Evaluating Extension Services and Productive Cash Grants in Rural Brazil
How to cite
Gonzalez-Navarro, Marco; Szerman, Dimitri. 2019. "Evaluating Extension Services and Productive Cash Grants in Rural Brazil." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003802. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3802-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The state-sponsored Brazilian “Programa Fomento Rural”, created in 2011, aims to support poor smallholder farming households. Under the working hypothesis that farmers often cannot increase production due to lack of productive knowledge or resource constraints, this program couples rural extension services with non-reimbursable cash grants, which must be invested into agreed upon projects. The program strives to improve household welfare, including food security, by improving farmers’ production capacities. As of May 2018, nearly 200,000 families had enrolled. According to qualitative assessments, the program has been successful at increasing total farm investments and agricultural production as well as diversifying agricultural produce.
The goal of this project is to evaluate the Fomento program using a multi-site randomized controlled trial to quantitatively assess Fomento's impact on production and wellbeing, and to uncover the channels through which it alleviates rural poverty. The study takes place in three states of Brazil with different socioeconomic characteristics – Rio Grande do Sul, Minas Gerais, and Para. Ultimately, this study will test the effectiveness of a graduation-style program that couples productive asset grants to extension services on farm production and household wellbeing.
Intervention
We work with program managers to implement a randomized rollout of the program among the targeted population across three Brazilian states. The targeted population consists of rural households currently enrolled in Bolsa Familia (Brazil’s flagship cash transfer program for the poor). These households are selected at random from Bolsa Familia’s database (Cadastro Único) and screened for program eligibility. A subset is allocated to early treatment, and the control group is simply allocated to future treatment.
We can use randomization due to the staggered rollout nature of the program. “Treatment” families start receiving the Fomento program in 2018 (Minas Gerais) or 2019 (Pará and Rio Grande do Sul). “Control” families do not receive it during the duration of the evaluation, but they are slated to receive Fomento after this study ends, in 2021. Hence, the intervention is totally public, and there is no hidden component.
Families selected to participate in the Fomento program receive non-reimbursable cash grants along with rural extension services. Rural extension is provided by trained technicians employed by public companies and has several components. First, the household receives a diagnosis of what it can do to increase its production. Next, based on this diagnosis, the technician elaborates a tailored business plan in consultation with the household, specifying the steps that the household must follow to achieve the targets. For example, the technician (extension worker) can recommend the adoption of new practices, purchase of equipment, or a change in the crop mix. The household then receives 60 percent of the total cash grant of R$2,400.00 (USD $650). The non-reimbursable funds are transferred by the Ministry of Social Development (MDS) directly to the beneficiary families through the Bolsa Família Program payment structure. This cash must be invested accordingly, adhering to the business plan previously developed. The extension agent then verifies that the household made the necessary investments and the remaining 40 percent of the cash grant is then released. Households are then provided technical assistance, with 5 to 10 visits during the course of one year to help implement the business plan.
Experimental design
This research project employs a randomized controlled trial to investigate the impact of FOMENTO on indicators of interest. The trials will be conducted across the states of Para, Minas Gerais, and Rio Grande do Sul.
In each state, the respective EMATERs (state agencies in charge of managing FOMENTO) selected a number of municipalities for this research project (20 municipalities in Para; 15 in Minas Gerais and; 46 in Rio Grande do Sul). Using Cadastro Unico, MDS then listed all eligible families for the Fomento program in those municipalities (i.e., families living in rural areas with income per capita less than R$85 who have not benefited from the program before). Using this sampling frame, the EMATERs then shortlisted approximately 1,000 families in each of their respective states.
In Minas Gerais, the Fomento project was conducted under the name “Dom Helder” with the Ministry of Agrarian Development (MDA) as the primary resource of funds. Together with the MDA’s Agency for Technical Assistance and Rural Extension (ANATER), MDS also played a key role in the program articulation. The key difference in this arrangement vis-a-vis the arrangements in PA and RS is that in Dom Helder the extension company (ANATER-MG) is paid on a per-visit basis, and more visits per family are scheduled.
Dom Helder’s lottery had to be conducted before the data collection started, because of ANATER’s schedule. Out of a list of families compiled by MDS (based on Cadastro Único), ANATER shortlisted households to participate in the lottery. The research team then conducted the lottery designating families into the control and treatment groups. Families in the treatment group started receiving the Fomento by September of 2018, while those in the control group will receive it in 2020.
Data collection strategy:
This research project plans two waves of primary data collection using household survey instruments developed by the research team. In each wave, 2577 households from treatment and control groups will be interviewed.
The first wave (baseline) took place between July and September of 2018 before the treatment was delivered to the selected households. The second wave (end line) will re-interview the same households 18 months after treatment is delivered.
Data collection was performed by a specialized firm hired by MDS through an open public tender. MDS also hired an independent consultant to assess the quality of data collection activities by performing field spot checks and random phone calls to interviewed families will help to ensure data quality. The survey instrument was administered using tablets, with automatic field validation, consistency checks, and voice recording.
There is one survey instrument. It will be answered by the person who spends more time in rural activities within the household and contains questions on land use and crop choices; water usage; income; labor, farm production; technology use; household consumption; food security; women empowerment and subjective well-being.
Finally, we may use automated response calls to mobile phones to collect high-frequency data on consumption patterns and food security. Automated calls are a cost-effective way to collect data on issues such as food consumption and reactions to weather shocks, which require high-frequency monitoring. Despite being economically vulnerable, up to 85% of the target households use mobile phones, and coverage in the region is good.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.