Is active case management the key to the successful integration of refugees? Evidence from a field experiment in Germany

How to cite

Sajons, Christoph; Müller, Bettina. 2019. "Is active case management the key to the successful integration of refugees? Evidence from a field experiment in Germany." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003934. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3934-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Christoph Sajons* , Bettina Müller

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003934
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3934-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2019-02-04 – 2019-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
H43, J15, J61
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3934

Abstract

In 2015 and 2016, over 1.2 million refugees arrived in Germany, the large majority without knowing the German language or possessing any formal or vocational degrees. The task to integrate them in the German society is further complicated by the fact that being subject to an often lengthy asylum procedure and constant assistance by government social workers and volunteers tends to decrease the refugees' self-initiative and their belief to be able to shape their own future. This study examines whether introducing an active and activating case management can counter this development and foster the integration of refugees. To identify its impact, we implement a field experiment at the roll-out of a local "integration management" program in a medium-sized German city. About 620 household heads and their family members are randomly allocated to treatment and control group, with treatment meaning working with the integration managers for eight months, while those in the control group continue to be cared for by traditional social workers throughout this period and are taken into the integration management afterwards. The short-term impact is measured as the difference in relevant integration variables after the eight months treatment period. Additionally, we intent to disentangle potential channels of influence (more intensive assistance due to a lower refugees-per-integration-manager ratio vs. more structured and activating approach).

Experimental design

Background information:
The integration management program in our cooperating city is implemented in three consecutive waves. In the first wave (roughly May 2018 to January 2019), the most urgent cases were included, i.e., individuals who needed more intensive assistance for themselves or family members at that point in time. For the other two waves, no special allocation mechanism was foreseen on the part of the city. We therefore agreed with the officials to do the allocation randomly in order to evaluate the effectiveness of the program.

Individual steps:
1. The officials from the integration management program assemble a list of potential participants. That is, they list all refugees in their jurisdiction who have not been part of the program yet and for whom there is no immediate reason or need to put them in a specific wave.
2. We provide a list of randomly generated numbers to the officials. The numbers are matched with the IDs of the potential participants, such that they can be randomly allocated to treatment and control group on the household level and stratified by place of living (16 refugee residences, publicly provided apartments, and private apartments).
3. Treatment group individuals participate in the integration management program between February and October 2019, while control group participants continue to be supervised by social workers or can get help at public counsel offices throughout the same period.
4. We accompany both integration managers and social workers for a couple of days to get first-hand knowledge about the different approaches used (summer 2019).
5. In October 2019, the supervising integration managers collect the final data about the outcomes and background of the treatment group participants.
6. After that, control group participants enter the integration management program (roughly November 2019 to June 2020), while treatment group participants can turn to social workers or public counsel offices for advice, if still needed.
7. At the beginning of wave 3 (November/December 2019), the supervising integration managers collect the information about the control group participants.
8. The officials from the integration management combine the data for treatment and control group, remove any personal and identifying information, and send the resulting data set to us (January 2020).
9. The researchers aim at getting funds for a post-participation survey to obtain information on potential channels of influence at play. To protect the personal information of the participants, the questionnaires will be sent out and collected through the city officials (roughly February/March 2020).

Analysis:
The identification of the treatment effect (i.e., the effect of being supervised by the integration management program) relies heavily on the experimental setup presented above, in particular, the random allocation of participants into the comparison groups. That is, we measure the effect on the three main outcome variables as the difference in the respective means of the two groups, assuming that they are almost identical in all other aspects (observed and unobserved). This is equivalent to running regressions of the respective outcome on a simple treatment indicator. Additionally, we will add potentially relevant control variables to check whether the estimates remain stable, i.e., whether the random allocation of participants to the two comparison groups worked well.
Furthermore, we will examine whether different subgroups react differently to the treatment by separately introducing interaction terms between the treatment variable and indicators for various potentially interesting subgroups, especially women, households with children, individuals with a low formal education, and people living in private apartments.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
The treatment is clustered by family and the random allocation process stratified by residence and type of apartment. There are two formal/practical reasons for this approach: (1) All members of a family have to be treated simultaneously, that is, they have to be in the same group. (2) Because integration managers are responsible for individual residences, the allocation has to be done fairly evenly on the residence level. Otherwise, individual integration managers could end up with very uneven amounts of work over the two phases. If this allocation mechanism leads to heavily lopsided distributions in certain residences (in particular, the smaller ones), e.g., if the household heads in one group have larger families than the ones in the other, we therefore adjust the distribution for this residence manually.
Clusters
Around 620 families.
Observations
Around 1,000 adults.
Arms
About 310 families treatment, 310 families control.
Primary outcomes
a) Labor market integration: Employment of any kind (full time, part time, mini jobs, internships, apprenticeships, publicly sponsored jobs) b) Language proficiency: Self-assessed German language proficiency c) Housing: Living in a private apartment (in contrast to living in a refugee residence or an apartment organized by the city)
Secondary outcomes
• Actively searching for a job (if not in employment) • Further education activities (school, university/college, apprenticeship, training programs) • Recognition of academic or vocational degrees from abroad • Application for recognition of academic or vocational degrees from abroad • Participation in a German language or integration course These outcomes are of minor importance and we will only take a look at them to make sense of the main results.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords