Exploring Behavioral Biases in Contraceptive Decision-Making: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Urban Malawi
How to cite
Karra, Mahesh; Zhang, Kexin; Ngwira, Bagrey; Longwe, Abiba. 2019. "Exploring Behavioral Biases in Contraceptive Decision-Making: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Urban Malawi." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004194. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4194-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study seeks to investigate some of the behavioral mechanisms that play a role in contraceptive decision-making through a field experiment, in which we manipulate the specific architectural conditions under which women are counseled on family planning. The study population is married women of reproductive age who have a need for family planning in Lilongwe, Malawi. Our approach is motivated by evidence suggesting that women’s stated and realized preferences for contraception are likely to be both malleable and highly sensitive to a range of biases. To this end, we explore how key biases are characterized through a woman’s revealed preferences and decisions about a method. We test the following two hypotheses:
1. Women’s stated preferences for and choices of contraception are sensitive to the number of method choices that are presented to them, consistent with prior evidence on choice overload. Specifically, decision-making under the presence of too many choices may either be determined heuristically, in which choices over methods are driven by key method attributes (e.g. effectiveness in preventing pregnancy, incidence of side effects, etc.) or may be avoided altogether (decision deferral).
2. Giving women the choice whether or not to involve their husbands or partners as part of the counseling process is likely to affect 1) women’s decision-making around and choice of a contraceptive method; 2) the extent to which women are able to realize their preferences for family planning.
Intervention
All participants will receive a counseling session on contraceptive methods and family planning. Following receipt of counseling, women in all treatment arms (including the control arm) will be asked to reveal their preferred choice of method. Following this elicitation, women in all arms of the study will be offered the following package of services:
1. A free taxi ride to our partner family planning clinic in Lilongwe, the Good Health Kauma Clinic, which has been previously identified as a high quality family planning clinic that provides the full range of contraceptive methods.
2. A free consultation with a family planning service provider at the Good Health Kauma Clinic.
3. Free family planning services at the Good Health Kauma Clinic.
These services have already been tested and implemented in the field as part of a recently completed family planning study in Lilongwe (NHSRC Protocol No. 16/7/1628). To increase the salience of the offer, the package of services will be time-limited for one month following the counseling session. By offering the package of three services above, which together aim to reduce the barriers to accessing family planning services at our partner clinic, we will be able to elicit a measure of demand for family planning and will also be able to observe how a woman’s demand (her final choice of method) aligns with her initially stated preferences for family planning immediately following counseling.
A follow-up survey will be conducted one month following a woman’s counseling session. Outcome data that captures a woman’s preferences and decision-making around contraception will be collected at baseline survey, pre-counseling session, post-counseling session, and at every clinic visit. In situations where women do not show up at the clinic, our enumerators will make phone calls or home visits to conduct end-line surveys with the women and ask about their preferences and decision-making around contraception.
Experimental design
Participants taking part in this study will receive a survey will ask about their marriage, pregnancy status, fertility preferences, and views on family planning, maternal and child health, and reproductive health. Participants will then receive a second survey after two months at a local clinic, by phone, or at the participant’s home.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.