Using behavioural economic insights to overcome student procrastination

How to cite

Albrecht, Sabina; Cheung, Stephen; Page, Lionel; Kocher, Martin. 2020. "Using behavioural economic insights to overcome student procrastination." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004136. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4136-2.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sabina Albrecht* , Stephen Cheung , Lionel Page , Martin Kocher

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004136
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4136-2.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2018-07-18 – 2024-06-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4136

Abstract

The ability to complete academic work in a timely manner is critical to students’ success at school. This project builds on insights from behavioural economics to investigate the mechanisms responsible for students’ tendency to procrastinate in their studies and to test simple interventions to overcome procrastination problems. We randomise a large sample of senior secondary students in Australia into a baseline and three treatment groups, in which we observe the timing and success of completion of a sustained real effort task. Treatments vary based on the length of the deadline given to complete the task and on whether students receive a reminder (unanticipated or anticipated) to do the task. In a second step, we elicit experimental measures of impatience and present bias, which are theoretically linked to procrastination behaviour, of these students to investigate how empirically observed procrastination behaviour correlates with students’ time preferences. Finally, we link our behavioural measures to administrative data to examine whether present-biased preferences and procrastination behaviour are predictive of students’ university entrance scores.

Intervention

The first part of our study is designed to observe procrastination behaviour of high school students in their regular school setting. This part contains an RCT with four interventions, described below. (The second part of our study is an experimental elicitation of time preferences and does not contain any intervention as such. Details about that part can be found under Experimental Design.)
We give the students a real-effort task that is commonly used in laboratory experiments as an incentivised homework to be completed by a set deadline. We observe the students’ working patterns on the homework task, from which we derive measures of procrastination. By randomising classes into different interventions aimed at overcoming procrastination behaviour, we study the effectiveness of these interventions in terms of overcoming procrastination behaviour in a naturalistic setting. The interventions vary the length of the deadline to complete the homework task and whether students receive a reminder to complete the task before the end of the deadline. Specifically, the four interventions/treatment conditions are:
1) Baseline: Four-week deadline, no reminder
2) Short deadline: One-week deadline, no reminder
3) Anticipated reminder: Four-week deadline, anticipated reminder
4) Unanticipated reminder: Four-week deadline, unanticipated reminder

Experimental design

Our study design comprises two experimental parts, which are both artefactual field experiments in the classification of Harrison and List (2004)*. The first part is designed to observe procrastination – a behavioural implication of present bias – in high school students in an unobtrusive and naturalistic setting. In this part, we give the students an incentivised homework, consisting of a real-effort task requiring sustained attention, to be completed within a set deadline. We make use of the described interventions aiming at improving the timeliness of goal completion. The second part is designed to measure time preferences (i.e. an individual’s preference for when to do tasks and his or her bias for the present) for each student. For this part, we follow the experimental methodology of Augenblick, Niederle and Sprenger (2015)**.

Reflecting the two-part design, the study is executed over two separate periods. The first part takes place over the course of five weeks. At a first visit to the school, students fill out a background questionnaire, receive instructions and get to practice the homework task for the first part of the study. Two days later, the period to work on the homework task begins, which is up to four weeks long. Subsequently, we return to the school to introduce the second part of the study, which takes place over the course of three weeks.

*Harrison, G.W. and List, J.A. (2004). Field Experiments, Journal of Economic Literature, 1009-1055.
**Augenblick, N., Niederle, M. and Sprenger, C. (2015). Working Over Time: Dynamic Inconsistency in Real Effort Tasks, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1067-1115.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done by a computer prior to visiting the first school. We use the Research Randomizer (Version 4.0)*, a software provided by randomizer.org , which allows within-school random assignment of classes to one of the four treatment conditions (random assignment with blocked design). This ensures a higher balance in sample size between the treatment conditions and aligns with our empirical strategy that includes school fixed-effects. *Urbaniak, G. C., & Plous, S. (2013). Research Randomizer (Version 4.0) [Computer software]. Retrieved on April 23, 2018, from http://www.randomizer.org/
Randomization unit
We randomise all treatments at the class level, within school.
Clusters
Initial target: 60 classes in 30 schools Due to unanticipated difficulty in data collection on account of COVID-19 restrictions, we revise our target down to 40 classes in 15 schools.
Observations
Initial target: 900 students Due to unanticipated difficulty in data collection on account of COVID-19 restrictions, we revise our target down to 600 students.
Arms
Initial target: 15 classes Baseline, 15 classes Short Deadline treatment, 15 classes Anticipated Reminder treatment, 15 classes Unanticipated Reminder treatment Due to unanticipated difficulty in data collection on account of COVID-19 restrictions, we revise our target down to 10 classes per treatment arm.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are based on the recorded attempts to complete the task. - Dichotomous: Starting to complete the task - Continuous: Time of starting to complete the task - Dichotomous: Success of completion - Continuous: Time of completion - Continuous: Number of attempts at completion - Continuous: Time of attempts - Continuous: Progression before the reminder (anticipated/unanticipated)
Secondary outcomes
No secondary outcomes considered at this time.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords