Pre-departure Interventions for Migrant Domestic Workers

How to cite

Steinmayr, Andreas; Barsbai, Toman; Licuanan, Victoria; Tiongson, Erwin; Yang, Dean. 2019. "Pre-departure Interventions for Migrant Domestic Workers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003837. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3837-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Andreas Steinmayr* , Toman Barsbai , Victoria Licuanan , Erwin Tiongson , Dean Yang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003837
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3837-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2014-05-26 – 2019-03-30
Countries
Hong Kong (), Philippines (), Saudi Arabia ()
JEL codes
D9, J61
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3837

Abstract

This trial studies the impact of four pre-departure interventions for migrant domestic workers from the Philippines. Interventions take place about two weeks before migrants depart for the destination country. The study is based on 2,000 female domestic workers bound for Hong Kong and Saudi Arabia.

First, the "gift and photo" intervention encourages migrants to introduce themselves to the employer with a small gift that we provide and to show a family picture. The intervention aims at improving the treatment of the domestic worker by her employer.

Second, a short savings module and third, regular savings reminders aim at improving financial decision making and encourage migrants to save the targeted share of income.

Fourth, an intervention where experienced domestic workers share their experiences, problems faced, and suggestions to overcome these problems aims at managing expectations, faster adjustment, and overall higher well-being.

Intervention

Gift and photo intervention

At the end of the baseline interview, domestic workers assigned to this intervention are given a pack of dried mangoes (a specialty in the Philippines) and are encouraged to give them as a small introductory gift to their employer’s family. They are also encouraged to show a family photo (including the domestic worker) to signal to the employer’s family that the DW is a human being with a family and a personal background too. This intervention also signals the DW’s good intentions for the relationship with the employer. Specific instructions provide guidance for avoiding cross-cultural misunderstandings (e.g., by showing a picture where family members are dressed too lightly).

The intervention is motivated by the observation that many former domestic workers report that they are treated very poorly by members of the employer’s household and that they are not respected as human beings. The intervention aims to affect the relationship between DW and the employer by changing the starting situation and thereby creating a different trajectory of the relationship. In particular, the intervention aims at portraying DWs as human beings with a family and friends in the Philippines.

Experience sharing

Experienced domestic workers share their experiences, problems faced, ways of coping with problems, etc. The information in the experience sharing intervention is grouped around 3 themes: work experiences (including hours worked, specific concerns such as the large size of houses to be cleaned and number of family members served, hours of rest/sleep etc.), relationships with the employer (including cross-cultural communications, salary issues, food issues, etc.) and relationship with the families left behind. This first-hand experience sharing is meant to increase the credibility of the content. This intervention tries to manage expectations regarding what the DWs will face when they actually work abroad and provide them with strategies to cope with potential problems.

Savings module

The new savings module to be evaluated is comprehensive and focuses only on a few messages. In terms of content, the module offers direct guidance on a) prioritizing and distinguishing between expenditures that are needs and those that are merely wants, b) creating a joint financial plan with their family prior to departure, including the amount and use of remittances, c) an exercise in making a budget with a template showing how much money should be saved to reach a specific savings goal after two years, d) the importance of keeping some savings in a bank directly under the control of the DW. The pedagogy is interactive, e.g. using role-play to illustrate how to deal with financial requests from relatives and neighbors, and asking DWs who have already had experience working abroad to share the financial results of their time abroad and lessons learned. A short comics-style handout that DWs can bring with them to use as a reminder is also provided.

Savings reminder

Regularly sent text messages encouraging migrants to save the targeted share of their income. Due to logistical challenges of updating cellphone numbers, this intervention is carried out only for a small subsample.

Experimental design

Baseline interviews are conducted immediately before a mandatory pre-departure training for domestic workers. The training usually takes place a few weeks before departure. The assignment of the gift and photo intervention takes place during the baseline interview. The intervention is randomly assigned with 50% probability at the individual level and the randomization is independent of the randomization at the group level.

Group-level interventions (savings module and experience sharing) are randomized at the classroom level. Any class is either assigned to none or any of the two group-level interventions. No class is assigned to both.

Savings reminders are randomly assigned at a later point in time for the subsample for which a cellphone number is available.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done beforehand using a Stata algorithm based on available registration lists.
Randomization unit
The gift and photo intervention is randomized at the individual level. A savings module and experience sharing by former domestic workers were randomized at the classroom level. Savings reminders are randomly assigned at the individual level at a later point in time for the subsample for which a cellphone number is available.
Clusters
210 classrooms
Observations
2000 migrant domestic workers (1200 going to KSA, 800 going to Hong Kong)
Arms
Gift and photo 1000 individuals assigned to treatment, 1000 assigned to control Experience sharing and savings module: 55 classrooms assigned to the savings module, 27 assigned to experience sharing (KSA only), 128 assigned to control
Primary outcomes
Gift and photo intervention: treatment of domestic workers by the employer, subjective wellbeing Experience sharing: Managing expectations regarding conditions abroad leads to faster adjustment, better work performance, higher employer satisfaction, better treatment, higher sense of wellbeing Savings module: increase in savings, involvement of the family in financial planning Savings reminder: increase in savings
Secondary outcomes
see analysis plan

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords