The effects of parental involvement in financial literacy education. Evidence from a randomized experiment.

How to cite

Maldonado, Joana Elisa; Witte, Kristof De; Declercq, Koen. 2018. "The effects of parental involvement in financial literacy education. Evidence from a randomized experiment.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0003481. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3481-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Joana Elisa Maldonado* , Kristof De Witte , Koen Declercq

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0003481
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.3481-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2017-09-01 – 2018-12-31
Countries
Belgium (Europe)
JEL codes
C93, I21, O16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/3481

Abstract

Parents play an important role in the financial education of their children. We study the impact of parental involvement in financial education in secondary education in the Flemish region of Belgium. We evaluate the impact of innovative teaching material on means of payment and assess whether involving parents by means of a homework assignment affects students’ financial knowledge and behavior. The study is based on a randomized controlled trial with 67 schools and approximately 2,800 students. To estimate the causal effect of parental involvement, schools were randomly assigned to a treatment condition. We compare test scores of students in the treatment condition with parental involvement to those from a treatment condition with homework without parental involvement, as well as to a treatment condition without any homework and a control group.

Intervention

Schools are assigned to the following four experimental conditions:
1) Control group: Students do not follow the course on financial education.
2) Treatment group 1: Students follow the course on financial education.
3) Treatment group 2: Students follow the course on financial education and complete a homework assignment without their parents.
4) Treatment group 3: Students follow the course on financial education and complete a homework assignment together with one of their parents.

Experimental design

Schools that registered for participation were randomized to the aforementioned four experimental conditions. We assessed the level of financial literacy of all students before as well as after followed the course. Students assigned to the control group completed the same tests at the same time as students in the treatment groups, without following the course between the tests. The experiment was implemented in two waves: In the first wave, students in grade 8 (the second year of secondary education in Flanders, age 13-14) participated in the experiment. In the second wave, students in grade 9 (the third year of secondary education in Flanders age 14-15) participated, completing the same course and questionnaires.

Before the intervention, all students (control group + treatment groups) filled in an online questionnaire to test their financial literacy. Students also reported several personal characteristics like gender, school grades, and socio-economic background. Teachers in the treatment groups received the course material, including instructions for implementation, after all students filled in the questionnaire.
Approximately one month after filling in the first test, students in the treatment groups followed a 4-hour financial education course on means of payment. The course material was designed as a serious game and students had to solve questions on means of payment in groups of two students. Students could find the necessary information to solve the questions in a paper booklet that complemented the digital game. As incentive for good performance during the course, the winning team received a small present. All course material was developed by high school teachers with consideration for the age and the ability of the students.
In treatment groups 2 and 3 (see above), students had to complete a homework assignment before the start of the course. In treatment group 2, students did the homework without their parents. In treatment group 3, students did a variation of the homework assignment together with their parents.
At the end of the course, students filled in a test to measure financial knowledge and financial behavior. At the same time, students in the control group also filled in this test without having followed the course. This test was designed as variation of the first test, i.e. with questions analogous to the test students completed before the intervention.

Design details

Randomization method
Schools were randomly assigned to the different experimental conditions by a random number generator in Stata.
Randomization unit
In both waves, we randomized the treatment at school level. All students and teachers in the same school were assigned to the same condition. In this way, all teachers in the same school received the same teaching material and instructions in order to minimize the possibility of spill-over effects and contamination of the different treatment conditions.
Clusters
Given that the intervention has already been executed and data have been collected for both the pretest and the posttest, we report the actual number of students and schools for which we have observations for both the pretest and the posttest, i.e. the final sample for our analysis. The calculation of the minimal detectable effect size is also based on this final sample. Wave 1: 41 Wave 2: 25
Observations
Wave 1: 2,228 Wave 2: 551
Arms
Wave 1: grade 8 Control group = 739 pupils, 13 schools Treatment group 1 = 400 pupils, 9 schools Treatment group 2 = 598 pupils, 12 schools Treatment group 3 = 491 pupils, 7 schools Wave 2: grade 9 Control group = 111 pupils, 5 schools Treatment group 1 = 161 pupils, 7 schools Treatment group 2 = 124 pupils, 6 schools Treatment group 3 = 155 pupils, 7 schools Total sample Control group = 850 pupils, 18 schools Treatment group 1 = 561 pupils, 16 schools Treatment group 2 = 772 pupils, 18 schools Treatment group 3 = 646 pupils, 14 schools Average number of schools per condition = 16.5 Average number of pupils per condition = 707.25 Average number of pupils per school = 42.9
Primary outcomes
We measure financial literacy by a test that contains 13 questions. This test consists of questions that measure financial knowledge as well as financial behavior.

Papers from this trial

  1. Maldonado, J.E., De Witte, K., and Declercq, K. (2022). The Effects of Parental Involvement in Homework - Two Randomised Controlled Trials in Financial Education. Empirical Economics 62(3), 1439-1464. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00181-021-02058-8

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords