Promoting water purification: The roles of learning, habit formation, and social norm

How to cite

Akram, Agha; Hussam, Reshmaan; Khan, Akib; Fleischman, Gabriella. 2018. "Promoting water purification: The roles of learning, habit formation, and social norm." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003673. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3673-3.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Agha Akram* , Reshmaan Hussam , Akib Khan , Gabriella Fleischman

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003673
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3673-3.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-05-05 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3673

Abstract

Despite the potential to reduce diarrheal disease burden (Quick, et al, 2002), use of affordable point-of-use decontamination technologies such as chlorine tablets is low in many developing countries including Pakistan (0.3%, with 8% adopting any purification technology; Pakistan DHS, 2012-13). While price - even when low - can hinder adoption, free access induces only partial usage. For example, free delivery of chlorine solution in Kenya yielded a usage rate of only 34% (Dupas, et al, 2016). However, there is little evidence on ways to increase usage beyond this basic level induced by access. Akram & Mendelsohn (2017; hereafter, AM) explore an alternative hypothesis: If the households do not understand - or trust - expert opinion on benefits of usage and benefits are hard to measure, they may not be convinced of the returns to such a technology. In a pilot RCT, AM use household recordkeeping of children’s diarrhea incidence to help them learn the benefits of chlorinated drinking water (along with sharing information on the diarrhea rate from a comparable population not exposed to chlorine). Compared to a base policy of free access to chlorine tablets and expert advice on why to use them, this simple intervention increased chlorine use after one year by a remarkable 56 percentage points. It was highly cost-effective as well, with the marginal cost per DALY-averted at $495. We propose to build on this pilot by a) testing at a larger scale and b) investigating mechanisms, particularly those related to learning and social norms, to inform design choices for the next stage(s) of experimentation and eventually scale-up. The experimental design is further structured to test learning against habit formation: both processes require intense initial engagement and can yield sustained behavioral change, but economists know little about which is most effective for behavioral change (and technology adoption) broadly. Particularly in a space where returns are not obvious and existing information campaigns have largely failed, investigating which mental process is most operative regarding long term adoption of preventive health behaviors is crucial to policy design: do we, as policymakers, invest in subsidizing an activity repeatedly so people develop a habit, or do we invest in improving our information campaigns so individuals can better understand the returns to a behavior?

Intervention

We propose a randomized controlled trial (RCT) across 1,800 households. We first describe the various components of our interventions, and then outline the treatment arms explicitly.

Monitoring: Biweekly health worker (HW) visits to: a) collect data on diarrhea incidence over the last 2 weeks; b) test chlorine in the water once per month; and c) offer free chlorine tablets (2-week’s supply) and expert advice on use. This mimics standard public health campaigns on chlorine distribution.

Info-tool: HW helps the caregiver record diarrheal incidence (unique episodes across children) and total diarrhea days (the sum of all diarrhea days across episodes and children), and creates a bar graph to visually represent the total diarrhea days experienced by the children in the last 2 weeks. At the end of each month (during the second biweekly visit in a month), the diarrhea days from that month are added up and colored into a month-level bar graph. This is a simple, visual paper-and-pencil tool, and AM (2017) and our recent pilots have demonstrated that low-literacy-numeracy caregivers are comfortable using it.

Benchmarks: HW shares information on the diarrhea days expected in households (over the last two weeks) that do not use chlorine (estimated using data from the experiment; more on this below); and

Habit formation with financial incentive: Caregivers are offered small daily rewards (tokens redeemable for child/household goods) if the caregiver can show empty chlorine tablet wrappers as proof of usage. Each daily reward for proper chlorine use is equal to approximately 5 US cents (with ‘proper use’ calibrated to household’s pre-intervention water consumption).

Our four experimental arms are as follows:

Comparison (C): Monitoring minus the offer of free chlorine tablets and chlorine-testing
Treatment 1 (T1): Monitoring
Treatment 2 (T2): Monitoring + Info-tool + Benchmark
Treatment 3 (T3): Monitoring + Habit formation with financial incentive

To determine the benchmark in T2, we will use the diarrhea results of C from the previous two weeks. HW will share this information during the bi-weekly visits starting from the second visit (using data from the first bi-weekly visits to C from the previous two weeks).

Comparisons of arms and corresponding research questions are:

T1 vs T2: What are the short and long-run effects of facilitating learning about health returns on tablet take-up and usage?
T2 vs T3: Which mechanism is more effective in generating both contemporaneous and sustained change in behavior - active learning (via Info-tool and benchmark) or habit formation (with temporary incentives)?
C vs T1: How do the effects above compare to the standard public health effort of free distribution alone?

The interventions will span months 1-6 of the experiment (Phase 1), during which HWs visit all households once every two weeks for data collection and intervention execution. Note that, for the three treatment arms, tablet distribution and testing of water (and hence incentives for T3) starts in the third month as we reserve the first two months to help the caregivers develop some pre-tablet-access record of diarrhea incidence in their households. For months 7-16 (Phase 2), HWs will visit all households once each month to observe changes in long-term behavior. In month 16, HWs will offer a final 3-month’s supply to all households (except C). An endline survey will be administered 1 month after this visit.

Experimental design

We propose a randomized controlled trial (RCT) across 1,800 households. We first describe the various components of our interventions, and then outline the treatment arms explicitly.

Monitoring: Biweekly health worker (HW) visits to: a) collect data on diarrhea incidence over the last 2 weeks; b) test chlorine in the water once per month; and c) offer free chlorine tablets (2-week’s supply) and expert advice on use. This mimics standard public health campaigns on chlorine distribution.

Info-tool: HW helps the caregiver record diarrheal incidence (unique episodes across children) and total diarrhea days (the sum of all diarrhea days across episodes and children), and creates a bar graph to visually represent the total diarrhea days experienced by the children in the last 2 weeks. At the end of each month (during the second biweekly visit in a month), the diarrhea days from that month are added up and colored into a month-level bar graph. This is a simple, visual paper-and-pencil tool, and AM (2017) and our recent pilots have demonstrated that low-literacy-numeracy caregivers are comfortable using it.

Benchmarks: HW shares information on the diarrhea days expected in households (over the last two weeks) that do not use chlorine (estimated using data from the experiment; more on this below); and

Habit formation with financial incentive: Caregivers are offered small daily rewards (tokens redeemable for child/household goods) if the caregiver can show empty chlorine tablet wrappers as proof of usage. Each daily reward for proper chlorine use is equal to approximately 5 US cents (with ‘proper use’ calibrated to household’s pre-intervention water consumption).

Our four experimental arms are as follows:

Comparison (C): Monitoring minus the offer of free chlorine tablets and chlorine-testing
Treatment 1 (T1): Monitoring
Treatment 2 (T2): Monitoring + Info-tool + Benchmark
Treatment 3 (T3): Monitoring + Habit formation with financial incentive

To determine the benchmark in T2, we will use the diarrhea results of C from the previous two weeks. HW will share this information during the bi-weekly visits starting from the second visit (using data from the first bi-weekly visits to C from the previous two weeks).

Comparisons of arms and corresponding research questions are:

T1 vs T2: What are the short and long-run effects of facilitating learning about health returns on tablet take-up and usage?
T2 vs T3: Which mechanism is more effective in generating both contemporaneous and sustained change in behavior - active learning (via Info-tool and benchmark) or habit formation (with temporary incentives)?
C vs T1: How do the effects above compare to the standard public health effort of free distribution alone?

The interventions will span months 1-6 of the experiment (Phase 1), during which HWs visit all households once every two weeks for data collection and intervention execution. Note that, for the three treatment arms, tablet distribution and testing of water (and hence incentives for T3) starts in the third month as we reserve the first two months to help the caregivers develop some pre-tablet-access record of diarrhea incidence in their households. For months 7-16 (Phase 2), HWs will visit all households once each month to observe changes in long-term behavior. In month 16, HWs will offer a final 3-month’s supply to all households (except C). An endline survey will be administered 1 month after this visit.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office
Randomization unit
Household (with at least one child between the ages of 6 months and 5 years old at baseline)
Clusters
1,800 Households
Observations
1,800 Households
Arms
450 Households
Primary outcomes
Presence of residual chlorine in household drinking water; Acceptance of offered chlorine tablets; Diarrhea prevalence
Secondary outcomes
Height-for-age Z-score; Weight-for-height Z-score

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords