Understanding the Impacts of a Civic Participation Initiative in Rwanda: Experimental Findings
How to cite
Nichols-Barrer, Ira. 2014. "Understanding the Impacts of a Civic Participation Initiative in Rwanda: Experimental Findings." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000352. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.352-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The Millennium Challenge Corporation sponsored the Rwanda Threshold Program (RTP) to help the Government of Rwanda improve its performance on governance indicators related to citizens’ political rights and civil liberties. Mathematica Policy Research conducted an evaluation of the RTP’s Strengthening Civic Participation (SCP) component, an initiative with two focus areas: (1) supporting the efforts of civil society organizations to advocate for local issues and (2) training local government officials to increase responsiveness to the concerns and priorities of citizens. The evaluation uses a stratified random assignment design, whereby districts within each of Rwanda’s five provinces were paired based on district population and economic characteristics and then randomly assigned to either a treatment or a control group. We designed a household survey to collect data for evaluating SCP impacts, and administered this survey at baseline before the program (in early 2011) and one year after the start of the program (2012). We drew nationally representative samples of approximately 10,000 households in each data collection round. The baseline and follow-up surveys collected data on respondents’ civic participation levels, including awareness and perceptions of local government performance, responsiveness, and accountability. Specifically, respondents were asked about their awareness of local government meetings, familiarity with local government officials, perceived citizen influence, and knowledge and access to information about local government affairs. Respondents were also asked about their overall satisfaction with government services related to water infrastructure, local road conditions, waste collection, public schools, and health clinics. We use this household survey data to analyze program impacts.
Intervention
The Strengthening Civic Participation (SCP) program was an initiative with two focus areas: (1) supporting the efforts of civil society organizations to advocate for local issues through grant support and technical assistance and (2) supporting the efforts of local government officials to increase responsiveness to the concerns and priorities of citizens through grant support and technical assistance.
Experimental design
The activities under the Strengthening Civic Participation component of the RTP were planned to be implemented in two separate, year-long phases, with 15 districts receiving activities in each phase. We took advantage of this plan by randomly dividing Rwanda’s 30 districts to either phase I or phase II. To do so, districts within each province were first matched in pairs or groups of three to ensure the best possible match between the two district groups. The districts were matched on the following five district characteristics:
• Population change between 2002 and 2006
• Population density
• Common Development Fund (CDF) appropriation amounts for FY 2008 (as a proxy for poverty levels)
• Share of district spending obtained through local revenues in FY 2008
• District expenditure per capita on good governance and social affairs
These matched district pairs or triplets were then used as randomization blocks. Specifically, after these blocks were created a public lottery was conducted in the presence of district officials to randomly assign districts within each block to the treatment group (districts that would receive program activities in phase I in 2011), or the control group (districts that were to receive program activities in phase II in 2012). The 15 control districts never received any program activities because the RTP was not extended beyond 2011.
Design details
Materials
Papers from this trial
- Mathematica. “Rwanda Threshold - Strengthening Justice and Promoting Political Rights: Final Analysis Report.” Washington, DC: Millennium Challenge Corporation, October 3, 2014. doi:https://doi.org/10.3886/9nys-5e23. https://mcc.icpsr.umich.edu/evaluations/index.php/catalog/1971/versions/V1.0.1
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.