'The Impact of External Modernization and Internal Modernization for Small-Scale Retailers in Emerging Markets: Evidence from a Field Experiment'
How to cite
Kankanhalli, Shreya; Anderson, Stephen; Narayanan, Sridhar; Iacovone, Leonardo. 2019. "'The Impact of External Modernization and Internal Modernization for Small-Scale Retailers in Emerging Markets: Evidence from a Field Experiment'." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004087. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4087-1.2000000000000002
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The retail sector in Mexico and other developing countries tends to be dominated by millions of traditional small-scale businesses that fail to adopt modern business structures. It is important to investigate approaches to modernizing the retail sector given the prevalence of traditional retail firms in urban centers, the large proportion of workers that are employed in traditional retail across developing countries, and the critical logistics role that retailers play in distributing goods from international suppliers to local consumers. We propose two novel approaches to effectively induce retailers to modernize their businesses: an “external or customer-facing” approach and an “internal or product-facing” approach.
We evaluate the impact of the two approaches on modernization levels and performance via a randomized control trial. In our RCT, 1154 small retailers in Mexico City are randomized into three groups of equal size: control (n=384), “external” treatment (n=385) and “internal” treatment (n=384). Over 6 weeks, junior fellows (i.e. top university students majoring in business, economics or related disciplines) partner with retailers in one of the two treatment groups and work with them to implement relevant modernization structures through 12 site visits. Each site visit is 2.5 hours long, so the program amounts to 30 hours of direct implementation of modernization structures. Retail firms in the “external” treatment group only implement external modernization structures, while retail firms in the “internal” treatment group only implement “internal” modernization structures, with help from their junior fellow.
Intervention
1. “External" Modernization intervention: Firm is partnered with a ‘Modernization Fellow’ (i.e. a top university student majoring in business, economics or related disciplines) who helps them implement external modernization structures in their business over 6 weeks. The Fellow helps the firm through 11 site visits, of 2.5 hours each, that are exclusively dedicated to hands-on implementation of external modernization structures. Fellows are trained and supervised by senior managers who also make 3 site visits (each 2.5 hours).
2. "Internal" Modernization intervention: Exactly the same format and intensity as the first intervention, except the Fellow implements internal modernization structures at the treated business.
Experimental design
The study consists of three parts: (1) business selection, (2) baseline, randomization and intervention, and (3) collection of followup data. Part one began in fall 2017. Across five residential zones of Mexico City, university students managed by our team approached retail business owners with a marketing pitch to apply for a ‘modernization’ program. Interested retailers signed up via a recruitment survey, which we used to screen candidates. Screened firms were invited to complete a baseline survey. About 1150 firms qualified and were randomized into three equally-sized groups:
• Group 1: offered to get external modernization structures changed.
• Group 2: offered to get internal modernization structures changed.
• Group 3 (control): formed a counterfactual group that did not receive any intervention.
Randomization happened at the firm level immediately prior to the scheduled intervention delivery.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.