A Scientific Approach to SME Productivity

How to cite

Camuffo, Arnaldo; Spina, Chiara; Novelli, Elena; Felin, Teppo. 2019. "A Scientific Approach to SME Productivity." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003875. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3875-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Arnaldo Camuffo* , Chiara Spina , Elena Novelli , Teppo Felin

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003875
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3875-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-12-01 – 2019-11-30
Countries
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (London)
JEL codes
M13, L25
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3875

Abstract

SMEs are a vital part of the economy of almost all Countries (including the UK). However, their contribution to wealth creation, GDP and employment is lower than expected since the share of high-productivity SMEs remains substantially low (especially in the UK). The UK Government has recognised that SME productivity is a concern and has worked since 2011 on an action plan to improve it. Recent evidence shows that a key barrier to SMEs development is the shortage of programmes that educate and support businesses. Other studies also suggest that the lack of systematic managerial approaches and evidence based decision-making also hinder the growth and productivity of SMEs.
It is therefore important to ascertain what practices might improve SMEs’ decision-making processes - and, therefore, result in higher productivity. Addressing this research question would allow to better focus national and local government policies supporting SMEs, and more specifically to offer management training programs with proven ability to enhance small business owners and managers decision making. This project aims to address this question by testing the effect on SMEs’ productivity and growth of a set of novel business practices labelled ‘a scientific approach to decision making’. Extant studies converge in suggesting that SMEs, and especially microbusinesses, need to improve their ability to make rigorous strategic decisions.
This suggests that there is considerable room for improvement in the way they are managed and that there is a clear need to have them learn effective decision making tools.
The project will focus on micro-businesses, which represent the lion share of all businesses in most Countries (including UK), but account for only a small fraction of turnover. This suggests that there is considerable room for improvement in the way they are managed. Moreover, identifying solutions to improve these firms’ productivity could lead to particularly impactful results and a substantial return on investment. A focus on micro-businesses is also consistent with our experimental research design, with the intervention targeted to business owners or managers whom, in microbusinesses make most decisions (and especially strategic ones) with direct impact on performance.
More specifically we want to know if firms adopting a scientific approach to decision making are more productive than non adopters. Using an experimental research design we will compare two samples of firms, similar -on average- on all covariates. We will intervene on the two groups offering management training and then test if the pre/post-intervention productivity increase of firms treated with the scientific approach is larger than the pre/post productivity increase in the control group (which gets standard management training).

Intervention

The intervention consists in a management training and mentorship program comprising 8 sessions (3 hours each) plus homeworks and reviews.
The training program offers to all participants state-of-the-art tools (like the business model canvas, customer validation and development, the balanced scorecard and strategy maps) to diagnose their business, assess their strategy/business model and, if necessary, re-orient or change it. However, the treatment group will also be instructed about how to do this following a scientific approach. The Scientific Approach consists of making decisions following a set of behavioural routines – similar to those used by scientists- comprising four key components:
1. Articulation of a “theory” to design a business model grounded on a well-defined framework of the targeted customer problem;
2. Formulation of explicit/testable/falsifiable hypotheses about the consequences of actions;
3. Collection and analysis of evidence and data or design and execution of experiments to test these hypotheses;
4. Open and critical analysis, evaluation and reflection of the evidence.
Our ‘theory of change’ builds on the intuition, supported by prior research, that, under conditions of uncertainty, many business owners overestimate (false positives) or underestimate (false negatives) the potential of the strategies they follow. Instead, microbusinesses that use a scientific approach make evidence-informed decisions and reduce the number of ‘incorrect’ decisions made. This is expected to have a positive impact on their productivity.

Experimental design

Parallel experimental design, with two arms, pure randomization at the microbusiness level and a 50%/50% allocation ratio.

Design details

Randomization method
Participants randomized into treatment and control using STATA randomization procedure.
Randomization unit
Firm (microbusiness)
Clusters
240 firms
Observations
2400 (240 firms X 10 monthly observation)
Arms
120 microbusinesses control, 120 microbusinesses treatment
Primary outcomes
1. Level of adoption of the scientific approach. More specifically we will measure the pre-post intervention average level of adoption of the scientific approach in both the treatment and control groups using a purposely designed instrument (interview and survey) which allows to calculate an additive measure of adoption of the scientific approach broken down into its 4 components. We expect to detect a significant difference in the increase in the level of adoption of the scientific approach between treated and control microbusinesses. 2. Number, type and timing of strategic iterations -significant business changes- (short-term, 3 months since the start of the intervention). We expect to detect no difference or a slight difference in the number of strategic iterations during and after the intervention between the treated and the control group, with better adopters iterating earlier and more radically. 3. Productivity, measured according to the guidelines of the ONS productivity handbook

Papers from this trial

  1. Camuffo, A., Gambardella, A., Messinese, D., Novelli, E., Paolucci, E., Spina, C. 2023. A Scientific Approach to Entrepreneurial Decision Making: Large Scale Replication and Extension, working paper https://cepr.org/publications/dp12421
  2. Novelli, E., Spina, C. 2023. When do Entrepreneurs Benefit from Acting Like Scientists? A Field Experiment in the UK https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3894831

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords