Pilot testing of a parent record of child health
How to cite
Rego, Ryan; Langat, Philemon; Lilford, Richard; Watson, Samuel. 2018. "Pilot testing of a parent record of child health." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003681. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3681-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Diarrhoea is one of the two most significant causes of death in children under five (1,2), with inadequate water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) being a significant risk factor for diarrhoea. In several low and middle-income countries (LMICs), water and sanitation interventions are underway and planned to deal with inadequate water and sanitation provision. However, collecting relevant data on whether people are experiencing diarrhoea on a sufficient scale to monitor the effects of water and sanitation interventions has been proven difficult (3). The standard questions used, for example in the Demographic Health Surveys, enquire as to if a child has had diarrhoea over the past two weeks. These retrospective questions with a long recall period suffer from several biases, including recall bias, social desirability, and (in the case of longitudinal studies), the Hawthorne effect. We hypothesise that questioning if a child has had diarrhoea within the last 24 hours, covering the most immediate past period, would improve the accuracy of data collection. This would be combined with other measures, such as re-wording the question to find hidden cases of childhood diarrhoea.
Health questionnaires are increasingly being conducted through digital means, such as telecommunication. In this case, the respondent uses their mobile phone to answer the questionnaire. This method has two immediate advantages: it is not expensive in comparison to data collection in person, and it enables results to be collected from contrasting and moving populations. In this study, we wish to pilot the use of mobile phones to collect data from parents and carers covering child health, with particular emphasis on diarrhoea in one site in Mwanza, Tanzania. Our research questions include: 1) Does changing the wording to ask whether a child has had diarrhoea within the last 24 hours result in lower reported rates of diarrhoea (per day) than the two-week threshold?; 2) Does the use of a three-point scale including the Swahili word for ‘watery diarrhoea" result in lower reporting than the Swahili equivalent of ‘loose stools'?; 3) How does a three-level diarrhoea ‘scale' compare to the standard Demographic and Health Survey (DHS) two-level scale?; and 4) Does the existence of a small incentive influence survey response rates and bias?
In addition, we will harvest information on response rates over time and on peoples' attitude to the telephone questionnaire through qualitative work.
Intervention
We will be measuring diarrhoea prevalence in households using text messages surveys. Participants will be cross randomised into combinations of the following three conditions:
-No incentive OR TZS 1000 (GBP 0.40) incentive
-Two week recall period OR 24 hour recall period
-Standard diarrhoea measurement questions OR enhanced diarrhoea measurement questions
The standard diarrhoea measurement question asks if the child has had normal, loose, or watery stools in the past 24 hours/two weeks. The enhanced diarrhoea measurement questions include three levels of questions, in which the respondents are asked how many loose stools there were; if the child saw a health care provider; if there was blood; and if there was vomiting.
Experimental design
This is a factorial crossover RCT with eight arms, with some combination of the following:
-Incentive OR no incentive
-Two week recall OR 24 hour recall
-Standard questionnaire OR three level questionnaire
Throughout the course of the study, participants will be randomised throughout all study arms, ensuring that there are no consecutive weeks of the same recall period; and no more than two consecutive weeks of the same level of incentivization.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.