Mental accounting in sustainable consumption choices
How to cite
Weiß, Anna; Lauer, Thomas. 2018. "Mental accounting in sustainable consumption choices." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003727. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3727-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
A growing branch of literature focuses on how to induce people to choose more sustainable products. There are some promising approaches, but they all target only one, independent dimension of pro-environmental behavior (PEB) at one point in time.
However, PEBs are not a set of decisions made independently from each other. Several studies have found behavioral spillovers between PEBs. These spillovers can be either positive (Lanzini and Thøgersen 2014; e.g. Margetts and Kashima 2017) – meaning that having performed a PEB in the past makes a future PEB more likely – or negative (e.g. Chatelain et al. 2018). Besides the usual explanations like moral licensing (e.g. Mazar and Zhong 2010) and rebound effects (e.g. Haan and Girod 2009) for negative behavioral spillovers, Haan and Girod (2009) have proposed mental accounting (cf. Thaler 1980; 2008).
Only few studies so far have considered spillovers between PEB and sustainable consumer choices. Lanzini and Thøgersen (2014) as well as Margetts and Kashima (2017) investigate whether green shopping decisions spill over to PEB, while Thøgersen and Ölander (2003) examined how these choices evolve over time. In a field experiment in China, Zhou et al. (2017) find positive spillovers from PEB to the willingness to pay for eco-labelled rice. Chatelain et al. (2018) test the theory that mental accounting not only influences expenditures, but also environmental-friendly behavior. They find that people are therefore unlikely to perform two similar PEBs within a short time frame if these behaviors are strongly linked to each other.
This study will be the first one to investigate the spillover between pro-environmental choices in an incentivized online experiment with high stakes, compared to prior experiments that considered for example recycling efforts. The results may foster the discussion of whether hoping for a catalyzing effect of one PEB to another is counterproductive (cf. Thøgersen and Crompton 2009).
Intervention
Control condition: only online shop
Immediate treatment: donation task directly before online shop
Lagged treatment: donation task one week before online shop
Experimental design
In the first stage of the experiment, participants receive an endowment of 100 € and are invited to donate to an environmental cause (Margetts and Kashima 2017; Hahnel and Brosch 2018), while the rest of this money goes to their bank account. The participants know that 10 % of them will be randomly drawn for the payments to be implemented.
In the second stage, participants purchase at an online shop, which offers products in at least one sustainable and one conventional variety (Demarque et al. 2015). The different options of the same product will only vary in whether they are conventional or sustainable, where the latter will be clearly labelled. Participants have a budget of 25 € to spend and again a 10 % chance of receiving the goods they have purchased (this lottery is independent of that for stage one). The share of sustainable products purchased will then be used as an indicator of pro-environmental choices.
The experiment will be divided into two experimental treatments: In the immediate treatment both parts of the experiment are played subsequently, while in the lagged treatment part 2 of the experiment is conducted one week after part 1. In both cases, the instructions will only be given for the part the participants are currently working on in order to prevent strategic behavior. Participants in the control condition only play part 2.
Both stages are similar in that their endowment is windfall money, the winning chance is equally high, and the decision is between either being sustainable or keeping more (either money or products) to oneself. By comparing the results from the immediate and the lagged treatment, it can be tested what impact the strength of the mental linkage has. in addition, by means of a short survey at the end of the experiment, the results can be validated through the participants answers.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.