Information, consumer choice, and quality and quantity of primary care
How to cite
Kjellsson, Gustav; Ellegård, Lina Maria; Dietrichson, Jens; Anell, Anders. 2018. "Information, consumer choice, and quality and quantity of primary care." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003599. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3599-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In order to improve the quality of care, all regions in Sweden have implemented systems where individuals choose their primary health care provider. All providers are financed by public means and pre-set user fees, but may be privately or publicly run. For consumer choice systems to improve the functioning of health care, users must choose units that deliver care of relatively high quality. Demand side frictions related to switching present a possible obstacle to the functioning of this market: the gathering of information about and comparison of providers is costly in terms of time, and there are also small process costs related to notifying providers of the change. We study the effects of two interventions using two randomly drawn samples of the population in the region of Skåne. The first sample is representative of the adult population in the region (above 18 years of age in February 4th 2015) and the second includes all individuals that that moved to the region between mid-February and early May 2015. The treatment groups, 10,259 individuals in the population-representative sample and 3,454 in the sample of new residents, received a leaflet designed in collaboration with the regional health care authority by postal mail. The leaflet contained comparative information on, e.g., accessibility, quality, and available services of an individual’s current primary care provider and its three geographically closest competitors. By sending information directly to consumers, the experimental treatment reduced search costs and may also have improved understanding, as the information was presented differently on the leaflets compared to information available online. 7,700 of the treated in the population-representative sample, and all treated new residents, received a pre-paid choice form together with the leaflet. The small monetary and hassle costs associated with switching were therefore reduced. In a previous study, we showed that information and reduced switching costs increased the probability of switching provider. This study concerns a longer-term follow-up of treatment effects of the intervention. Primary outcomes relate to care consumption and process quality measures in the population-representative sample. Secondary outcomes include additional care consumption variables and long-term switching of providers.
Intervention
Part 1: In the first intervention, the regional health authority in the region of Skåne (located in the south-west of Sweden) - Region Skåne - provided 1 percent of the population that are over 18 years old with comparative information about the primary care center (PCC) that they were enrolled at and its three geographically nearest competitors. The information leaflet was sent by mail, and contained information about, among other things, opening hours, quality ratings, and special competences. The leaflet also contained information about a webpage, where comparisons to more PCCs can be made. An example of a leaflet is included in our previous study (Anell et al. 2018). The Part 1 intervention had two treatment arms: 25% of the treated received only information about primary care centers (info), while 75% of the treated received information along with a pre-paid form that could be used to register the change of provider (info&form). The control group received nothing.
Part 2: in the second intervention, the health authority sent similar information leaflets by postal mail to half of all new residents that had registered in the region during the three months following the first intervention. Half of all new residents were assigned to treatment, which in this intervention was one-armed and included only the info&form treatment. The control group received nothing.
The two interventions were implemented in 2015 (Intervention start dates: February 23 and June 12). These were followed up using data on provider choices up until October 2015. This is a pre-analysis plan for a medium-term follow up of these interventions for a period including October 2018. The experiments and the first follow-up was registered in 2015 with registration number AEARCTR-0000659.
Experimental design
The premise for Part 1 was that the regional health authority has to treat all primary care centers equally, in order to be neutral in terms of competition on this market. Using the random number generator within Stata (which we use for all randomizations), we therefore first drew 11 percent of listed individuals over 18 from each of the 150 primary care centers. Then, then we randomly selected 9.0909091 percent of these 11 percent as the treatment group. The remaining share constituted the control group. Within the treatment group, we then randomly assigned 25 percent stratified per center to the group that would only receive information (info), and 75 percent to the group that would receive information and a pre-paid change form (info&form).
Part 2: The randomization procedure for this part was similar to the one described for Part 1. The second population included all individuals (above 18) who entered the enrollment register between February 4 and May 11, 2015. Of these 6,906 individuals, approximately 50% were assigned to treatment. To avoid spill-over effects within families, this intervention was cluster-randomized by residential address. The number of clusters were 6,059. The population was extracted from the enrollment register on May 11, the randomization took place on May 25 2015, and the leaflets were mailed out in the second week of June. In this part, all individuals in the treatment group received both a leaflet and a pre-paid form (i.e. info&form). 3,454 individuals were assigned to the treatment group and 3,452 to the control group.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.