This pre-analysis plan details the analysis to be conducted on new data being collected for an evaluation of a micro-loan, grant and training program that was conducted at the end of 2013. Extensive data has already been collected on a range of business outcomes and has found significant effects of pairing ILO Start Your Business (SYB) trainings with microfinance on business outcomes for men. It is though unclear what the effect of these programs has been on general individual and household welfare. The next data collections will conduct two household follow-up surveys of the participants of the program to understand the long-term effect of cash grants and finance for both business and household welfare outcomes.
Experimental design
From August to October 2012, 1,550 microenterprise owners in Uganda were offered randomly either a loan, grant, businesses skills training, a combination of these programs, or no program (the control group).
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization was done in an office by a computer in Stata.
Randomization unit
Randomization was done at the individual level, stratified by region.
Clusters
1550 business owners.
Observations
7750
Arms
Individuals have been randomly selected and split into five different groups. 406 were assigned to the loans intervention, 401 to the loans and training, 167 to grants, 219 to grants and training, and 357 to the control group. The sample sizes were based on power calculations after taking into account implementation budget limitations.
Primary outcomes
The main questions of interest for the next rounds of data collection include a range of indicators on the following topics:
1. Income
The existing data collection has focused on outcomes for the main business. Individuals and households in Africa though often have multiple sources of income. It is not clear from the current data if the money from the grants and loans was used for productive investment in other enterprises, or has replaced other income. A detailed exploration of the other businesses run by the individual and others within the family will be conducted.
2. Intra-household bargaining and money allocation
The issue of money allocation within the household is important, especially for married women. The initial results of the SYB evaluation show a negative effect for married women with family living nearby. It is not yet clear what happened to the money women received. It is common for women in Africa to have little or no control over money they earn or receive and are expected to give money to their husbands or extended family for both productive and non-productive investment. This new survey will explore women’s bargaining power over money within the household to determine what might have led to these negative results and determine where the money went.
3. Investment in household welfare
While the initial results for men with training and loans has been to increase business profits, it is not clear what the men did with the money. There are currently no consumption or savings impacts from the program. It is possible that men simply use the extra money for short-term individual consumption, which would not have significant welfare implications. It is also possible that there is a hidden welfare effect on business or household assets and investment. The household survey will thus explore the household assets and spending further to determine if there is a positive welfare effect from the programs.
4. Unintended consequences
The initial results have raised a number of questions about the unintended consequences of the programs, especially for family employment and child schooling. The household survey will further explore this issue to better understand whether the business owners pulled children out of school to work in the business, and if so, for how long.