The impact of HR consulting services on Small and Medium Enterprises: evidence from a field experiment in Birmingham, UK

How to cite

Monti, Manuel; Akesson, Jesper. 2019. "The impact of HR consulting services on Small and Medium Enterprises: evidence from a field experiment in Birmingham, UK." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004119. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4119-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Manuel Monti* , Jesper Akesson

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004119
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4119-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-06-14 – 2020-06-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
M12, M14, M51
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4119

Abstract

While a number of studies have demonstrated a strong link between better formal management and organizational practices and productivity growth, many SMEs find investing in these areas challenging. They face a confusing and fragmented business support offer, and evidence suggests that many small businesses do not take advantage of formal advice. Research in the UK estimates that around 28% of SMEs have an unmet need for business support, and that half of these do not recognise this need despite experiencing unresolved problems.

The CIPD’s People Skills program was designed to provide SMEs in the UK with human resource (HR) support and advice by connecting SMEs with local independent consultants. A pilot evaluation of the program showed that this could be an effective way of improving the HR skills of SMEs. This trial builds upon the pilot by focusing on how to connect SMEs to HR consulting efficiently and at scale in Birmingham, UK. In the first part of the trial, we randomly assign business members of the Greater Birmingham Chambers of Commerce to receive different communications containing behavioral messages and test their effect on take-up of free HR consulting. In the second part, we evaluate the effect of the free HR consulting on intermediate and long-term outcomes linked to productivity by randomly assigning the HR consulting service across SMEs that sign up for the program.

Intervention

In the first stage, we test the effect of different communications sent across different channels on enrollment to a program that offers free HR and people management consulting for SMEs. The different messages will be randomized.

In the second stage, SMEs are randomized to either receive free HR and people management consulting provided by local experts over the course of two days or not receive anything.

Experimental design

The trial will be carried out in two phases. The unit of analysis will be individual SMEs in both phases of the evaluation.

In the first stage, we will randomise the receipt of communications to invite SMEs to take an online diagnostic and sign up for the free HR support. In the initial online trial, there will be four treatment arms. The allocation ratio will be even.

In the second stage, we will randomise the receipt of the HR consulting service among firms that signed-up and took the online diagnostic. Firms will be randomised into receiving the service or not receiving the service. Consultants will be assigned to firms that are selected to receive the treatment. Three months after treatment is provided, outcomes will be measured in a follow-up diagnostic.

Design details

Randomization method
Randmization done in our office by computer and will be conducted by a matched pairs design where we block on variables related to firm-level characteristics and productivity. We will also balance on other firm-level information. For the second stage, firms are randomized on a weekly basis as they sign-up for the program. Randomization in this stage will also block on their assignment from the first stage.
Randomization unit
Firm
Clusters
For the first stage: 4,000 firms in the online messaging trial and 30,000 firms in the offline messaging trial. For the second stage: approximately 1,000 firms (dependent on how many firms sign up)
Observations
For the first stage: 4,000 firms in the online messaging trial and 30,000 firms in the offline messaging trial. For the second stage: approximately 1,000 firms (dependent on how many firms sign up)
Arms
For first stage: - in online trial: 1,000 firms treatment letter 1; 1,000 treatment letter 2; 1,000 treatment letter 3; and 1,000 treatment letter 4. - in offline trial: TBD For second stage: 500 firms control, 500 HR consulting.
Primary outcomes
For the first stage, the primary outcome of interest is registration to the program. For the second stage, the primary short term outcomes of interest are overall and area specific people management and HR score measured through an online diagnostic survey approximately three months after the consulting support is provided. The primary long term outcomes of interest are revenues and headcount from administrative tax data (BEIS will collect this data).
Secondary outcomes
For the first stage, secondary outcomes include open and click-through rate (online trial) and contact (calls and emails) to the program team (contact information is included in the communications). For the second stage, secondary outcomes include projected revenues in following year, projected employment in following year, self-reported importance of people management, time spent on people management in last three months, likelihood of seeking external assistance when dealing with HR related problems or when trying to improve people management, and likelihood of investing in building a greater internal people management capability.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords