Stay connected: Encouraging water service payments in Nairobi’s urban slums
How to cite
Coville, Aidan; Galiani, Sebastian; Gertler, Paul. 2018. "Stay connected: Encouraging water service payments in Nairobi’s urban slums." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003556. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3556-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Through a large-scale randomized experiment of approximately 5,500 water utility customers (landlords) we measure the direct impact of disconnection notices to non-paying customers, and the associated spillover effects on neighbors. We additionally provide tenants with information about account balances and payment behavior to test the effect of strengthening bottom-up accountability in low and high enforcement settings. The study builds on work exploring how to effectively expand the provision of basic services (water, electricity, sewerage) to low income areas when poor households are typically unable to bear the full costs of connection and use. Subsidies and/or lines of credit have been successful in increasing household-level access, but this can increase the debt burden of utilities and households if customers fail to pay. This, in turn, threatens the sustainability and incentives of utilities to expand access further. Combining limited ability/willingness to pay with weak and ad hoc enforcement mechanisms in informal settlements, where the majority of Kenya’s urban poor live, means that defaulting on monthly fees for water and sewer charges is the norm rather than the exception. The target population is customers of the utility - the Nairobi City Water and Sewer Company – who are typically landlords with properties that house multiple tenants where these landlords are primarily responsible for paying utility service charges.
Intervention
Nairobi Water field staff (Community Development Agents, or CDAs), together with the utility’s finance team will be responsible for outreach and disconnections.
Control: All customers in the sample will be provided the following base intervention delivered by CDAs (in sequence): (i) A phone call to the landlord / owner to collect up-to-date contact information, provide basic information on how to read meters and pay bills, and share their latest account balance on record; (ii) an on-site meter reading; and (iii) an SMS to landlords/owners providing the account balance based on the meter reading.
Treatment 1: A subset of compounds will receive a face-to-face visit from a CDA informing tenants about the current balance, how payments can be made, and the importance of ensuring the landlord makes payment to avoid having services disconnected.
Treatment 2: After the first round of outreach, a subset of compounds that remain in arrears will be provided official notification and given approximately 15 days to make payment or have their services disconnected. Official communication includes (in order): (i) a notice posted to the compound door warning customers of disconnection if payment is not made by a specified deadline, and providing a contact number for coordinating a payment arrangement or disputing bill; (ii) an SMS providing a second warning; and (iii) a third and final warning provided through a phone call made to landlords alerting them to pay within 48 hours or be disconnected. Compounds that do not make payment in this time will then be disconnected. Reconnection would be at the landlord/owner’s expense, and only after paying their outstanding service charges in full.
Experimental design
The identification strategy relies on a cluster-randomized experiment. All informal settlement customers in Nairobi Water’s utility database will first be called to confirm contact details and receive the base intervention. Eligibility criteria into the study will include: (i) customers can be contacted and their contact details can be updated; and (ii) customers do not hold multiple accounts (multiple property owners) – which is expected to yield an eligible sample size of approximately 5,500 customers. After the base intervention has been implemented and contact details have been updated, all compounds with tenants (approximately 2600 customers) will be randomly assigned to receive face-to-face tenant sensitization (Treatment 1). Randomization will be stratified by location (settlement), whether landlord resides in the property, and whether the landlord has ever made a payment. After completion of the outreach campaigns, all customers in the study will be grouped into clusters which will reflect the street they live on (approximately 166 clusters). Half of the clusters will be randomized into treatment and half into control, stratified by settlement and cluster size. Within treatment clusters, half of all compounds eligible for disconnection based on their balance and repayment history, will be randomly assigned to receive disconnection notices, resulting in approximately 420 compounds receiving notices and subsequently disconnected if they fail to make payment. To test for direct effects of receiving disconnection notices, we will compare disconnection treatment customers in treatment clusters to disconnection-eligible customers in control clusters. To test for spillovers, we will compare repayment rates of control customers in treatment clusters to disconnection-eligible customers in control clusters. To test the effectiveness of bottom-up accountability through increased tenant pressure in low and high enforcement settings, we will compare compounds with tenants that receive treatment 1 (tenant sensitization) to compounds with tenants that don’t receive the treatment, in disconnection vs. non-disconnection clusters, effectively estimating the interaction effect size of treatments 1 and 2.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.