Peer selection and performance - A field experiment in higher education
How to cite
Rilke, Rainer Michael; Yurtoglu, Burcin; Fischer, Mira. 2018. "Peer selection and performance - A field experiment in higher education." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003646. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3646-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We investigate how individuals choose their peers and how endogenous peer selection influences performance. In a field experiment with students of a business school, we vary whether study groups are put together randomly, or whether students can choose their group partner endogenously. With the help of pre-elicited educational performance as well as demographic data, we are able to trace how individuals choose their partner and how these choices influence their group and individual performance during the course. Besides average performance, we analyze how the selection procedure influences the distribution of performance. We measure performance on three consecutive events. The groups' performance is measured by their score on two different tasks during the semester and individual performance is measured by a student's outcome on the final exam. Students only learn about their performance after the final exam. Secondary outcomes of interest are ability beliefs, satisfaction, and social preferences.
This registration belongs to the second wave of the study (the first wave has RCT ID AEARCTR-0002757). The structure of both waves is exactly the same. However, we replaced the second group exercise sheet with a group presentation task with the intention of making cooperation more visible.
Intervention
Students are randomly assigned to one of two exercise classes. In one class they are randomly matched with a peer. In the other class, matching is endogenous and students choose the peer themselves. In both classes, these groups of two solve the same two exercises together and receive a common grade for each. The first exercise is a written task, the second is a video presentation. Then every student individually writes the same exam. There is no intermediate feedback and students only learn about their performance a few weeks after the exam.
Experimental design
The experiment's setting is a business school in Germany. All students enrolled in a bachelor's program have to participate in the same microeconomics class during their first semester. The class is taught in three groups: two groups for students in the regular track and one group for students in the international track. Only students in the regular track are part of the experiment. Students do not know that an experiment is taking place.
Students in the regular track are randomly assigned to one of two groups. In one of those groups students are randomly matched with a peer, in the other group matches are formed endogenously. Students have to solve two exercises with their peer during the semester and receive a common grade for each sheet, which each makes up 15% of the final grade. In the end of the semester, each student individually writes an exam which makes up 70% of the final grade. Immediately after the exam, students are asked to fill in a questionnaire that elicits demographic information, ability beliefs, satisfaction and social preferences.
We received permission to run the experiment from the business school's academic director as well as its program manager. None of the institutions we were affiliated with when we started the experiment has an institutional review board.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.