Does the support for behavioral policies depend on why they work? Representative evidence on the relevance of psychological mechanisms
How to cite
Fischer, Mira; Woessmann, Ludger; Grewenig, Elisabeth; Lergetporer, Philipp; Werner, Katharina. 2019. "Does the support for behavioral policies depend on why they work? Representative evidence on the relevance of psychological mechanisms." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004163. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4163-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In this project, we investigate whether people’s support of a behavioral policy depends on the psychological mechanism by which it affects behavior. We implement an online-survey experiment among a representative sample of adults aged 18 years and older in Germany. Each subject is randomly assigned to one of four experimental groups, and completes three consecutive stages. In stage 1 all subjects are asked whether they support training for the unemployed. In stage 2 all subjects are presented with a vignette of an unemployed individual, who is informed by letter that the Federal Employment Agency registered him for a training course and that he has two weeks to object to his registration, and is otherwise obliged to participate. Subjects also learn that he participates in the course. In treatment 1 no further information is added. Treatment 2 is identical to treatment one, except that subjects additionally learn that the unemployed individual did not read the letter and thus did not know that he could object to his registration. Treatment 3 is identical to treatment 1, except that subjects additionally learn that the unemployed individual believes that the course will help him to find a new job faster because the Federal Employment Agency registered him for the course. Treatment 4 is again identical to treatment 1, except that subjects additionally learn that the unemployed individual, because of the letter from the Federal Employment agency, feels pressured to participate in the course and does not dare to object to his registration. All subjects are then asked to report their level of agreement with respect to the described procedure. Stage 3 elicits subjects’ beliefs about whether the procedure (i) restricts the freedom of those that are unemployed, (ii) influences the beliefs about the effectiveness of the course for finding employment (iii) exerts social pressure on those that are unemployed and (iv) “makes the decision” for the unemployed who are indifferent.
Intervention
We investigate whether people’s support of a behavioral policy depends on the psychological mechanism by which it affects behavior. Subjects complete a questionnaire on (i) their support for further training for the unemployed (ii) their support for an automatic registration for further training for the unemployed with the possibility to opt out presented to them in a vignette, and (iii) their beliefs about the importance of different psychological mechanisms for the effectiveness of the behavioral policy. Depending on the treatment, subjects learn in the vignette that a unemployed individual participated in the training (i) with no further explanation given to the subjects, (ii) because he did not know that he could opt out, (iii) because he thought due to his registration that the training would help him to find a new job faster, or (iv) because he felt socially pressured to participate in the training.
The treatment variation allows us to study whether respondents’ beliefs about how a behavioral policy affects decision-making influences their support for this policy.
Experimental design
We conduct the experiment in a sample of 4,000 adults aged 18 years and older. The survey is conducted in cooperation with a renowned German survey institute, KANTAR Public. The recruitment and polling is managed by KANTAR Public, who collect the data via an online platform. That is, our participants answer the survey questions autonomously on their own digital devices. Randomization is carried out by KANTAR Public at the individual level, using a computer.
Our experiment is structured as follows:
Respondents will be randomly assigned (between subject) to treatment 1 (control), treatment 2 (unintentionality), treatment 3 (belief updating), or treatment 4 (social costs)
Treatment 1:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, no information on decision-making by the unemployed is given
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision to follow default
Treatment 2:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed did not know of possibility to opt out
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision to follow default
Treatment 3:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed interprets the default as containing positive information about the effectiveness of the default option
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision to follow default
Treatment 4:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed feels socially pressured by the default
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision to follow default
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.