Reducing Mistreatment of Migrant Domestic Workers

How to cite

Bartos, Vojtech; Yang, Dean; Tiongson, Erwin; Steinmayr, Andreas; Licuanan, Victoria; Barsbai, Toman. 2019. "Reducing Mistreatment of Migrant Domestic Workers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003788. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3788-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Vojtech Bartos* , Dean Yang , Erwin Tiongson , Andreas Steinmayr , Victoria Licuanan , Toman Barsbai

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003788
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3788-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-02-25 – 2019-04-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D9, J61
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3788

Abstract

This project investigates whether Filipino migrant domestic workers are treated better by their employers in Saudi Arabia and Hong Kong after an intervention that suggested them to bring a small gift and to show a family photo to their prospective employer during their first meeting. The first part of this study (originally registered with the funding agency 3ie) found these positive effects (also in a revealed-preference way). In the second part, we use an incentivized online experiment with representative samples of upper- and middle-income populations of Saudi Arabia and Hong Kong. Participants ("employers") can redistribute money between themselves and Filipinas. The games allow us to study both pro- and anti-social behavior. Before their decisions, participating Filipinas either reveal 1) no additional information about themselves, 2) they show photos of their families, 3) they send a small online gift, or 4) both. We also examine if the effect differs when the gift or photo are presented during the first round, or during a second round, two weeks later. To separate mechanisms, we also introduce a default allocation of money in the redistribution games. In the second round, we also measure changes in implicit associations using a single-target Implicit Association Test.

Intervention

This is the description of the intervention in the second part of the project. We use an incentivized online experiment with representative samples of upper- and middle-income populations of Saudi Arabia and Hong Kong. Participants ("employers") can redistribute money between themselves and Filipinas. The games allow us to study both pro- and anti-social behavior. Before their decisions, participating Filipinas either reveal 1) no additional information about themselves, 2) they show photos of their families, 3) they send a small online gift, or 4) both. We also examine if the effect differs when the gift or photo are presented during the first round, or during a second round, two weeks later. To separate mechanisms, we also introduce a default allocation of money in the redistribution games. In the second round, we also measure changes in implicit associations using a single-target Implicit Association Test.

Experimental design

The incentivized online experiment with individuals from Saudi Arabia and Hong Kong aims to understand the behavioral change in individuals in response to the treatment in the first part of the project, where the treatment bundles together several potential mechanisms. We identify three channels through which the treatment effect might occur:
1) feeling of reciprocal obligations by the employers,
2) decreased social distance between employers and domestic workers (DWs),
3) and employers’ increased moral cost of causing harm to DWs.
These channels should result either in more altruistic feeling of employers towards the DWs and/or lead to reduced antisocial behavior. We also hypothesize that kind actions at the first instance of an interaction promote kind reciprocal behavior from the other party, relative to when the kind action only comes at a later stage.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual level (participants in an online survey).
Clusters
We recruit 1200 KSA and 1200 HK first round participants in the role of “senders” using survey companies in KSA and HK. We expect a final sample of 1001 KSA and 1001 HK participants completing both rounds. The only sampling criteria is that 1) individuals are locals and of middle/high income bracket, and we will have 2) males and females in the same proportion. The companies will incentivize the participants using the existing incentive schemes they use. The bonus points are equivalent to money.
Observations
2002 individuals (1001 in HK, 1001 in KSA)
Arms
Control treatment: 143 in HK, 143 in KSA Gift treatment round 1: 143 in HK, 143 in KSA Gift treatment round 2: 143 in HK, 143 in KSA Photo treatment round 1: 143 in HK, 143 in KSA Photo treatment round 2: 143 in HK, 143 in KSA Gift + photo treatment round 1: 143 in HK, 143 in KSA Gift + photo treatment round 2: 143 in HK, 143 in KSA
Primary outcomes
Dictator game transfer : amount shared with a Filipina
Secondary outcomes
6 binary dictator games; Single-target Implicit Association Test; survey questions asking about treatment of a hypothetical Filipino domestic worker; survey question asking about general perceptions of Filipinos

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords