The Effects of Child Care Quality and Attendance in a Developing Country

How to cite

Hojman, Andrés; Martínez, Sebastián. 2019. "The Effects of Child Care Quality and Attendance in a Developing Country." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004254. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4254-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Andrés Hojman* , Sebastián Martínez

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004254
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4254-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2018-11-15 – 2021-06-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4254

Abstract

This trial evaluates the effects of three different and policy relevant child care conditions on children’s outcomes: (i) attending with improved quality, (ii) attending with regular quality, and (iii) not attending.

The improved quality condition is based on an improvement package that was applied to some of the early childhood centers in Panama, and includes teacher training sessions and monitoring and supervision from the central level. It also includes additional resources and important improvements in infrastructure for some of the centers. The improvement package was randomly assigned across centers.

To have the possibility of evaluating the three treatment conditions, we chose preschool centers that were located at a walkable distance from each other, in which one had been assigned to the improvement package and the other was part of a control group. Then, we recruited families in the same geographical area, that had a child of the proper age, and that were interested in applying to a preschool center. A total of 1900 children were surveyed. All of the families were included on the application lists for the centers, and then a lottery in each center defined the assignment of the slots.

The experiment will allow us to identify the impact of the three different treatment conditions on the children, including pairwise comparisons of the counterfactual scenarios. Our main variables of interest are related to (i) child development, (ii) labor force participation of the members of the family, and (iii) quality of time at home.

Intervention

The improved quality condition is based on an improvement package that was applied to some of the early childhood centers in Panama, and includes teacher training sessions and monitoring and supervision from the central level. It also includes additional resources and important improvements in infrastructure for some of the centers. The improvement package was randomly assigned across centers.

The children in our baseline survey are two or three years old, and the centers take children up to the age of four, so they will be able to stay for one or two years, which will be the treatment exposure time. Children not receiving slots at the centers can find preschool education or child care in any outside option or can get one of the slots if the families getting the original offers reject them.

Experimental design

To have the possibility of evaluating the three treatment conditions, we chose preschool centers that were located at a walkable distance from each other, in which one had been assigned to the improvement package and the other was part of a control group. Then, we recruited families in the same geographical area, that had a child of the proper age, and that were interested in applying to a preschool center. A total of 1900 children were surveyed. All of the families were included on the application lists for the centers. For each center, each applicant child received a random priority and slots were offered in that order. That way, each child received a random priority in each of the two centers. We plan to use those random priorities as sources of exogenous variation in our analyses.

The experiment will allow us to identify the impact of the three different treatment conditions on the children, including pairwise comparisons of the counterfactual scenarios. Our main variables of interest are related to (i) child development, (ii) labor force participation of the members of the family, and (iii) quality of time at home.

Design details

Randomization method
The random priority numbers were constructed in an excel file, and then the slot offers and the waitlist priority were informed to the central administration offices. The child care center supervisors then called the families asking them if they wanted to matriculate. When a family rejected the slot, they continued to the next child in the wait list.
Randomization unit
Children
Clusters
41 centers
Observations
1900 children
Arms
For the child-level evaluation 486 children were offered slots in higher-quality preschools and 524 were offered slots in regular-quality preschool. The rest (around 890 children) are our control group.
Primary outcomes
• Child development, as measured by ASQ-III. Other instruments could be applied in the future, depending on budget constraints. • Quality of home environment, as measured by HOME • Parental and family labor market outcomes, as labor participation, type of occupation, having a formal job, wages and income
Secondary outcomes
• Body weight, height and BMI • Types, quality and intensity of care. There are several intermediate outcomes of interest in this category: who takes care of the child at each moment in time; what are the characteristics of the care and the caregiver, including educational level, alternative wage; and how the time of the child is allocated during the day. • Fees paid for formal and informal care by the parents

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords