Pre experiment registration: Debt and Social Comparison
How to cite
Grohmann, Antonia; Koch, Melanie. 2018. "Pre experiment registration: Debt and Social Comparison." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003597. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3597-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The aim of this experiment is to examine whether having to make consumption decisions publically leads people to borrow in order to be able to signal higher status then they actually achieved. Participants are paid depending on their performance in a test that involves questions designed to measure intelligence. Participants that perform well on the test are able to buy better quality pens. Participants that perform less well are can still buy better quality pens, but have to take a loan for this. There are three treatments, in the first treatment the decision is taken privately on the computer, in a second treatment participants have to announce their choices publically, in a third treatment participants make their decisions on a computer, but can see the choices participants in the same session took. The shopping round is followed by a slider task. We test if participants in different treatment work harder in order to earn more following the shopping round.
Intervention
There are three treatments:
(i) Private treatment - respondents make choices on computer
(ii) Public treatment – respondents make choices on computer but announce out loud.
(iii) Information treatment – participants make decisions on computer but can see choices make by others.
Experimental design
At the beginning of the experiment subjects come into the lab and are given detailed instructions. Subjects are told that there are rounds during which they can earn money. (i) is an IQ style test during which they can earn money according to their position compared to other participants. (ii) is an income earning round during which their earning depend on their performance alone.
(i) Subjects earn money according to their performance compared to others participants in the lab. They have to spend this income on a pen. Pens come in different prices and in different qualities. Participants can borrow money to buy higher quality pens then they could afford due to their income. There are three different treatments for different ways that people communicate their choice of pen.
(ii) The second income round is a slider task. Subject’s earnings only depend on their own performance in the slider task.
The two income rounds are followed by a questionnaire during which we ask a large number of psychological questions.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.