Playful Learning: Towards a More Intentional Practice in Norwegian Preschool Groups

How to cite

Størksen, Ingunn; Geldhof, John; Solli, Ingeborg; Lenes, Ragnhild; Braak, Dieuwer; Rege, Mari. 2019. "Playful Learning: Towards a More Intentional Practice in Norwegian Preschool Groups." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003852. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3852-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ingunn Størksen* , John Geldhof , Ingeborg Solli , Ragnhild Lenes , Dieuwer Braak , Mari Rege

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003852
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3852-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-08-15 – 2035-01-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I20, H42
Secondary IDs
The Research Council of Norway. Grant no. 270703
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3852

Abstract

In this study, we implement a large-scale randomized field experiment in which preschool teachers in Norway introduce a new Norwegian Playful Learning Curriculum with five-year-olds. The intention with this curriculum is to stimulate socio-emotional, self-regulatory, language and math skills, which numerous studies have identified as foundational for future learning and development (Duncan et al., 2007; Hall, Welsh, Bierman, & Nix, 2016; Rabiner, Godwin, & Dodge, 2016). A total of 126 Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC) centers participate in the field experiment, with 63 randomly selected centers in the treatment group.

The Norwegian Playful Learning Curriculum is a comprehensive structured curriculum with play-based activities for five-year-olds. We study the curriculum in the universal preschool context of Norway. The prevailing curriculum in Norway is very non-specific and unstructured, and therefore Norway provides an excellent platform for investigating the effects of a structured curriculum on children’s skills.

The Norwegian Playful Learning Curriculum was developed in a previous research project called the Agder Project (Leveling the playing feld: An intervention to promote school readiness and human potential - https://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2241/history/18261). This project emphazised user involvement from teachers in the development of the intervention. Researchers in the Agder-project, in close collaboration with 42 ECEC teachers in Agder, developed The Norwegian Playful Learning Curriculum and tested treatment effects. The curriculum was developed during a 15 credit point training with the teachers. This is the curriculum that treatment teachers in the current project implement, and thus this RCT in many ways represents a replication of the Agder Project. Still, there are some important distinctions between the two. First of all teachers in the Agder Project received extensive training. Such extensive training is too expensive to give to all future users of the curriculum, and the training in itself might have caused effects in the Agder Project. Although user involvement was an advantage in the Agder Project to create an ecologically valid curriculum, a major drawback was that possible effects may be related to extraordinary engagement from the teachers and not the actual curriculum. Furthermore, ECEC centers in the treatment group of the Agder Project received funding for substitute teachers while the participating teachers implemented the intervention, and this in itself might give positive treatment effects. In order to detangle these effects, and to test whether the curriculum can easily be scaled up at a low cost, in the current study teachers are only offered a one day course introducing them to The Norwegian Playful Learning Curriculum before implementation. In addition to the book containing this curriculum, they receive a complementary video bank illustrating pedagogical principals and examples. Teachers receive weekly electronic nudges or reminders to give extra attention to vulnerable children, e.g. children lacking or falling behind on socio-emotional, self-regulatory, language and math skills.

Intervention

In this project we study the effects of the Norwegian Playful Learning Curriculum, see https://gan.aschehoug.no/nettbutikk/lekbasert-laering-gan.html . The treatment centers also had access to a complementary web-resource, see www.lekbasert.no with examples and theory related to the curriculum. The curriculum is developed to stimulate children's early math, language, socio-emotional and self-regulatory skills. Before implementation of the intervention teachers received a one-day introduction course to the Norwegian Playful Learning Curriculum. During implementation teachers received weekly electronic nudges that reminded them to give attention to vulnerable children, for example children with poor or lacking skills within early math, language, social competence or self-regulation.

Experimental design

We investigate effects of the Norwegian Playful Learning Curriculum in an RCT with 126 participating daycare centers. After recruitment, the daycare director and the teacher(s) responsible for the five year olds, signed an agreement detailing responsibilities and expectations. Moreover, they assisted us in collecting informed consent from the parents. Thereafter, the centers were randomized (block randomization) into treated and control.

Teachers in treated group implemented the Norwegian Playful Learning Curriculum in their daycare center during the school year 2017/2018 (September 1st 2017 to May 31st 2018). The teachers committed to spend at least eight hours every week working with the playful learning activities in the curriculum. The ECEC centers in the control group continued as before, and were given access to the intervention, material and training, when the implementation was completed.

We assess the children in August 2017 (pre-test), June 2018 (first post-test).

Children’s math and literacy in first grade of school will be measured with the aid of standardized mapping tests that schools routinely conduct during spring of first grade, second grade and third grade.

Further longitudinal data will be drawn from official registries: National tests from 5th and 8th grade, GPA from compulsory school, choice of subjects for upper secondary school, and completed upper secondary school by age 20.

Design details

Randomization method
We randomly split the centers between a control and a treatment group using block randomization based on municipality and size of preschool centers.
Randomization unit
Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC) centers.
Clusters
126 ECEC centers.
Observations
Approximately 1300 children.
Arms
63 treatment centers and 63 control centers.
Primary outcomes
First post-intervention assessment (June, 2018): Ani Banani Math Test (ABMT) (Størksen & Mosvold 2013) for assessing mathematics skills, the Norwegian Vocabulary Test (NVT) (Størksen et al. 2013) for assessment of language, Digit Span Test (Wechsler 1991) for assessment of working memory (an important aspect within self-regulation) and Preschool Early Numeracy Skills Screener (PENS) (Purpura, Reid, Eiland & Baroody, 2015). Post-intervention assessment : Children’s math and literacy in first grade of school will be measured with the aid of standardized mapping tests that schools routinely conduct during spring of first grade, second grade and third grade. Further longitudinal data will be drawn from official registries: National tests from 5th and 8th grade, GPA from compulsory school, choice of subjects for upper secondary school, and completed upper secondary school by age 20.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords