Testing Contact Theory in a Field Experiment
How to cite
Freddi, Eleonora; Potters, Jan; Suetens, Sigrid. 2019. "Testing Contact Theory in a Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003955. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3955-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
About 15% of the population in the Netherlands and other European countries have an immigrant background (either first, second or third generation). The percentage is likely to increase in the near future due to immigration flows from the Middle East and Northern Africa, and the expected demographic changes caused by, for example, climate change. This poses challenges for society. To illustrate, immigrants in the Netherlands and other European countries are more likely to be at risk of poverty, are more likely to be unemployed, and, if employed, earn substantially less than natives or have a job for which they are overqualified.
Several factors underlie the achievement gap between “natives” and people with an immigrant background. Research has shown that discrimination, referring to differential treatment of others under ceteris paribus conditions, may be one of the factors. A key question for policy makers and scientists is how such discrimination can be overcome. An answer to the question can possibly be found in Allport (1954)’s contact theory. The theory presumes that discrimination is the consequence of natives viewing others with an immigrant background as an ‘out-group’ with whom they have little in common. The theory predicts that positive contact in the form of personal interaction, sharing of common goals, cooperating in joint projects reduces discrimination. In this paper we study whether positive contact indeed reduces discrimination in the context of social interaction between Dutch natives and people with an immigrant background.
Experimental design
We run a field experiment with native Dutch people. The participants participate in a team task and each team is assigned a supervisor. In some teams the supervisor has a native Dutch background and in other teams the supervisor has an immigrant background. As such we obtain exogenous variation in the degree of positive contact with someone who has an immigrant background. Participants nor supervisors are aware that they are participating in an experiment.
A month later we elicit choices in order to study whether the participants treat people with an immigrant background differently than native Dutch. The participants first make a choice in an ultimatum game in the role of responder (i.e. they are asked their minimum acceptable offer) and then make a choice in a deception game in the role of communicator following Danilov and Saccardo (2015). Some of the participants are matched to a proposer who has an immigrant background and the other participants are matched with a native Dutch proposer. Proposers and responders are anonymous to each other, but responders know the first name of the proposer. This name serves as a signal of immigrant background. If there is a gap in the minimum acceptable offer in the sense that the minimum acceptable offer is higher in the “immigrant” treatment than in the “native” treatment, then we interpret this as discrimination against those with an immigrant background. In the deception game the participants are again matched to an anonymous partner and are only informed about the name of their partner. They have the option to tell the truth about the outcome of a dice roll, or to lie in favor of the partner, which comes at a small cost for oneself. If the percentage of lies is higher in the “native” treatment than in the “immigrant” treatment, we take this as discrimination.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.