Teaching Financial Wellness: the Effects of Personalized Debt Counseling for At-Risk Borrowers
How to cite
Herbst, Daniel. 2019. "Teaching Financial Wellness: the Effects of Personalized Debt Counseling for At-Risk Borrowers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003620. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3620-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
I evaluate a randomized controlled trial of high-touch financial counseling sessions provided by a non-profit financial wellness organization. Counseling sessions consist of thirty- to sixty-minute phone calls, in which counselors help individuals prioritize their debts and construct a detailed budget. Drawing from a sample of highly-distressed student loan borrowers, I measure the impact of these counseling sessions on a variety of financial health outcomes, including credit scores, bankruptcies, credit card balances, and student loan delinquencies.
Intervention
The intervention consists of high-touch financial counseling sessions provided by a non-profit financial wellness organization. Counseling sessions consist of thirty- to sixty-minute phone calls, in which counselors help individuals prioritize their debts and construct a detailed budget.
Experimental design
A large student loan servicer provided me a list of anonymized identifiers linked to annual credit bureau data and monthly student loan information. The list population included any borrower who had received a delinquency call from the servicer between 2012 and 2016. From this list I randomly selected a fifty-percent sample of "treatment eligible" borrowers and generated a borrower-level "financial wellness index" based on credit bureau and student loan information. I then provided the list to the loan servicer, which regularly contacts delinquent borrowers through incoming and outgoing phone calls handled by loan servicing agents.
During the intervention period, calls between borrowers and servicer were placed and received as usual. However, call agents were notified of borrowers' treatment eligibility once they were connected to a call. Upon connecting with a treatment-eligible borrower, call agents would ask borrowers if they were interested in free financial counseling. If a borrower consented to the counseling treatment, the call agent would transfer the call to the non-profit financial counselor along with that borrower's anonymized identifier. The financial counselor would then initiate the counseling session.
To make sure the financial counselor did not receive too many or too few calls over a given period, treatment eligibility was ratcheted up or down depending on the flow of calls. Using the treatment eligibility list and financial wellness index, the loan servicer started with a small group of its most distressed borrowers and gradually increased who would be referred for treatment. Importantly, I retain anonymized identifiers and index values for all treatment-eligible and control borrowers.
After 250 borrowers have received treatment, the intervention will cease, and the financial counseling organization will provide me a list of dates, times, and anonymized identifiers corresponding to each counseling session. The loan servicer will continue to collect credit bureau and student loan information for all borrowers through their normal operations. Specific dates are not yet determined, but I will wait one to three years before collecting outcome data from the servicer for analysis. Follow-up data collection will take place in subsequent years for longer-term outcomes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.