Economic Distress and Out-Group Discrimination

How to cite

Zimmermann, Florian; Voth, Hans-Joachim; Marechal, Michel; Fouka, Vasiliki. 2019. "Economic Distress and Out-Group Discrimination." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003785. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3785-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Florian Zimmermann* , Hans-Joachim Voth , Michel Marechal , Vasiliki Fouka

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003785
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3785-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-01-14 – 2019-07-26
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3785

Abstract

Conflict between groups of humans is as old as mankind. Millions of people have perished as a result of inter-group violence over the course of history, and continuous conflict has arguably shaped human behaviors and forms of collaboration. Milder forms of outgroup discrimination and in-group bias, such as xenophobia and agitation against immigrants, increasingly dominate modern-day politics in developed countries. What drives people to hate others who are different from themselves? We propose to examine a longstanding hypothesis: whether poverty and corresponding economic distress has a causal effect on out-group discrimination and xenophobia. We conduct experiments amongst respondents with low socio-economic status. We will randomly transfer funds that are sufficient to improve the economic condition of study participants, and examine their attitudes towards ‘others’ – comparing responses with other participants who are equally poor, but did not receive an income transfer. Hence, in contrast to previous work, our approach exogenously manipulates actual economic distress and thereby allows us to measure its causal impact on xenophobic attitudes and behavior. Moreover, our study design will reveal whether targeted income transfers are an effective tool in reducing hatred of foreigners and will allow us to illuminate different psychological mechanisms that shape the relation between poverty and out-group bias

Intervention

We conduct experiments amongst respondents with low socio-economic status. We will randomly transfer funds that are sufficient to improve the economic condition of study participants, and examine their attitudes towards ‘others’ – comparing responses with other participants who are equally poor, but did not receive an income transfer.

Experimental design

We conduct experiments amongst respondents with low socio-economic status. We will randomly transfer funds that are sufficient to improve the economic condition of study participants. We then measure behavior and attitudes towards outgroups, using a series allocation decisions as well as an implicit association test. We compare responses between the treatment group (received transfer) and a control group (no transfer).

Design details

Randomization method
Participants are randomized into a treatment and a control group. This is done in the experimenter's office by a computer. One third will be assigned to the treatment group and receive an unconditional $200 cash transfer to their UAS ClinCard ten days after the baseline survey is closed. The control group will not receive any cash transfer. We will stratify the randomization based on the following two dimensions: • A dummy variable whether subjects are white or non-white • A dummy variable for the following subgroups: those who score below-median in the communal moral values index (5, 6) and those who score above-median (those whose score equals the median will be randomly assigned to one of the two). This results in four strata (white/high moral values index; white/low moral values index; non-white/high moral values index; non-white/low moral values index). To deal with the possibility of missing values in these two baseline variables, we will create a fifth strata consisting of the group of respondents with missing values.
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
500 individual participants
Observations
500 individual participants
Arms
500 individual participants - 1/3 in treatment, 2/3 in control
Primary outcomes
We focus on two outcomes. First, we will measure xenophobic behavior using a donation experiment involving real financial consequences. Following the literature, we choose immigrants as the target outgroup and manipulate whether the donation goes to an organization that actively combats immigration, an organization that supports immigration, and a neutral organization. Specifically, we inform subjects that we will donate $100 on their behalf to three different organizations: i) the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) as an anti-immigration organization, ii) the National Immigration Forum (NIF) as a pro-immigration organization, and iii) the American Cancer Society (ACS) as a neutral control organization. Subjects have the opportunity to reduce or eliminate those donations. Decisions are implemented using a slider. For each organization, the slider is set at $100. By moving the slider to the left, subjects can reduce the donation in steps of $1. The donation decisions for FAIR and NIF reveal the extent to which the cash transfer reduces anti-immigration and/or increases pro-immigration attitudes. We add ACS for obfuscation purposes. Second, we will administer an Implicit Association Test (IAT) to measure subjects’ implicit bias towards outgroups (immigrants) relative to US citizens. We adapted the IAT to our specific context. Subjects will be instructed to classify names (e.g., Houssain, John) and words (e.g., terrible, love) into the four categories “Immigrant vs. American” and “Good vs. Bad” as fast as possible using the left and right arrows on their keyboard. The underlying idea of this test is that individuals with stronger implicit xenophobic attitudes will be faster when “Good” and “American” or “Immigrant” and “Bad” paired rather than “Bad” and “American” or “Immigrant” and “Good” because the former pairs exhibit stronger mental associations.
Secondary outcomes
1. We elicit subjects’ self-reported emotional state and stress levels to test this longstanding hypothesis. 2. We will administer a Symbol-Correspondence Task to obtain a measure of cognitive functioning. 3. We elicit individuals’ sensitivity to social desirability using the well-established social desirability scale. 4. We measure participants’ self-reported self-esteem and locus of control. 5. We assess whether financial distress affects the perception of immigrants as a threat to society. Living through times of financial hardship might increase focus on specific aspects of in-group-outgroup relations and as a consequence might change the perception of the out-group. We focus on three different aspects: First, immigration could be seen as increased competition for jobs in the labor market or resources in the social welfare system. Second, immigration could be associated with concerns about crime and terrorism. Third, immigration might be seen as a threat to the in-group’s values and traditions. All these perceptions might shift once the financial situation improves. To test this empirically, we elicit participants’ perceptions on all three aspects.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords