The impact of school feeding on nutrition, education, agriculture and other social outcomes: design of a randomised controlled trial of 'home-grown' school feeding in Ghana

How to cite

Aurino, Elisabetta; Drake, Lesley. 2018. "The impact of school feeding on nutrition, education, agriculture and other social outcomes: design of a randomised controlled trial of 'home-grown' school feeding in Ghana." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003629. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3629-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Elisabetta Aurino* , Lesley Drake

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003629
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3629-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2013-06-01 – 2016-07-01
Countries
Ghana (Sub-Saharan Africa)
JEL codes
H5; I18; I25; I28; I3; J13; O13; Q1
Secondary IDs
ISRCTN66918874
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3629

Abstract

School food programmes are a popular way to support the education, health and nutrition of school children. The Ghana School Feeding Programme (GSFP) reaches over 1.6 million primary school children across all regions of Ghana. Private caterers are awarded contracts by the GSFP to procure, prepare and serve food to pupils. The caterers are able to procure on a competitive basis without commitment to purchasing from small-scale farmers.

‘Home-grown’ school feeding aims to link the increased demand for school feeding goods and services to community stakeholders, including small-holder farmers (mainly subsistence farmers) and women groups. This study proposes a randomized control trial that aims to evaluate the impact of school feeding sourced from small-holder farmers on small-holder food security, and the overall effects of the GSFP on child nutrition and education in Ghana.

This study involves a field experiment around the scale-up of the GSFP, including 116 primary schools in 58 districts.
The randomly assigned interventions are:
1. School feeding programme, where the standard GSFP is implemented
2. 'Home-grown' school feeding (HGSF+) group, including schools and communities where the Ghana School Feeding Programme is implemented in addition to district-level training of community-based organizations and local government
3. Control group, including schools and household from communities where the intervention will be implemented at the end of the trial (preferably without informing schools and households of impending intervention).

A total of 2626 households in 116 school catchment areas were surveyed at baseline. Households are selected at random from village-level listings.

Primary outcomes include: child health and nutritional status (BMI-for-age and height-for-age z-scores); school participation; learning (maths and literacy); cognition (raven and digit span); and smallholder farmer income, sales and production. Intermediate outcomes along the agriculture. nutrition and education pathways are also measured. The evaluation follows a mixed-method approach, including child-, household-, school- and community-level surveys as well as focus group discussions with project stakeholders.

Intervention

The randomly assigned interventions are:
1. School feeding programme, where the standard Ghana School Feeding Programme is implemented
2. 'Home-grown' school feeding (HGSF+) group, including schools and communities where the Ghana School Feeding Programme is implemented in addition to district-level training of community based organizations and local government
3. Control group, including schools and household from communities where the intervention will be implemented at the end of the trial (preferably without informing schools and households of impending intervention).

Experimental design

The selection of the study areas involved two key steps. I) Selecting 58 districts at random within Ghana from a sample frame including all districts in the country. The sample frame was stratified by region and district inclusion was prioritised using data from the GSFP retargeting exercise including data on the prevalence of poverty and food insecurity. II) Identifying 2 comparable schools within each of the 58 selected districts. A protocol was designed to ensure that the schools were comparable based on data from the Education Management Information system (EMIS) and that potential for contamination and crossover between the schools and pupils in each district was minimised. This step utilized a list from the GSFP secretariat of schools not currently covered by GSFP in each district. Data from the annual school census from 2011-2012 was then used to match schools not receiving the GSFP and identify “best matched” pair. The allocation into school feeding and control schools was then randomised within each pair. The 58 schools assigned to the intervention were then randomly assigned to regular GSFP and HGSF+. In this way the randomisation of the HGSF+ intervention occurs at the district level. The number of 58 schools is based on power calculations determined with the objective of achieving statistical validity and representativeness for the main outcomes of interest.

Design details

Randomization method
Lottery style
Randomization unit
Selection of the target areas involved three key steps: 1) the first step involved selecting 58 districts at random within Ghana from a sample frame including all districts in the country. The sample frame was stratified by region, and district inclusion was prioritised using data from the GSFP retargeting exercise including data on the prevalence of poverty and food insecurity; 2) the second step involved identifying 2 comparable schools within each of the 58 selected districts. A list was obtained through the GSFP secretariat including schools not currently covered by the GSFP in each district. Data from the annual school census from 2011 to 2012 were then used to match schools not receiving the GSFP and identify ‘ best matched’ pair. The allocation of school feeding and control was then randomised (lottery style) within each pair; 3) the third step in the site selection protocol involved the random allocation of districts to the HGSF+/GSFP groups by modelling pilot selection using a set of community- and district-level variables and selecting the permutation of allocation that minimises the R-squared for the predicted selection
Clusters
58 districts, 116 schools
Observations
A total of 2626 households in 116 communities were surveyed at baseline
Arms
58
Primary outcomes
Agriculture: Household income, production, sales. Education: Child enrolment, attendance, completion, maths and literacy scores (5–15 year old). Cognition: Raven’s test and forward/backward digit span scores (5–15 year old). Physical health/Nutrition :Anthropometry (height-for-age, BMI-for-age, 2–15 year old, haemoglobin levels (5–15 year old)

Papers from this trial

  1. Food for Thought? Experimental Evidence on the Learning Impacts of a Large-Scale School Feeding Program Elisabetta Aurino, Aulo Gelli, Clement Adamba, Isaac Osei-Akoto and Harold Alderman Journal of Human Resources, January 2023, 58 (1) 74-111; DOI: https://doi.org/10.3368/jhr.58.3.1019-10515R1 https://jhr.uwpress.org/content/58/1/74
  2. A School Meals Program Implemented at Scale in Ghana Increases Height-for-Age during Midchildhood in Girls and in Children from Poor Households: A Cluster Randomized Trial Aulo Gelli , Elisabetta Aurino , Gloria Folson , Daniel Arhinful, Clement Adamba , Isaac Osei-Akoto , Edoardo Masset , Kristie Watkins , Meena Fernandes , Lesley Drake , Harold Alderman https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31100125/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords