights and nudges. It provides a model of water conservation interventions for sustainable cities.
Experimental design
A randomised control trial (RCT) was used to evaluate the impact of two behavioural interventions: (1) usage feedback and (2) an inter-school social comparison based on water usage in schools. After installation of smart water meters, all schools received a once-off leak detection and maintenance upgrade. Thereafter, the schools underwent a nine-week baseline period before treatments were applied.
This study contains a control group and two treatment groups:
Control group: Schools received smart meter installation, but no feedback on their usage.
Treatment group 1 (T1 - Feedback): Schools received feedback about their daily and weekly usage. Weekly usage reports were emailed and sent via text message to the principal and two additional staff members. Principals were encouraged to share this information with learners during weekly assemblies. In addition, schools received a pre-designed poster that could be updated with the latest water usage information on a weekly basis. The poster was put next to a school’s notice board with the intention of improving information transition from staff to pupils.
Treatment group 2 (T2 - Social comparison): Schools received the same feedback information as treatment group 1 along with comparative feedback on their water usage relative to other schools. The social comparison treatment consisted of a leader board of schools based on percentage water savings relative to the pre-intervention baseline. The leader board was updated weekly. As in T1, schools received a pre-designed poster on which usage information could be updated weekly.
Feedback reports were sent on Monday mornings on a weekly basis. Many of the schools did not have reliable internet access, thus treatment had to be applied through reports rather than through the use of an online portal in order to ensure equality of treatment across schools.
The schools entered the study in three waves with interventions starting on 15 April 2018, 3 June 2018 and 22 July 2018. This stepped approach to treatment implementation was necessary firstly because the severity of the drought made water saving a top priority and the City of Cape Town and corporate funders of the intervention wanted feedback reports as soon as possible, and secondly because installing the smart water meters and doing the maintenance work was a lengthy process.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.