Matchmaking and Mentoring: An Experimental Study of Online Entrepreneurial Support

How to cite

Lall, Saurabh; Chen, Li-Wei; Mason, Dyana. 2018. "Matchmaking and Mentoring: An Experimental Study of Online Entrepreneurial Support." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003644. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3644-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Saurabh Lall* , Li-Wei Chen , Dyana Mason

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003644
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3644-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2018-12-05 – 2019-11-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Business Economics, Social Innovation, Entrepreneurship
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3644

Abstract

This study will use a combination of experimental and quasi-experimental approaches to examine two research questions related to online mentoring for entrepreneurs. In partnership with MicroMentor, an initiative of Mercy Corps, we will examine the effectiveness of interventions to promote successful mentor-mentee connections, and overall effect of connecting with a mentor on entrepreneurial and venture-level outcomes.

There is a growing body of evidence that emphasizes the critical role that mentors play in helping entrepreneurs launch and accelerate their ventures (Eesley & Wang, 2017; Spigel, 2015). However, we know little about how mentor-mentee relationships are developed in an online context (Mills et al., 2012), and what types of interventions may lead to more meaningful mentoring relationships. Additionally, practitioners and researchers are interested in examining the impact of online mentoring on entrepreneurial performance. We propose one experimental and one quasi-experimental study to examine these questions.

Intervention

Entrepreneurship is believed to be of critical importance to economic development, and leading policymakers, donor agencies, and practitioner organizations are increasingly interested in understanding the drivers of entrepreneurial outcomes (Naudé, 2010). Governments, foundations, and other influential actors have allocated considerable resources to the development of programs that support entrepreneurs through provisions of social, financial, and human capital (Global Accelerator Learning Initiative, 2017; Rogerson et al., 2014; Cumming & Fischer, 2012).

In this context, mentoring offers a promising avenue of support for entrepreneurs, and has been demonstrated to offer several benefits (Eesley & Wang, 2017; St. Jean, 2009; Ozgen & Baron, 2007). For example, students paired with entrepreneurs as mentors were shown to be more likely to pursue entrepreneurial careers (Eesley & Wang, 2017). Additionally, entrepreneurs with access to mentors have more confidence in their abilities to complete key entrepreneurial tasks (St. Jean & Mathieu, 2015; St. Jean, 2009; Ozgen & Baron, 2007), and also be more alert to new opportunities (Ozgen & Baron, 2007). Finally, mentoring has also been demonstrated to have considerable positive outcomes in other domains, such as engineering (Dennehy & Dasgupta, 2017), and academia (Poteat et al., 2009).

However, while research suggests several benefits of mentoring, there are still questions that remain unanswered. While mentor-mentee relationships have been studied in facilitated settings, we know little about how these relationships form and develop, and what factors can improve the quality of these connections. Additionally, while research suggests benefits in entrepreneurs’ self-assessed abilities, it is important to learn whether mentoring also leads to improvements in actual business performance.

We conduct a randomized controlled trial (and a subsequent quasi-experiment) that tests the impact of two strategies designed to help entrepreneurs connect to mentors – building confidence or reducing information asymmetry. In partnership with a large international nonprofit organization (MicroMentor, a program of Mercy Corps) that facilitates mentor-mentee connections online, we will compare the impact of these two strategies (separately and combined) and a control group on connection rates and the quality of those connections. We conduct a randomized controlled trial (and a subsequent quasi-experiment) that tests the impact of two strategies designed to help entrepreneurs connect to mentors – building confidence or reducing information asymmetry. In partnership with a large international nonprofit organization that facilitates mentor-mentee connections online, we will compare the impact of these two strategies (and a control group) on connection rates and the quality of those connections. In a follow-up study, we will compare business performance for entrepreneurs that received mentoring compared to those that did not, using a quasi-experimental approach.

The 4 groups of randomly assigned entrepreneurs will receive the following interventions
1. Confidence building - a series of messages (delivered through an online chat buddy mechanism on the MicroMentor platform) designed to help entrepreneurs build their confidence to reach out to potential mentors through the MicroMentor platform.

2. Encouragement to provide information - a series of messages (delivered through an online chat buddy mechanism on the MicroMentor platform) designed to encourage entrepreneurs to develop more complete online profiles on the MicroMentor platform.

3. A short video that combines elements of both confidence-building and encouragement to provide information

4. A control group that receives no intervention

The follow-up study will examine business outcomes across mentored and non-mentored entrepreneurs across all 4 groups.

Experimental design

We conduct a randomized controlled trial (and a subsequent quasi-experiment) that tests the impact of two strategies designed to help entrepreneurs connect to mentors – building confidence or reducing information asymmetry. In partnership with a large international nonprofit organization (MicroMentor, a program of Mercy Corps) that facilitates mentor-mentee connections online, we will compare the impact of these two strategies (separately and combined) and a control group on connection rates and the quality of those connections. We conduct a randomized controlled trial (and a subsequent quasi-experiment) that tests the impact of two strategies designed to help entrepreneurs connect to mentors – building confidence or reducing information asymmetry. In partnership with a large international nonprofit organization that facilitates mentor-mentee connections online, we will compare the impact of these two strategies (and a control group) on connection rates and the quality of those connections. In a follow-up study, we will compare business performance for entrepreneurs that received mentoring compared to those that did not, using a quasi-experimental approach.

The 4 groups of randomly assigned entrepreneurs will receive the following interventions
1. Confidence building - a series of messages (delivered through an online chat buddy mechanism on the MicroMentor platform) designed to help entrepreneurs build their confidence to reach out to potential mentors through the MicroMentor platform.

2. Encouragement to provide information - a series of messages (delivered through an online chat buddy mechanism on the MicroMentor platform) designed to encourage entrepreneurs to develop more complete online profiles on the MicroMentor platform.

3. A short video that combines elements of both confidence-building and encouragement to provide information

4. A control group that receives no intervention

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be conducted by a computer program. As entrepreneurs sign up for the platform during the trial period, they will be randomly assigned to one of the four groups to receive the specified intervention (or control group)
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
3,500 entrepreneurs
Observations
3,500 entrepreneurs
Arms
875 per treatment arm
Primary outcomes
1. Percentage of entrepreneurs that successfully connect with a mentor (defined as at least 4 messages back and forth) 2. Number of messages exchanged with mentor 3. Percentage of entrepreneurs that exchange contact information (phone number, email) to continue conversations off the platform 4. Polarity and Subjectivity of conversations to examine the quality of the mentoring relationship (Kouloumpis, Wilson, & Moore, 2011; Sarlan, Nadam, & Basri, 2014)
Secondary outcomes
After the completion of the intervention, we will also examine the following business outcomes for mentored and non-mentored entrepreneurs, one year after they have registered on the platform. Note that since the platform is open to all entrepreneurs, we are unable to specifically match entrepreneurs to mentors to look at the impact of mentoring. However, we will be able to use the experimental design in the first phase of the study to try to control for possible endogeneity issues: 1. Perceived self-efficacy (McGee et al., 2009) 2. Revenues 3. Number of employees 4. External investment received

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords