SEWA Wage Insurance Experiment
How to cite
Malani, Anup; Miller, Grant; Miller, Morgen; Mahajan, Aprajit; Torgovitsky, Alex; Tebaldi, Pietro. 2019. "SEWA Wage Insurance Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004240. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4240-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We present the motivation, design and analysis plan for the SEWA Wage Insurance Experiment (SWIE). The SWIE is a randomized controlled trial examining the demand for and impacts of providing so-called "hospi-cash'' insurance that provides a per-diem indemnity payment while a beneficiary is hospitalized. We brand this a wage insurance product because SEWA intends it to cover lost wages due to hospitalization, even though it can cover other costs and consequences of hospitalization as money is fungible. The SWIE offers roughly 200 villages access to two hospi-cash policies. The SWIE randomizes the prices to which villages are offered access to these two plans. The SWIE has two methodological innovations. First, it identifies sharp non-parametric bounds on demand using the approach in Tebaldi et al. (2019). Second, we develop a new approach to experimental design in order to choose prices so as to minimize the width of these non-parametric bounds. The SWIE also contributes to our understanding of the value of indemnity health insurance policies. The SWIE examines impacts of prices on hospi-cash insurance and health care insurance uptake and the impact of prices and uptake of hospi-cash on hospi-cash insurance claims and health care utilization. The evidence on uptake also estimates demand for indemnity insurance. The SWIE also estimates adverse selection into this wage insurance. Finally, the experiment also examine whether the hospi-cash insurance product improves risk-sharing within treatment villages.
Intervention
We offer households the ability to purchase two hospi-cash policies at certain prices (i.e., premiums). The two policies differ in their coverage.
Experimental design
This study will include three pilot surveys, a baseline survey, and an endline survey approximately 18 months after the end of the baseline.
The village and household samples for this study were assembled in two steps. First, we selected 214 villages in Ahmedabad and Gandhinagar districts in Gujarat state. Of these 214 villages, 5 were assigned to a pilot 1 that we used to determine which two hospi-cash policies we would study, 9 were assigned to the pilots 2 and 3 that we used to determine the price conditions for the experiment in the main study. The remaining 200 villages were used for the main study.
Our inclusion criteria for households in the 3 pilot studies and the main study was that households have at least one SEWA member currently living there. (For example, the adult children of a SEWA member who no longer lives with them were ineligible to participate in the study.) While this criteria affects external validity, it provides a cohesive sample that already trusted SEWA and its financial services arm, VimoSEWA, and is thus likely to be cooperative with our study.
There were no exclusion criteria for pilot 1. For pilots 2 and 3 and the main study, however, we excluded members that were subscribed to VimoSEWA's existing hospi-cash policy. We excluded these members because a member who already has a hospi-cash policy is unlikely to purchase a second policy. Moreover, we are interested in demand for hospi-cash amongst those who do not already have it. We also excluded members below the age of 18 and above the age of 54 from pilots 2 and 3 and the main study, as the hospi-cash policy is not available to individuals outside this age band.
After the pilots, each of the 200 villages in the main study were randomly assigned villages to one of the four possible price-pairs for the two products offered. SEWA will also continue to offer it's standard suite of non-hospi-cash policies to SEWA households.
In advance of the start of marketing, we will conduct a baseline survey of sample households. After marketing, we will gather data from SEWA on which households purchased a hospi-cash policy and which one they purchased. We will also obtain SEWA claims data for all sample households that enroll in a hospi-cash plan. Approximately 18 months after the end of the baseline, we will conduct an endline.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.