A Correspondence Study of Skill and Context Variation in Parental Hiring Probabilities Before, During, and After the COVID-19 Pandemic
How to cite
Cooke, Lynn Prince; Kweon, Soyoung. 2019. "A Correspondence Study of Skill and Context Variation in Parental Hiring Probabilities Before, During, and After the COVID-19 Pandemic." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0004015. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.4015-1.4
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This is a harmonized correspondence study on employer hiring in Finland and the UK, to compare gender differences with parental status the treatment effect. The over-arching research question has two dimensions. First, this study evaluates whether there are gender differences in relative positive callback rates for parents versus childless married individuals at an early stage of the hiring process, and if they differ across low-, medium- and high-skill occupations. Second, it uses a comparative design to generalize results across two diverse country contexts in terms of institutional support gender employment equality and maternal employment in particular. We select the same three gender-neutral occupations for analysis in each labor market, harmonizing education and work experience in each across the countries. After the start of fielding in both countries, however, the COVID-19 pandemic and associated lockdowns had dramatic effects on the labor markets. We therefore added a new facet of assessing whether the lower demain exacerbated discrimination against mothers and favoring fathers.
Experimental design
This is a comparative correspondence study assessing potential gender differences in hiring discrimination around parenthood in a low-, medium- and high-skilled occupation in two countries. For the comparative element of this study, the countries were selected given their variation in institutional supports for both class and gender equality. Finland has more extensive labor market institutions and policy support for dual-earning and caring. The more liberal UK welfare regime minimizes state intervention in market mechanism affecting either class or gender equality. To compare effects across skill levels, three occupations requiring different levels of education were selected that are also less gender-segregated in both countries: call center workers, restaurant managers, and accountants.
Two sets of comparable application materials in terms of employment trajectories and accomplishments were developed for each occupation in each country based on national statistics, data bases, LinkedIn profiles, and discussions with country HR experts and recruiting professionals. The sets of application materials were harmonized to equalize number of years of post-secondary education plus work experience within occupations across countries.
External validity of instruments for each occupation has been confirmed via interviews with HR experts, whereas commensurability of sets of application materials (internal validity) has been validated with in-person student and online abs in each country students and adult samples, in a lab and online.
In fielding, job advertisements will be drawn from online employment databases in each country to provide widest coverage of available jobs. We use a 2x2 within-subject design for effects of parenthood (i.e., for each job ad, two applications will be sent of the same gender, both of whom are married but one is randomly assigned to be a parent (treatment) and the other childless (control)). Parenthood is signaled in the personal information on the resume (doing so is still more normative in Europe). Differences in positive callback rates between men and women are investigated by means of between-subject variation. Gender is manipulated by applicant names, drawn from the most common first names in each country. To evaluate treatment effects, the study documents positive callbacks from employers, comparing group differences in requests for an interview with rejections or non-response. We further divide the fielding period into pre-, pandemic, and post-pandemic periods based on timing of lockdowns and labor demand flows.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.