Information Diffusion in Agricultural Social Networks under Externalities: A Pest in Honduras

How to cite

ALMANZAR, MIGUEL; Torero, Maximo; Chiarella, Cristina. 2019. "Information Diffusion in Agricultural Social Networks under Externalities: A Pest in Honduras." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003862. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3862-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

MIGUEL ALMANZAR* , Maximo Torero , Cristina Chiarella

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003862
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3862-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-03-01 – 2020-12-31
Countries
Private
Secondary IDs
O13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3862

Abstract

We use agriculture social network data from over 100 communities in Honduras and identify farmers to target and train on new technology and practices to prevent and control a new pest that posits negative externalities to the community. A randomized controlled trial compares targeting approaches in their effectiveness for information diffusion within existing networks. The targeting strategies rely on: community leaders of existing institutions, theory-driven network statistics, community nominated to best transmit a message, and random farmers within the network. The comparison provides information on the cost-effectiveness and scalability of these targeting strategies

Intervention

An individual/personal training session with selected farmers in communities affected y the yellow aphid in Honduras. These trainings are aimed to transmit three key messages or lessons: i) how to identify and monitor the yellow aphid in sorghum and maize, ii) how to control the yellow aphid once it has affected the crop, and iii) how do pest spatial externalities affect the community, not just the individual, and how can they be prevented through cooperation.
Solutions will be shared with the participants through multimedia and interactive learning activities that are adapted to the local context. We will also provide each participant with the tools to implement these solutions: a calendar that contains the key messages from the training and serves as a tool to keep their scouting records, and yellow traps. In addition, each training participant receives a set of calendars and yellow traps for identified members in their community, to which we ask them to deliver them to and communicate the lessons learned during the training.

Experimental design

To compare the effectiveness of the different methods on reaching most farmers and achieve coordination, we will test three different injection points based on defined characteristics and positionality in the social networks. These three injection points will be compared with a group of communities where random farmers initially receive the information. In addition, these four treatment conditions will be compared to a control group, where no farmer will receive the training.
The network characteristics that define the injection points are:
a. Local Leaders: social capital and institutions
b. Diffusion central: network theory/statistics
c. Community nominated: the people’s voice
d. Random farmers: natural diffusion

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office computer on baseline data.
Randomization unit
Communities (caseríos)
Clusters
221 communities
Observations
3,025
Arms
a. Local Leaders: social capital and institutions: 28 communities b. Diffusion central: network theory/statistics: 28 communities c. Community nominated: the people’s voice: 28 communities d. Random farmers: natural diffusion: 27 communities e. Pure control: 110 communities
Primary outcomes
Identification and Knowledge: Correctly identifies yellow aphid from different images, Names unique characteristics of yellow aphid Use of Solutions: Monitoring, alertness and diligence: Reports performing regular scouting for yellow aphid, Keeps a yellow aphid scouting, record on their calendar, Estimates number of yellow aphid from images, Correctly identifies number of areas and places were to perform yellow aphid scouting Use of Resources: Yellow traps and home-made insecticide solution, Identifies yellow traps and detergent solution as effective measures to control yellow aphids, Correctly knows how install yellow traps (spacing and placement), Correctly identifies ingredients and quantities to make sustainable detergent solution to use as insecticide, Installed yellow traps in the previous agricultural season, Applied detergent solution as insecticide if exposed to yellow aphid, Knowledge of management of infected plants and weeds to minimize further contagion Collective action and externalities: Received information or heard of yellow aphid infestation in the community from neighbors, Provided information of yellow aphid infestation in the community to their neighbors, Received training and calendar tool package from an injection point trained in the experiment, Received training, calendar tool package, or information on yellow aphid from a non-injection point (other trained by an injection point of the experiment), Used calendar tool to record neighbors s/he informed and/or trained in the previous agriculture season Effectiveness of training in final outcomes: Probability of having had a yellow aphid problem in the past agricultural season, Probability of planting and not harvesting due to yellow aphid, Quantity of sorghum lost on field and quantity harvested, Sorghum productivity or yields, Food security: Probability of being hungry and availability of grains in the household

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords