Liquidity Affects Job Choice: Evidence from Teach For America
How to cite
Coffman, Lucas; Kessler, Judd B; Featherstone, Clayton R; Conlon, John J. 2019. "Liquidity Affects Job Choice: Evidence from Teach For America." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004168. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4168-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The main research question is whether many Americans lack the liquidity to accept a job offer. We test this by randomly varying the size of grants and loans in an existing transitional funding program provided to early career job applicants. The hypothesis is that even small increases in cash on hand -- in the form of grant or loan money -- will increase the likelihood of accepting the job. We implement the experiment with Teach For America, a teacher placement organization. The experiment takes place over three years with 7,295 admits to TFA who apply for and are eligible for all transitional funding. Transitional funding decisions are made in “batches”, about once per week from October through June. We randomize to treatment arms within each batch. In the first two years, the treatment arms provide modest increases in transitional funding by increasing either the grants or loans provided. The third year is a “self-replication” and stress test of the first two years of results. To self-replicate, for those who exhibited a treatment effect in the first two years (and those in similar, but slightly better financial shape), we maintain the same treatment assignments. To stress test the null results, for those who did not exhibit a treatment effect, we tripled the size of the main experimental variation. Across all three years, we find that for admits whose expected costs of moving exceed their estimated cash on hand, providing immediate financial assistance increases their odds of accepting their TFA offer. Further, we find no treatment effects, even for large financial assistance, when provided to admits whose cash-on-hand exceeds their expected costs. We measure “accepting the job” by whether or not the job applicant is working through Teach For America as of the first day of school on the first semester of their assignment.
Intervention
The experimental population is all of those admitted to TFA during the 2015--2016, 2016--2017, and 2017--2018 admissions cycles, who applied for transitional grant and loan (TGL) funding, and were eligible for grants according to TFA’s formula.
Applications to TFA and the TGL funding were done on a rolling basis, and treatment assignment was done in lockstep. TGL packages and randomization to treatment were calculated in “batches” of applicants, done roughly once per week.
In 2015--2016, admits were randomly assigned to treatments 1--3 below.
In 2016--2017, until March 15, 2016, admits were randomly assigned to treatments 1--3 below, and after March 15, 2016, admits were randomly assigned to treatments 1--4 below.
In 2017--2018, admits in the bottom quintile of TFA’s measure of “expected contribution” (see below) were assigned to treatments 1--4 below, and admits in the top four quintiles of “expected contribution” were assigned to treatments 1, 5, and 6 below.
All randomized assignment was done with equal probability for each potential treatment.
The full list of treatment groups is:
1. Control: The standard TFA TGL package based on the admit’s financials, less a uniform amount compared to the previous year to fund the experimental variation.
2. $600 Loan: $600 in extra loan money on top of the control grant and loan award
3. $600 Grant: $600 in extra grant money on top of the control grant and loan award
4. $1,200 Grant: $1,200 in extra grant money on top of the control grant and loan award
5. $1,800 Loan: $1,800 in extra loan money on top of the control grant and loan award
6. $1,800 Grant: $1,800 in extra grant money on top of the control grant and loan award
Experimental design
Across all three years, treatment assignment was done as explained in 22. Applicants were notified of their TGL funding package via email. Experimentally provided increases to funding were not mentioned. No other interaction with the admits was made until the post-experiment survey.
The data were analyzed after year two. Year three was an intentional self-replication attempt based on those results.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.