Education, Work and Peace - promoting opportunities for young adults in Colombia

How to cite

Antunes, Alice. 2019. "Education, Work and Peace - promoting opportunities for young adults in Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003869. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3869-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alice Antunes*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003869
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3869-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2018-12-01 – 2021-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O12, J24, D04
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3869

Abstract

The proposed study aims to evaluate the impact of the project on vocational education, psychosocial support, soft skills training, and labor market placement for vulnerable youth (including displaced youth) in the districts of Bosa and the municipality of Soacha in Colombia. The project is implemented by the Swiss NGO Vivamos Mejor and its local partner Fundación Apoyar.
In low and medium income countries, poor households tend to have a "portfolio of work" rather than a "job" (Blattman and Ralston, 2015). In these context, increasing incomes is not about creating jobs but improving skillsets to raise the quality of work portfolios (Blattman and Ralston, 2015). There is some evidence on the effectiveness of vocational training programs – programs that develop technical skills with the aim of integrating trainees in decent working conditions in the long term (Beerli et al., 2017) – in reducing youth unemployment in Latin America, but the results are not conclusive (Attanasio et al. 2011, 2017; Angrist et al., 2002, 2006; Card et al., 2011). It is perhaps not only hard skills, but also soft, "life" skills, which are lacking, and some initial evidence suggests that complementing vocational education with additional treatments is indeed more effective in obtaining results (see e.g. Bandiera et al., 2018). As far as we know, there are no studies that directly measure the impact of complementing vocational education with "life skills" training. Our study can clarify if, and to what extent, programs with complementary treatments are more effective than programs with only vocational education.
The proposed randomized control trial is composed of 300 vulnerable young adults who will be randomly sorted via lottery into three groups: a control group, a treatment group receiving vocational education (Treatment 1), and a treatment group receiving vocational education, psychosocial support and citizen empowerment training - our life skills training component (Treatment 2). Each group will be composed of 100 young adults.
We expect to find that participants with vocational education and soft skills training are better able to find a job in the formal labor market, making at least the minimum salary (which is more than they would have made in the informal labor market), and receiving social and health security benefits.

Intervention

The proposed randomized control trial is composed of 300 vulnerable young adults randomly sorted via lottery into three groups: a control group, a treatment group receiving vocational education (Treatment 1), and a treatment group receiving vocational education, psychosocial support and citizen empowerment training - our life skills training component (Treatment 2). Each group will be composed of 100 young adults. Training will take one year, administered by a nationally accredited institution. During that year, participants in Treatment 1 also receive soft skills training in the form of: (1) psychosocial support, whereby realistic life plans are developed, traumas are identified and approached by the in-house psychologist, and parents are sensitized on the importance of formal labor market education; (2) labor market placement, where a partner agency works on the employability skills of the participants, such as preparing a good application and job interview skills; (3) strengthening a culture of peace by promoting a set behaviors to overcome internalized violence paradigms instilled by the long internal conflict of the country. Training is offered in human resources, logistics, and administration.

Experimental design

The proposed randomized control trial is composed of 300 vulnerable young adults, who will be randomly sorted via lottery during December 2018 and January 2019 into three groups: a control group, a treatment group receiving vocational education (Treatment 1), and a treatment group receiving vocational education, psychosocial support and citizen empowerment training - our life skills training component (Treatment 2). Each group will be composed of 100 young adults.
We will undertake three overall data collections: a baseline data collection consisting of the details provided under “outcomes” above - prior to the training at the beginning of 2019, a mid-line survey upon completion of training after one year (end of 2019, beginning of 2020), and a final data collection in November 2021 to estimate mid-term effects of the program. Thus, the study will compare both the two treatment groups, and the two treatment groups separately to the control group.
During the baseline data collection, participants take part in four surveys:
- The sign-up survey collects details on wages, hours worked, formal and informal employment, administrative details, and the Wartegg test results;
- The psychological interview conducted by the in-house therapist collects information on life expectations, family situation and support, and a subjective evaluation of participants’ leadership style, conflict resolution style, interpersonal relationships, verbal fluidity, self-confidence and presentation;
- The household visit collects information on the infrastructure of the household, and details on family members (how many, income levels, and so on).
- The randomization survey consists in the Global Preferences Survey, the PCL-C, and an adaptation of Blattman et al (2017)’s survey
There will be a selection process to reduce attrition. This includes: study of submitted CV’s; conducting personal interviews and family visits; processing of a Wartegg test. While we understand that this limits the external validity of our experiment, this is a necessary step given the extreme vulnerability of our target population. The criteria for entering the program include: living in Bosa or Soacha; classified as vulnerable according to SISBEN (Index 1 or 2); not being able to finance a professional education by own means; demonstrated motivation and abilities to study one year; demonstrated family support.

Because the data is sensitive, we are keeping data mapping individuals to their administrative data separate from the main database. Individuals will be given random codenames, which will be their unique identifiers in the main database.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will take place during December 2018 and January 2019 via open lottery. Fundación Apoyar, the implementing partner, is running the randomizations stratified by location (Bosa and Soacha) and by career training offered (human resources, sales, logistics). Randomization is by public lottery where participants take turns drawing a colored tennis ball corresponding to their treatment group (control, treatment 1, treatment 2).
Randomization unit
Individual participants
Clusters
0
Observations
300 individuals
Arms
100 individuals in each treatment group and control
Primary outcomes
Our main outcomes of interest fall into three categories: labor market outcomes, soft skills (risk attitudes, trauma, behavior, vulnerability), and technical competency.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords