New Public Lighting in Informal Settlements: A Field Experiment in Cape Town, South Africa
How to cite
Borofsky, Yael; Günther, Isabel. 2020. "New Public Lighting in Informal Settlements: A Field Experiment in Cape Town, South Africa." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003777. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3777-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Rapid urbanization exacerbates public service challenges that disproportionately affect poor residents of informal settlements. The literature focuses on the barriers to and impact of access to basic services, such as water and sanitation, but public streetlighting is understudied. However, observational studies suggest that public lighting may help people feel safe, as well as access shared infrastructure, such as toilets, after dark. In South Africa, existing policies promote high-mast lights in informal settlements, despite concerns that they provide dim light and cast strong shadows, except in areas directly under the light. We use a cluster randomized controlled trial to test the efficacy and impact of one alternative — solar public lights mounted onto residents’ houses — in a Cape Town informal settlement. We test whether these lights provide effective public lighting and overcome obstacles to conventional streetlights in informal settlements. We use novel pedestrian motion sensors to measure nighttime mobility, lux meters to measure brightness, service requests to measure theft, vandalism, and malfunction, as well as surveys to measure nighttime outdoor activities, perceptions of safety, infrastructure satisfaction, and experience of crime. This study is the first, to our knowledge, to test the impact of public lighting on life at night in an informal settlement.
Intervention
The intervention is a 10-watt, outdoor, wall-mounted, solar-powered LED floodlight, which comes with a 15-watt solar panel, installed on the outside of residents’ homes, typically above or near the front door of the house. The light is programmed to turn on automatically during evening civil twilight and to turn off automatically during morning civil twilight. Once the light turns on, it moves through a brightness schedule (or, dimming profile), which adjusts the brightness of the light throughout the nighttime hours to manage the battery and ensure the light can burn for an entire night on a single day’s charge. This light should provide better lighting than the existing 30-40-meter-tall high-mast lights for two main reasons. First, the light is installed at roughly the height of each structure (about 3 m), meaning light shines directly into public or semi-public spaces rather than reflecting off of roofs, which wastes light and creates strong shadows for pedestrians. Second, the lights are distributed throughout the settlement, providing illumination in areas that may be situated far from the high-mast lights and thus, receive little to no light at all.
Households receive the light free of charge. Randomization is done at the path segment level and compound level (see the Experimental Design section). Compounds can be thought of as cul-de-sacs or shared semi-private spaces within the settlement that are used by several households, but are often gated. Every household that has a front door facing a selected path segment or compound receives a light during the intervention phase. At the end of the study, all households in the informal settlement will receive a free light.
Note: The idea for the use of wall-mounted lighting for public lighting in an informal settlement was developed as part of the doctoral work of ETH Zurich Institute for Science, Technology, and Policy (ISTP) PhD student Stephanie Briers who is pursuing a PhD in architecture.
Experimental design
We use a cluster-randomized controlled trial to study the impact of an alternative public lighting technology that is intended to provide brighter lighting on the dense, narrow paths in informal settlements than is currently provided by the two existing high-mast lights. High-mast lights can provide bright lighting on paths that are nearby, but they can also cast strong shadows and provide insufficient lighting in areas that are farther away. Until now, the impact of public lighting has rarely been quantitatively evaluated in poor, urban neighborhoods. The randomization allows us to test both the efficacy of the new technology and the impact of a public lighting intervention.
We stratify the entire path network of one poor informal settlement in Cape Town, South Africa with about 800 houses into pedestrian path segments and compounds (cul-de-sacs or shared semi-private spaces within the settlement that are used by several households, but are often gated).
We randomize 114 path segments (out of 133 possible segments) of the informal settlement into 49 treatment and 65 control path segments and the 50 compounds into 24 treatment and 26 control compounds. By randomizing at the path segment and compound level, we ensure that the treatment makes logical sense to a pedestrian or other user of public space at night. In other words, the intervention results in lit path segments, rather than randomly lit houses that might create patchy non-uniform lighting, or disconnected lit areas that do not enable residents to pass from one part of the neighborhood to another on a completely lit route. In this way, we are able to compare lit paths and compounds to unlit paths and compounds to analyze the effects of living on a lit path segment (or compound) on a variety of outcomes. Moreover, we can test whether lit paths or compounds are used more often using data gathered with the pedestrian motion sensors.
On treatment path segments and compounds, all households with a front door facing onto to the path or compound receive a free light for the entire six-month study period, which they can keep afterwards. The control households will receive a free light at the end of the study.
A house is only considered to be part of a path segment or compound if the front door is facing it. Note that we initially identified 133 path segments, but only allocated a total of 114 (49 + 65) path segments to the treatment and control group. The reason is that some of these paths (5 of the treatment, 12 of the control group) did not have any houses with front doors on them. Hence, these paths are excluded from the experiment. The remaining two segments are the central streets, which we also removed from the experiment because they are vehicular through-routes and cannot be accurately measured with sensors. In addition, some houses do not have front doors that open onto a path segment or a compound (e.g., houses that face the central street) so these houses will be excluded from the analysis.
Design details
Materials
Papers from this trial
- Borofsky, Y. and Günther, I., Bringing Light To The Dark — Can Solar Public Lighting Improve Nighttime Life For The Urban Poor? Working Paper. 2022. https://ethz.ch/content/dam/ethz/special-interest/gess/development-economics-dam/Publications/Light_Solar_Public.pdf
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.