Hawthorne Effect in Economic Games

How to cite

Knuth, Melinda; Kee, Jennifer; Lahey, Joanna; Palma, Marco. 2019. "Hawthorne Effect in Economic Games." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004174. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4174-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Melinda Knuth* , Jennifer Kee , Joanna Lahey , Marco Palma

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004174
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4174-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2019-05-04 – 2019-11-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4174

Abstract

Within this study we investigate if there is a Hawthorne effect from using eye-trackers in laboratory experiments. We will be using commonly used economic games accompanied by eye-tracking equipment at Texas A&M University. The games to be used include the Trust (investment) game (Berg et al., 1995), Risk games: Holt and Laury Lottery Choice game (2002) and Eckel and Grossman (2012) Lottery Choice game, Public Goods game (Andreoni, 1995), Dictator game (Anderson et al., 2018), Ultimatum game (Anderson et al., 2011), and Double Auction (market) game (Smith, 1964). Texas A&M students will be contacted to be subjects through the university “bulkmail” system. When subjects arrive at the laboratory, they will sign a consent form and choose a numbered disk of out a box. This number corresponds with the eye-tracking station number that they will be seated at. Half the subjects will have the eye-tracking equipment calibrated to their eye movements and the other half the subjects will not have eye-tracking equipment calibrated to their eye movements (but the equipment will still be present). Before each game, the equipment will be calibrated, or recalibrated, to the subjects. Subjects will play games and once complete will answer demographic survey and debrief. Upon completion, subjects will be paid their earnings in private.

Intervention

Treatment group: Eye-tracking calibration and recalibration during common economic game play.
Control group: Eye-tracking equipment present but not powered on or calibrated to the subjects during common economic game play.

Experimental design

Treatment group: Half of the subjects will sign a consent for to have eye-tracking equipment calibrated to their eye movements. Once consented, they will be continuously reminded of the eye-tracking equipment presence by the experimenter through re-calibration of the equipment before each game.
Control group: The other half of the subject pool will sign a consent that excludes language consenting for the eye-tracking calibration because the equipment will not collect data from them. The equipment will be present in the room but will not be powered on or be calibrated to the subjects. They will not experience re-calibration before each game but will listen to the experimenters’ instructions for the same time duration that it takes the treatment group (eye-tracking group) to be re-calibrated.

Design details

Randomization method
Subjects choose station number to sit at by randomly picking number out of a box. Randomization done within games by z-tree program.
Randomization unit
Individual randomization: Once subjects have consented in the laboratory lobby, they will choose a station number of a box. This is a random number between 1-16 corresponding to the 16 station numbers within the laboratory that the subjects may be seated at.
Clusters
400 student subjects.
Observations
7,600 decisions
Arms
400
Primary outcomes
1. Subjects playing the Trust game will not experience the Hawthorne effect from eye-tracking. 2. Subjects playing the Holt and Laury lottery game will experience the Hawthorne effect from eye-tracking. 3. Subjects playing the Dictator game will experience the Hawthorne effect from eye-tracking. 4. Subjects playing the Ultimatum game will experience the Hawthorne effect from eye-tracking. 5. Subjects playing Public Goods game will experience the Hawthorne effect from eye-tracking. 6. Subjects playing the 7. Subjects playing cheating games will experience the Hawthorne effect from eye-tracking. 8. Subjects playing the Eckel and Grossman lottery game will not experience the Hawthorne effect from eye-tracking. 9. Subjects participating in a double auction will not experience the Hawthorne effect from eye-tracking.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords