Showing Life Opportunities: Increasing opportunity-driven entrepreneurship and STEM careers through online courses in schools.

How to cite

Asanov, Igor; McKenzie, David. 2018. "Showing Life Opportunities: Increasing opportunity-driven entrepreneurship and STEM careers through online courses in schools.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003593. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3593-3.7

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Igor Asanov* , David McKenzie

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003593
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3593-3.7
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2019-02-01 – 2023-05-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I21, L26, O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3593

Abstract

We plan to provide an RCT to assess the effect of online courses in schools on intentions, career-related actions, and career choices to become an opportunity driven entrepreneur or choose a STEM type of education. We plan to work with to 15-17-year-old students (about 20,000 students) in 110 schools. We will randomly assign schools either to treatment (and receiving the entrepreneurship and science content online), or placebo-control (receiving a placebo treatment of online courses from standard curricula) groups. Within the treatment group, we randomize at the grade-level the type of entrepreneurship curricula, and then randomize the order of entrepreneurship and science courses to measure the short-term effects of each component and to mitigate order effects. In addition, we cross-randomize schools to a role model treatment of interviews with successful scientists and entrepreneurs. In addition, we provide information about career options. We then plan to follow subjects until (at least) age 19, to measure both short- and medium-term outcomes.

Intervention

We provide an online course in schools over 12 weeks in 2019. The courses will contain the following content: (1) entrepreneurship-related soft skills – this will cover personal initiative and negotiation skills; (2) basic scientific methods – this will cover ideas of the experimental method, and basic statistics; and (3) role model interviews with entrepreneurs and scientists. Placebo courses will be offered to a control group for measuring the overall effectiveness of these courses. Placebo courses consist of Spanish grammar and English. In addition, we provide information about career options.

Experimental design

A. The structure of the Intervention.
All pupils face a baseline test on different subjects’ knowledge and career attitudes on the online platform. We will also elicit behavior in incentivized games. Then, under the mentorship of their teachers, students are randomly selected to pass courses on Entrepreneurship and Science or academic reinforcement. They also watch video interviews with Entrepreneurship and Scientists or video from standard education curricula: Educa TV.

Before, during, and after the intervention, we will advertise a set of course-related activities, e.g. information about the university options (see detailed description in outcomes subsection). That will allow us to help interested students to practice their knowledge and choose a potentially better career. It will also bring us measurable action-based outcomes. We plan to pilot the online courses and parts of intervention in three public schools.

B. Randomization

We plan to randomize different parts fo the program at the four levels: school, grade, class, and individual level.

1. School level randomization. We randomize on the school level whether the students receive (1) entrepreneurship and science or (2) placebo courses.

2. Grade level randomization. We randomize at the grade level (10th or 11th grade) whether the students receive personal initiative or negotiations skills courses among the schools that receive Entrepreneurship and Science courses.

3. Class level randomization. At the class level, we randomize if the students watch role model videos (or Educa TV videos) and order of courses and role model videos.

4. Individual-level randomization. At the individual level, we randomize the individual elements of courses, interview sections, information about career options, and if students get an invitation by e-mail to participate in business and science competition.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer. Individual-level randomization done through an online platform.
Randomization unit
There are four different levels of randomization: - School level: We randomize treatment or placebo courses at the school level. - Grade level: Type of entrepreneurial training within treated schools at the grade level. - Class level: Order of courses, the presence of role model videos at the class level. - Individual level: Individual elements of courses, interview sections, information about career options, an invitation to participate in business and science competition at the individual level.
Clusters
1. We plan to work with 110 schools. These will be randomized into 70 treatment schools and 40 control schools. 2. Within the 70 treatment schools, there will be approximately 140 grades. We will randomize type of entrepreneurial courses at the grade level. 3.1 Within 110 schools, there will be approximately 550 class. We will randomize the presence of role model or placebo videos in these classes. 3.2 Within the 70 treatment schools, there will be approximately 350 classes. We will randomize the ordering of courses in these classes. 4. Randomization of individual elements of courses, interview sections, information about career options, an invitation to participate in business and science competition are not clustered, but randomized on the indiviudal level.
Observations
We plan to work with 110 schools and will work with levels 10 and 11 in these schools, for 220 grades. There are approximately 5 classes per school, so approximately 550 classes in total, and approximately 180 students per school, for aproximately 20,000 students in total.
Arms
Main intervention: 70 schools receive treatment courses, 40 placebo courses. Type of entrepreneurial courses intervention: 70 grades recieve personal initiative courses, 70 grades recieve negotiations course. Role model video intervention: Approximately 275 classes are exposed to role model, approximately 275 classes are exposed to placebo videos. Course order: Approximately 175 classes are exposed first to entrepreneurship-related soft skills course, approximately 175 classes are exposed first to basic scientific methods. Information and competition treatment: Approximately 5000 students receive detailed information about career options and invitation by e-mail to participate in business and science competition, approximately 5000 students receive only detailed information about career options, approximately 5000 students receive no information about the career options and invited to by e-mail to participate in business and science competition, 5000 students control.
Primary outcomes
(A) Career attitudes: Interest in entrepreneurial and scientific careers (B) Learning: Students’ performance on subject-specific tests (C) Learning changes behavior: Lab-in-Field experiments. (D) Steps-towards career: Action-Based Outcomes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords