Incentivising Adoption of and Measuring the Impact of Agricultural Products Processing Technologies: An RCT in West Africa

How to cite

Mulungu, Kelvin; Manning, Dale; Arouna, Aminou; Aboudou, Rachidi. 2019. "Incentivising Adoption of and Measuring the Impact of Agricultural Products Processing Technologies: An RCT in West Africa." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004081. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4081-3.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kelvin Mulungu* , Dale Manning , Aminou Arouna , Rachidi Aboudou

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004081
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4081-3.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2019-04-08 – 2021-08-31
Countries
Côte d'Ivoire (Northern and Central), Nigeria (Central), Togo (Northern)
JEL codes
Q12, Q13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4081

Abstract

Rice is an important crop in West Africa and globally. However, local rice in West Africa is viewed as a second choice among consumers as they prefer imported foreign rice because of perceived quality. From the supply side, there are problems with post-harvest losses and lack of processing. To overcome this problem related to quality and to reduce the post-harvest losses on the supply side, a novel parboiling technology, called GEM (grain-quality enhancer, energy-efficient durable material) technology, was developed and has since been disseminated to some farmers in Benin, Ivory Coast, Togo, and Nigeria. However, like most technologies in Africa, its adoption remains low.

There are multiple reasons that have been advanced for low adoption of technologies, among them is the lack of information, inappropriate technology, credit constraints, risk averseness of the farmers, lack of accompanying inputs, and institutional factors such poor roads that make these technologies less profitable. Incentives to encourage adoption have been recommended in literature and shown to have a long-lasting impact on the use of technologies. However, what type of incentives and where to place them to have the maximum behavioural impact (uptake) remains heavily unexplored. In this study, our goal is three-fold. Firstly, we want to compare the effectiveness of a price-matching incentive and a cost-saving (transport coupon) offered to randomly selected group of rice-parboilers on adoption. We expect that credit constrained households will respond more to the cost-saving incentive compared to the price-matching incentive. Secondly, we want to test if adoption of GEM has a positive impact on rice profit. We also study repeat use after the incentive has been used. The hypothesis is that those who experience the technology more under an incentive will use it more after the incentive period as they would have learned and overcome the imperfect information barrier.

To achieve these objectives, we select a sample size of 690, a third in the price matching incentive and a third in the cost coupon while the last third is in the control (i.e. not encouraged to adopt). Because there are few actors along the higher end of the agricultural value chain, we do a census of all parboilers in the selected sites (Gagnoa and Boauke in Ivory Coast and Lafia in Nigeria). The sample size is calculated and selected using profit as the main variable even though we wish to understand how the incentives affect adoption, the sample size required for the latter is generally lower than the sample size required to understand the impact of adoption on rice income.

We envisage the use of an instrumental variable approach in the estimation of the impact of the adoption of GEM on rice profit/income with the randomization into treatment as the instrument. We will further employ more detailed models to understand the relationships between the types of incentives and adoption like including measures of access to credit, perception of costs, and market.

Experimental design

This is a randomized controlled trial, randomized at the individual level. To ensure the integrity of the experiment, households involved in parboiling rice (henceforth parboilers) that have never received information about GEM and have not adopted yet will be listed in each of the 3 sites in Ivory Coast and 1 site in Nigeria, and one site in Togo. After listing, the households will be invited for an information session in which they will be introduced to GEM and its benefits. Given that there are not so many parboilers, as is common for actors along the value chain in agriculture, the goal will be to do a census of all parboilers within the catchment area. For each site, there is one GEM that has been recently installed and run by a group comprising a few members. Once the members who have not yet adopted have been given the information, they will be randomized into the two treatments and the control. Each treatment and the control will have a total of 230 parboilers. Once randomized into treatment and control, the treatment members will be further randomized into the treatment levels i.e. whether receiving incentives for 2 bags, 4 bags, or 8 bags. The treated parboilers will receive redeemable coupons that they will redeem upon bringing of rice to the GEM for parboiling. As they redeem the coupons, we will be able to monitor uptake. The coupons are applicable to both the cost treatment and the price matching incentive.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization will be done by computer once the names have been collected and entered into the computer.
Randomization unit
Households (if there are two parboilers in the house, both get selected, otherwise cheating would be high).
Clusters
0
Observations
690 (minimum)
Arms
0
Primary outcomes
Adoption- We want to understand uptake of the treatment as a response to the incentives Profit- To understand how profits from GEM compare to other parboiling technologies Income- To understand the impact of using GEM on household income Food security- to understand the impact of using GEM on household food security

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords