Raising outcomes in primary education, a cluster randomised trial in rural Guinea Bissau
How to cite
Fazzio, Ila; Eble, Alex; Hsieh, Jenny; Lumsdaine, Robin; Boone, Peter. 2019. "Raising outcomes in primary education, a cluster randomised trial in rural Guinea Bissau." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003670. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3670-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Most children in rural Guinea Bissau leave school without basic literacy and numeracy skills. Although enrolment in rural areas has increased from 24% to 60% over the past ten years, competencies in language and maths remain very low. Primary schools in rural Guinea Bissau are characterised by poorly trained, insufficient and under motivated teachers, a lack of materials for teaching and learning, poor infrastructure and inadequate didactic teaching pedagogy. Effective Intervention has designed ROPE - Raising Outcomes in Primary Education, a programme to deliver quality basic primary education for about 700 children in south rural Guinea Bissau that focus on hiring, training and monitoring teachers to provide a better quality teaching . The aim of this study is to assess the impact of this programme by comparing the test scores of children four years after the project has been implemented.
Intervention
The intervention programme comprised: i) a high quality in-service teacher training with regular monitoring and educational support; ii) the development and use of learning materials for teachers and pupils from preschool to 3rd grade. The academic support to children started in February 2014 (preschool) and was given to the same group until June 2018.
Primary teachers (21 initially) were placed in the villages assigned to intervention and three supervisors were responsible for monitoring and giving educational support to them.
Supervisors and Teachers’ Training
To create a high quality teaching group, supervisors and teachers were selected based on their fluency in one of the local indigenous languages, academic level, experience in teaching, knowledge in Portuguese and mathematics, pedagogical skills and motivation.
Supervisors received an intense training in Portuguese during 3 months and were rigorously tested by the end. Only those who had achieved B2 level according to the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages continued to receive training. From February 2012 to April 2012, they received training on personal and professional development, humans-rights, child development, teacher role in the school and community, classroom management, pedagogy methods and techniques, evaluation, planning, supervision and preparative activities (preschool). Following that they had another 6 months in-service training.
Teachers were selected later through a process that included two-week training to access their skills. During August and September 2013 they received training on classroom management, pedagogy methods and techniques, evaluation, planning, supervision and preparative activities (preschool).
Every year before the academic school year started, teachers received an intensive training on scientific and pedagogical topics listed in the national curriculum for the grade they were going to teach in that year. Further, they received regular and frequent tutoring and monitoring.
Intervention Classes
Selected and trained teachers were appointed to villages randomly allocated to intervention. During the first 9 months, they worked preparing pupils (aged 4, 5 and 6 years old) to enter in 1st grade. Then, teachers worked during 3 years with the same group of children until the end of 3rd grade. Teachers conducted support classes as and when required, with those children having learning difficulties or absenteeism during the project period.
Teachers’ supervision and educational support
Throughout the study these selected teachers were closely supported and monitored by supervisors and a Quality Control Group (QCG). The QCG was composed by the trainers of teachers.
Supervisors and the QCG conducted regular classroom observation to evaluate teachers’ performance, pupils’ learning, and guide teachers’ work.
Teachers had monthly meeting for lessons' planning with supervisors, and a monthly review meeting with all the team members.
To evaluate pupils’ learning outcomes, teacher and supervisor conducted tests prepared by the QCG, monthly and quarterly.
Learning and Teaching manuals
Teaching manuals and pupils’ exercise books were developed for introductory, 1st, 2nd and 3rd grades in all subjects that are included in the National Curriculum of Guinea Bissau. These manuals helped teachers to explore all the topics found in the curriculum, structure their classes linking their lessons to the pupils’ exercise books.
Community Involvement
During July and September 2013 and end of January 2014, supervisors conducted sensitisation and mobilisation campaigns in the communities randomly selected to receive the intervention. They promoted activities to motivate children to attend academic classes and sensitise parents and community to the importance of education and their role in ensuring better outcomes.
Parent Teacher Associations (PTA) were created and fomented to promote active participation and involvement of parents and communities in the process of learning.
An annual plan of the academic classes’ activities was presented and discussed with communities. PTAs were involved in the management of the academic classes and monitoring of children’s attendance and their learning progress. Children who are not performing were given extra time after the regular teaching time and parents were sensitised to support their children.
Experimental design
ROPE is a cluster-randomized trial involving 49 villages in the districts of Quinara and Tombali, where a village is the unit of randomisation.
It was unblinded given that parents were aware of whether or not they were in a village that was receiving materials and teaching support. However, a strict procedure to collect data and test children was applied to avoid any bias. The research team that conduct the surveys and tested the children were in principle blind.
The design was stratified. We conducted a cluster analysis to group the villages into homogeneous strata regarding the following variables: village’s distance to road, highest grade taught by the school if the village had a school (the grade was zero if the village did not have a school), number of households in the village, proportion of mothers speaking Crioulo in the village, and third quartile of mothers’ education in the village. We selected these variables on the assumption that they are correlated with the primary outcome, as showed by the NBER education study (Boone et al. 2013). The results of the cluster analysis suggested that two strata were sufficient (the dendogram is shown in Figure 1), one with 17 villages, another one with 32. The cluster analysis was conducted in SAS Software version 9.3, using PROC CLUSTER.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.