On the motivational power of pride: a field study with participants in a road-running event.

How to cite

Milligan, Jessica; Toussaert, Severine. 2019. "On the motivational power of pride: a field study with participants in a road-running event.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004154. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4154-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jessica Milligan* , Severine Toussaert

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004154
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4154-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2018-12-03 – 2019-06-28
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D910 Micro-Based Behavioral Economics: Role and Effects of Psychological, Emotional, Social, and Cognitive Factors on Decision Making, Z2 Sports Economics
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4154

Abstract

Pride is a powerful motivational force, which often propels individuals to take on personal challenges and push beyond their limits. One context in which the demand for personal challenges manifests itself very clearly is participation in road-running events such as marathons, which have become increasingly popular over the recent years. We conduct a two-part online study with participants in a ten-mile race in Washington DC, which typically attracts 15,000 – 20,000 (mostly amateur) runners each year. We survey volunteer participants before and after the event in order to study their motivation to perform at their best during the race as well as the pride they derive from their achievement.

Of particular interest to us is the motivation that emerges from perceived threats to one's (self or social) image triggered by others' assessments. Consider Ben who was told by his dad that he should forget about applying to Ivy League schools and concentrate instead on schools ``at his level''. Or think about Carol whose colleagues think she does not have what it takes to be promoted. It is not difficult to think of examples where the desire to prove others wrong pushes people to perform beyond others' (and possibly, their own) expectations. Examples in a sports context abound. We investigate the power of this motivational force in the context of the ten-mile race.

In the pre-race survey (already conducted), 431 participants were asked to tell us about their time goal for the race and were challenged/encouraged to achieve it. Participants saw one of 6 different versions of the pre-race survey, which differed in whether we (i) expressed doubts about their ability to achieve their time goal; (ii) rewarded them for achieving their time goal (with either a $10 or a $25 gift card). The post-race survey collects data about participants’ satisfaction regarding their race performance and their valuation of several aspects of the event such as the race medal.

Intervention

For this study, we use a combination of several data sources, including a Pre and Post race survey which included an experimental treatment. In the Pre-race survey, runners were randomised into one of 4 different treatments, which differed in whether (i) we expressed doubt about their ability to meet their time goal in the race; (ii) we offered them monetary incentives for meeting their goal. We included a cross randomisation of the monetary incentives ($10 / $25).

The intervention is complete, but the data collection is not yet completed (final data collection will be in the end of June 2019).

The full details of the intervention, including details about the surveys together with other data sources, are in the Pre Analysis Plan.

Experimental design

We recruited 431 runners from a 10 mile race (over 17,000 runners in total) to take part in a Pre and Post Race Survey. As an incentive to sign up and complete both surveys, runners were informed they could win prizes. 407 runners in total finished both the Pre and the Post Race Survey.

In the Pre-race survey, runners were randomised into one of 4 different treatments, which differed in whether (i) we expressed doubt about their ability to meet their time goal in the race; (ii) we offered them monetary incentives for meeting their goal. The groups were Control, Money, Pride and Pride & Money. The monetary incentives in the Money and Pride & Money treatments were cross randomized to be either $10 or $25 sports clothing vouchers.

The choice of sample size was partly dictated by budget constraints (lottery prizes and payment of vouchers for those who met their goal) and by power calculations.

Full details are available to read in the Pre Analysis Plan.

Design details

Randomization method
In the Pre-race survey, randomization into the control group or one of the 3 treatment groups was done in Qualtrics; an equal number of survey participants was allocated into each group. Likewise, the incentive level for the Money and Pride & Money Treatments was also randomized into equal groups offered either $10 or $25 by Qualtrics.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
431 individuals (214 women and 217 men). More details on the recruitment is in the Pre-Analysis Plan. We wanted a total of 400 (100 in each treatment group) participants to complete the study, and anticipated some attrition between the Pre and Post race surveys, hence we over-recruited for the first survey.
Observations
431 individuals (for primary race performance variables, only Pre race survey data is needed).
Arms
Pre-race survey (413): Control: 108 individuals. Pride treatment: 108 individuals. Money Treatment: 109 individuals (54 with $10 incentive, 55 with $25 incentive). Pride and Money Treatment: 106 Individuals (53 with $10 incentive, 53 with $25 incentive). Post-race survey: 407.
Primary outcomes
Race Performance: Goal attained. This is an indicator for whether the participant met the time goal they provided in the Pre-Race Survey See Pre-analysis plan for other outcomes.
Secondary outcomes
See Pre-analysis plan.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords