Do Microfinance Clients Benefit from Business Advice Services? Evidence from a Training and Consulting Program in Indonesia

How to cite

Avdeenko, Alexandra; Helmsmüller, Simona; Garamow, Adelina; Frölich, Markus. 2018. "Do Microfinance Clients Benefit from Business Advice Services? Evidence from a Training and Consulting Program in Indonesia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003625. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3625-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alexandra Avdeenko* , Simona Helmsmüller , Adelina Garamow , Markus Frölich

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003625
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3625-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-08-01 – 2019-11-24
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O17, L26, O12, D22
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3625

Abstract

Helping microentrepreneurs increase their profits is believed to be a promising tool in the self-help advocating development aid aiming to reach a large number of households threatened by poverty. Initiatives tackling the micro-level inhibitors to MSE growth are increasingly focusing on addressing the lack of business skills and managerial capital, with donors and practitioners pioneering a vast range of training courses to this end. Our study evaluates the PROMISE-IMPACT, Promoting Micro and Small Enterprises through Improved Entrepreneurs’ Access to Financial Services, initiated by the ILO in Indonesia and implemented by thirteen micro-Financial Service Provider, short FSPs. The program supports existing clients of the FSPs to explore whether business development services combined with finance can result in greater productivity and growth for the enterprises. As such, it provides classroom training and/ or individual consulting to MSEs, with a focus on financial management and marketing skills. Our research design is an RCT with more than 5,000 clients of the FSPs randomly assigned to one of the three treatment arms or the control group in winter 2017/2018. The treatment arms are: (1) Only classroom training, (2) only individual counseling, or (3) classroom training combined with individual counseling in follow-up visits, all provided by trained loan officers of the FSPs. Our research contributes to a growing body of evidence by tackling the following research questions: First, we investigate whether MSEs in Indonesia on average benefit from classroom training and/ or individual counseling. Second, we investigate who benefits the most from which type of business support.

Intervention

Our study evaluates the Promoting Micro and Small Enterprises through Improved Entrepreneurs’ Access to Financial Services (PROMISE-IMPACT) initiated by the International Labour Organization (ILO) in Indonesia and implemented by thirteen micro-Financial Service Providers (FSPs) in East and West Java, which included savings and credit cooperatives, rural banks, and development banks. The program supports existing clients of the FSPs to explore whether business development services combined with finance can result in greater productivity and growth for the enterprises. As such, it provides classroom training and individual consulting to MSEs. FSPs chose whether to implement three treatment arms (training, counselling and both) or one treatment arm (training and counselling). FSPs in Batch I chose all three treatment arms, whereas FSPs in Batch II and Batch III chose only the “training and counselling” treatment. Once the program was chosen, the research group randomized which FSP client receives which type of treatment. Eligible clients in this treatment are predominantly (though not exclusively) microenterprises in the manufacturing sector. The focus of the support lies on improving financial management and marketing.

Experimental design

The participating financial service providers chose themselves which of the three treatment arms they would like to offer. FSPs in Batch I chose all three treatment arms, whereas FSPs in Batch II and Batch III chose only the “training and counseling” treatment. After the baseline survey, we randomized the clients of the FSPs into the treatment arm. For logistic reason, we ran the randomization procedure for each batch separately at different points of time.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual (for program) and cluster (for variation nr of clients treated). Randomization is at the individual level. Individuals are randomly allocated to either treatment or control or to different treatment arms (depending on the type of FSP they are served by). While randomization is at the individual level, the randomization applies a two-stage procedure: first, the treatment probability is allocated at the branch/ cashpoint level, and second, individuals within a branch/ cashpoint are allocated to treatment. As a consequence of the random assignment of treatment probabilities, we allocated a larger number of clients to treatment in some branch/ cashpoints than in others. The allocation procedure followed a re-randomization approach whereby we only retained those randomization vectors that passed a balancing threshold, and of these, the first is kept for the actual randomization.
Clusters
13 financial institutions, for logistic reasons divided into three batches. Total of 141 branches/ cashpoints (thereof 26 in Batch I, 86 in Batch II and 29 in Batch III).
Observations
5,257 individuals (MSE owners)
Arms
1,909 individuals in the “Training and Counseling” treatment (thereof 763 in Batch I) 738 individuals in the “Training only” treatment (all Batch I) 763 individuals in the “Counseling only” treatment (all in Batch I) 1,847 individuals in the Control group (thereof 766 Batch I, 641 Batch II, 440 Batch III)
Primary outcomes
growth in enterprises; profits; firm survival or additional start-ups; business environment rating; financial situation of the household; life satisfaction; business loans; loan behavior of clients
Secondary outcomes
Best practices of marketing, best practices of financial management, behavioral changes in marketing practices, behavioral changes in financial management practices

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords