Building Bridges and Bonds - Just Beginning and DadTime Impact Evaluation

How to cite

Knox, Virginia; Israel, Dina; Harknett, Kristen; Balu, Rekha. 2019. "Building Bridges and Bonds - Just Beginning and DadTime Impact Evaluation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004028. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4028-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Virginia Knox* , Dina Israel , Kristen Harknett , Rekha Balu

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0004028
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4028-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2014-09-25 – 2021-09-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I310 General Welfare; Well-Being
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/4028

Abstract

The Building Bridges and Bonds study is an evaluation of new program approaches to support low-income fathers in working toward economic stability and improved relationships with their children. The study includes tests of the impacts of the Just Beginning parenting intervention and of the DadTime smartphone app intervention. The Just Beginning and DadTime program interventions were tested in three fatherhood program settings: Children's Institute, Inc. in Los Angeles, CA; People for People in Philadelphia, PA; and Seedco in New York City, NY.

The Just Beginning parenting intervention is a program that works with fathers and their young children together to improve the quality of father-child interactions; and the DadTime engagement intervention is a smartphone app that aims to improve fathers’ participation in the program by guiding and supporting them in making and following through on plans for attending Just Beginning workshops. It also prompts them to practice skills learned in the parenting intervention.

The impacts of the Just Beginning and DadTime program interventions will be evaluated using an experimental research design. The impact study will address questions about whether the new approaches affect key outcomes of interest, including father-child relationship quality and program participation.

Intervention

The Just Beginning Intervention is comprised of 5 sessions, which each include the following three program components.

(1) Parent Learning Session. A trained and certified facilitator introduces the father to a fundamental but simple concept that may help him to improve the quality of his interactions with his young child. The father watches a short collection of Sesame Beginnings video clips featuring Baby Elmo and other characters that illustrate these concepts and lay the groundwork for the father-child play session. The father and facilitator discuss the video and plan for the father-child play session.

(2) Father-Child Play Session. The father joins his young child in a child-friendly play space, which is safe for the child to explore and contains a colorful floormat, books, toys, and other items that facilitate father-child interactions. The father has an opportunity to try out the new approaches he has just learned as he plays with his child. The facilitator simply observes the interaction and does not interfere with it or judge the father.

(3) Debrief Session. The facilitator describes positive examples of how the father used any new approaches with his child. The father and facilitator reflect on the play session together. The father and facilitator jointly brainstorm ideas for how the father will apply the lesson he learned to other settings.

DadTime uses mobile technology to provide planning tools to support attendance at Just Beginning sessions, and reinforcements of Just Beginning program content.

(1) Program Attendance Planning Tools. DadTime sends an automated reminder one day before a scheduled Just Beginning session. It includes the time and location of the session and gives the father an opportunity to plan for his transportation and travel time. An option allows the father to send an automated text message reminder to the person accompanying the child to the session, if he is not bringing the child himself. Another option allows the father to instantly notify program staff if he needs to reschedule.

(2) Content Support. DadTime sends the father exercises and activity suggestions after each Just Beginning session, to help him reflect on what he has learned and plan for time he may spend with his child between sessions. Several weeks after enrolling in the program, the father begins to receive biweekly prompts that encourage him to plan for continued playtime with his child, as well as reinforce key program concepts.

Experimental design

The Just Beginning parenting intervention was added to the services offered at three existing fatherhood programs. Fathers who sought services at one of these programs were screened for eligibility for the Just Beginning program. Fathers who reported having recent contact with a child of theirs who was between 2 months and under three years of age was eligible for the Just Beginning program component, unless there was a legal restriction or other extenuating circumstance that would prohibit their participation with their child. Eligible fathers were randomly assigned to a Just Beginning program group, which is offered the new Just Beginning program component in addition to the usual services at the fatherhood program, or to a "Services as Usual" control group, which does not have access to the new Just Beginning program component.

In the same three sites testing the Just Beginning parenting intervention, the Building Bridges and Bonds study also tested a new smartphone app, called DadTime, to encourage fathers’ program engagement. The DadTime app was installed on smartphones of fathers in the Just Beginning program group upon enrollment.

For the DadTime engagement test, fathers who are in the Just Beginning program group went through a second stage of random assignment to a “Full DadTime” app group or a “Partial DadTime” app group. The Full DadTime group was offered access to the DadTime app content from the time of intake onward, and could use the app both during and after their period of participation in Just Beginning sessions. The Full DadTime group received both of the two key DadTime components: 1) reminders and attendance support, including pop-up reminders about JB session times, and short questions and suggestions to help fathers plan attendance at the sessions; and 2) activity suggestions, including short questions and suggestions to help plan when they will see their children and activities they can do together; the app tailored questions and suggestions based on the child’s age and how frequently the father said he saw his child.

In contrast, the Partial DadTime group did not have access to DadTime during their period of Just Beginning participation, and did not receive reminders or attendance support. The Partial DadTime group did, however, receive the same activity suggestions as the Full DadTime group starting about eight weeks after enrolling in the Building Bridges and Bonds study, which was intended to be after the father had completed his five Just Beginning sessions.

After eight weeks, the DadTime app sent suggestions to fathers of ways to play with their children, which were designed to potentially extend all Just Beginning fathers’ practice of the Just Beginning parenting skills. The study team selected the eight-week interval to set a common timeframe when both the Full and Partial DadTime groups would likely have completed their Just Beginning sessions. Fathers in the Services as Usual control group were not be eligible for the app because the app is designed to reinforce skills learned in Just Beginning.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done by computer.
Randomization unit
Individuals
Clusters
Fathers were be randomly assigned within 1 of 3 program sites.
Observations
738 fathers are in the Just Beginning study. 224 fathers are in the DadTime study.
Arms
For the Just Beginning study, 368 fathers were randomly assigned to the Just Beginning program group and 370 fathers were randomly assigned to the Services as Usual control group. For the DadTime study, 117 fathers were randomly assigned to the Full DadTime group and 107 fathers were randomly assigned to the Partial DadTime group.
Primary outcomes
*** For the Just Beginning impact evaluation we have 10 primary outcomes ***: (1) Frequency that father uses labeling with child. (2) Father attitude toward verbal engagement with child. (3) Warm and supportive parenting scale (4) Father-child dysfunctional interaction from the Parenting Stress Index (5) Parenting efficacy (6) Overall quality of father-child relationship (7) Father-child relationship quality scale (8) Father perceived influence on child (9) Father/child contact (10) Father's reliability for planned time with child *** For the DadTime impact evaluation we have 3 primary outcomes ***: (1) Completed first Just Beginning session (2) Number of Just Beginning sessions completed (3) Completed all Just Beginning sessions
Secondary outcomes
For the Just Beginning impact evaluation we have 35 secondary outcomes: (1) Father-child dysfunctional interaction - single item self-rating for good parenting (2) Father-child engagement in caregiving activities (3) Father-child engagement in learning and play activities (4) Father-child engagement in physical play activities (5) Father-child engagement in socialization activities (6) Harsh discipline (7) Physical harsh discipline (8) Parenting efficacy scale: financial items (9) Parenting efficacy rating: Following through on promises (10) Decision-making influence (11) Father dedication/commitment to child scale (12) Father report of how much he would miss his child (13) Father-child relationship quality scale: positive items (14) Father-child relationship quality scale: negative items (15) Current perceived influence rating (16) Future perceived influence rating (17) Father-child contact not in person rating (18) Nights in the past month father-child spent in same house (19) Focal child lives with father (20) Father lives with any of his children (21) Contact with any children in past 30 days (22) Cooperative co-parenting rating: "Mother and I make a good parenting team" (23) Cooperative co-parenting rating: "Mother tells me I am doing a good job" (24) Co-parenting challenges: undermining scale (25) Co-parenting challenges: conflict scale (26) Co-parenting challenges: maternal gate-keeping scale (27) Perceived stress scale: helplessness (28) Perceived stress scale: efficacy (29) Total amount of child support paid in the past month (30) Child support owed versus paid in the past month (31) Number of types of informal support provided to focal child in the past month (32) Number of types of informal support provided to non-focal children in the past month (33) Positive discipline (34) Currently employed (35) Amount worked since random assignment For the DadTime impact evaluation we have 4 secondary outcomes: (1) Father/child contact (2) Father's reliability for planned time with child (3) Frequency that father uses labeling with child (4) Warm and supportive parenting scale

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords