Two carrots and no stick – the Nijmegen social assistance experiment

How to cite

Betkó, János; Gesthuizen, Maurice; Spierings, Niels; Scheepers, Peer. 2019. "Two carrots and no stick – the Nijmegen social assistance experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004250. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4250-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

János Betkó* , Maurice Gesthuizen , Niels Spierings , Peer Scheepers

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004250
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4250-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2017-10-01 – 2021-09-30
Countries
Netherlands (Nijmegen)
JEL codes
H53 Government expenditure and Welfare Programmes, I38 Government Policy – Provision and Effect of Welfare Programmes, D91 Role and Effects of Psychological, Emotional, Social, and Cognitive Factors on Decision Making, C93 Field experiments
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4250

Abstract

In the Netherlands, a number of municipalities got permission from the national government to experiment with the welfare system. The city of Nijmegen is one of these municipalities. In the regular welfare regime, the last safety net of the welfare state is social assistance: a means tested benefit for people who lack other income (for example for people who lose their job and whose unemployment benefits have ended, or refugees who are granted an official status). People who receive social assistance in the Netherlands are bound to strict obligations regarding reintegration in the labor market, and sanctions if they fail to live up to them. Under the experimental regime, social assistance recipients can be allowed to keep an amount of money, if they earn any in addition to their allowance. Further, the strict rules on reintegration can be loosened. The municipality created two combination treatments based on this, that differ substantially from the regular regime. The core difference is that the experimental treatments are based on giving recipients more autonomy and trust. This is expected to have a positive effect on labor market outcomes (work, part-time work, entrepreneurship), participation, health and well being.

Intervention

The municipality of Nijmegen chose for two combination treatments, in which a different approach to re-integration is coupled with the opportunity to earn extra money in addition to the social assistance payment. In the regular regime, people are allowed to keep 25% of the money they earn, up to a maximum of approximately 200 euro per month, for a maximum of six months during their entire social assistance spell. In the experimental treatment, participants are allowed to keep an extra during the entire duration of the experiment (22 months, from 1 December 2017 up to 1 October 2019), they can keep op to 50% of their earnings, up until the same maximum (approx. 200 euro).
1) The first treatment group is allowed to keep extra money from earnings. In addition, all obligations regarding reintegration are cancelled, as are the related fines for non-compliance. Obligations that are cancelled are for example a minimum amount of job applications per week, the obligation to accept any job offer and the obligation to dress in an appropriate way when looking for work. If they want to, participants are allowed to ask for assistance of the local government or the regional re-integration organization in the search for a job.
2) The second treatment group is allowed to keep extra money from earnings. In addition, a special re-integration trajectory has been designed for them. Participation in this trajectory is obligatory. All participants are divided in groups of 10-12 people, who receive a group coaching session every month, for the duration of the experiment. The personal goal of the treatment is set by the participants themselves, and can be either work, part-time work, entrepreneurship or voluntary work. The group coaching is designed to have participants first gain more insight in themselves (situation, wishes and possibilities), and only after that to give them more tools to present themselves (pitching, networking).
3) The third group is the control group. These people applied for the experiment, but were randomized in the group that gets the same treatment as all other people on social assistance.
4) Finally, all people who were eligible to participate but didn’t apply function as reference group on primary outcomes.

Experimental design

The experiment is a cooperation between the municipality of Nijmegen and Radboud Social Cultural Research. It started on December first 2017 and ends October first 2019. One group of participants entered the experiment December 2017, another wave entered April first 2018. All applicants have been randomly distributed over the three groups (two treatment and one control). The target population consists of people on social assistance, with some groups excluded. This are most notably people under 27, people who would reach their retirement age before the experiment would end, refugees who hadn’t received an official status yet, and people who already received an intensive re-integration treatment. Recruitment of participants has been done through letters, mails, social media, an animation video, personal contact, flyers, posters, newsletters, local media and meetings in different parts of the municipality. Data collection consists of registration data (from the municipality, the regional re-integration office and the national bureau of statistics), survey data (baseline, after 1 year, after 2 years and after 3 years, the last one being done a year after the experiment has ended), and qualitative data (interviews and focus groups with both participants, coaches and other people involved).

Design details

Randomization method
All participants have been given a random number between 0 and 1 by SPSS, where the lowest 1/3rd became group 1, the middle 1/3rd became group 2 and the upper 1/3rd became group 3 (control).
Randomization unit
Individual.
Clusters
0
Observations
348 welfare claimants.
Arms
Treatment 1 122 welfare claimants Treatment 2 119 welfare claimants Control 107 welfare claimants
Primary outcomes
The number of people moving from welfare to work, either through earning enough to end the welfare benefit or earning an income in addition to the welfare benefit.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes are health, experienced stress, well-being, participation, happiness, and trust.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords