Strengthening Professionalism and Accountability within the Ghana Police Service, using Identities, Norms and Narratives
How to cite
Harris, Donna; Borcan, Oana; Telli, Henry; Dercon, Stefan; Collier, Paul; Serra, Danila. 2019. "Strengthening Professionalism and Accountability within the Ghana Police Service, using Identities, Norms and Narratives." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003631. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3631-1.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Corruption has long been one of the major obstacles to improving economic efficiency and reducing poverty in developing countries. In many places, corruption has become a norm - a way of life - something that is generally accepted as a behavioural standard. How do we change a corrupt norm? The aim of this project is to devise an innovative policy intervention to address this question. We focus on Ghanaian traffic police because it is relatively understudied and the relationship between the traffic police and citizens is a complex one. However, the high frequency of interactions between citizens and traffic police officers means that it is more visible than other forms of corruption. In Ghana, traffic officers are known to either purposely create roadblocks to extort bribes from drivers or to reduce the number and/or the frequency of checks on smugglers/traffickers in exchange for various sums of money (National Road Safety Commission, 2010, 2015). However, ethnographic research has also revealed that citizens who violate the traffic laws often initiate the payment to avoid a court order which is typically a very cumbersome process and time consuming. The aim of our paper is to first gain a better understanding of the organisational culture of the police service, the working environment, and obstacles that police officers face. In particular, we are interested in the role of intrinsic motivations in driving corrupt behaviour. Our conjecture is that if we can increase intrinsic motivation among police officers by instilling a new identity, new mission that they can internalise and identify with, the moral cost of engaging in corruption will increase and thus, they are more likely to refrain from taking/asking for a bribe. Our main treatment is an innovative and intensive identity-building training programme, which uses psychological and team-building exercises to re-shape the officers' social identity and values. We will be working with a training expert from the Brazil's Federal Highway Police to deliver the training to the treatment group of 350 traffic police officers in Ghana.
Intervention
The intervention will be a training programme aiming to engage the officers' intrinsic motivation for the job, foster a sense of identity and belonging to an effective and honest police force, shift beliefs about what constitutes corruption and thereby change the officers' behaviour in their interaction with citizens. The training will take place over one week. The curriculum will be designed by the research team in collaboration with a police training expert from Brazil's Federal Highway Police and with the advice of a leading professor in psychiatry from the University of Oxford.
Experimental design
The experimental subjects are officers within Ghana's Motor Traffic and Transport Department (MTTD) from the Accra region. There are 14 police divisions, further divided into 42 districts, employing around 700 police officers. This is our target population. Of these, 1 district (Central or Headquarters) is distinctly larger than the rest (around 200 officers). Officers in this district are sometimes deployed to different districts to cover duty posts where the need arises. This district will not be included in the experiment. We will randomly assign two thirds of the police districts to the treatment group. The unit of randomisation will be the police districts in order to reduce contamination across treated and control groups, due to interaction of police officers at the police district headquarters and within-district mixed teams on the ground. All police officers within the treated districts will be offered the training programme in April-May 2019. None of the police officers in the control districts will be offered the training programme at this time, but may be offered the programme in the spring of 2020, after the endline data collection, by local police commanders which we will train to deliver our tailored training programme. We will compare outcomes from police officers' endline surveys and experimental games, as well as drivers, passengers and household surveys, across treated and control districts. Baseline officer survey data was collected in October 2018 and driver and household and drivers/passengers survey data will be collected in April-May 2019. Endline data will be collected in November 2019. This design will allow us to estimate the Intent-to-treat effect (ITT) as the difference in means in outcomes at endline between the treatment and the control groups. In the event of less than perfect compliance we will estimate the local average treatment (LATE) effect by instrumenting compliance with the treatment offer.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Harris, D, O Borcan, D Serra, H Telli, B Schettini, and S Dercon. 2022. “Proud to Belong: the Impact of Ethics Training on Police Officers.” CSAE Working Paper Series. University of Oxford. https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:ea7bcad5-af6e-49d1-9a00-ff20f9c57569
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.